r/AskReddit • • 15h ago

What is something many people do while cooking that you think serves no purpose?

504 Upvotes

890 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.0k

u/PickleMortyCoDm 15h ago edited 3h ago

Oil in boiling water for your pasta. It doesn't stop your pasta sticking, stirring does. It only floats on the top and then gets poured away when you drain.

Edit: I feel it's only fair to mention that yes, I put a decent amount of salt in my water before boiling both pasta and potatoes. I should have mentioned that since it also increases the boiling point of the water and can cook things slightly better than without.

579

u/Capable_Delivery1006 15h ago

Man someone told me that a sprinkle of salt was worthless and they dumped a fuck ton in the water it made the pasta taste so much better lol

374

u/Itchy-Phase 14h ago

Correct, it’s more than most people think.

117

u/kbotc 14h ago

Yea, I found a place selling premeasured "Italian sea salt" for salting the water. I didn't buy the insane thing, but I did take the amounts they premeasured to heart.

16

u/ashcan_not_trashcan 12h ago edited 4h ago

Well... how much?

edit: Thank you for sharing!

47

u/kbotc 12h ago

It's ~1:10 by weight.

I usually add a heaping tablespoon of kosher salt for 4 US quarts. It should remind you of a broth if you taste it (Not salty like the sea)

33

u/StitchinThroughTime 11h ago

I add a scoop or 2 of chicken bullion to my water, adds flavor, salt and MSG.

26

u/baardvark 10h ago

Good idea, I have an MSG deficiency

2

u/procrastambitious 5h ago

My favourite comment in the whole thread

1

u/Phrosty12 2h ago

Yep. For home cooking (it was very different in the restaurant), I opt for 1 heaping tablespoon of iodized table salt per 2 quarts of water.

0

u/zigzackly 2h ago

‘Until it tastes like the sea.’

86

u/AstronomerIcy9695 12h ago

Boiling potatos in a shit ton of salt makes them really good too. Like more than you would for pasta, way more, like a concerning amount. Salt is cheap and you dump most of it out, but the high concentration seasons the potato all the way through.

41

u/thegloper 11h ago

Yup I worked with a girl from Syracuse and she simply referred to them as "salt potatoes". They come out super creamy too

14

u/DD163WALKER 10h ago

yep, salt potatoes are a NYer thing, specifically from Syracuse but they have spread West towards Buffalo. One of my favorite ways to cook potatoes, and then you get to dump a bunch of butter on them, very tastey.

24

u/Rubyhamster 10h ago

Just FYI, some potato types can dissolve in salted water! We have bred so many different types of potatoes so be sure to research or test before as is CAN become a very watery, salty potato mash

3

u/CFeatsleepsexrepeat 7h ago

Will use chicken stock to boil potatoes for mash sometimes. The flavour is sensational.

3

u/Kistelek 5h ago

Top tip if you make a sauce or soup too salty. Add a couple of halves of a peel potato in. The potato will absorb salt from the liquid.

2

u/AstronomerIcy9695 2h ago edited 2h ago

Oooo what a great tip. Thank you!

•

u/SeraphRising89 3m ago

They learned that from Archer. He made the spaghetti sauce too salty and Mallory didn't have a potato (it wasnt Christmas) to even out the salt level.

2

u/Atharaenea 9h ago

One time I managed to oversalt my potatoes. I'm pretty sure that I boiled them in a brine that was so salty it was oversaturated though.

Still better than no salt at all like my husband does. BLECH

1

u/AstronomerIcy9695 2h ago

Sometimes you gotta go too much to find out what is enough.

A saltless potato is like glue lol

91

u/kimmy_kimika 14h ago

You should always "over salt" the pasta! It adds so much flavor to the finished dish.

55

u/1600cc 13h ago

Just seasoning the water in general. I'll add herbs to the water that I know will mostly get poured out, but it really adds another dimension to the flavor.

Also I really enjoy boiling noodles in salty tabasco water for peppery and/or vodka sauces.
The spice doesn't really linger but you get a wonderfully light smoky pepper flavor penetrating the dish.

59

u/pmalleable 13h ago

If you want to take this a step further, I simmer my old Parmesan rinds, some garlic, onions, and peppercorns to make Parmesan stock and freeze it. Then I boil my pasta in the stock rather than water.

Try it, you're welcome in advance.

9

u/1600cc 13h ago

You have changed my life.
Thank you, in advance.

4

u/pmalleable 13h ago

Please do try it, and pass it on! I know nobody else who does this and it needs to spread.

4

u/1600cc 12h ago

I will be shouting your knowledge from the mountaintops!

11

u/Major-Grape-7690 12h ago

I have a buddy who smokes meat. He takes the fat drippings and add some to the pasta water for his smoked mac and cheese.

3

u/Sunshine_Window 8h ago

I want to try this!! How long do you simmer for?

1

u/pmalleable 3h ago

I don't have a set rule, but an hour is plenty of time. You can treat it just like making vegetable stock.

2

u/TheRandyBadger 10h ago

This feels illegal for some reason.

1

u/pmalleable 3h ago

Well, I've been doing this in my camper in New Mexico for a while and haven't been caught yet...

2

u/Tenebrumm 6h ago

That sounds like an interesting idea! We freeze all our leftover parmesan rinds and then add a few whenever we make a long-simmering bolognaise or ragu.

11

u/Laeryl 10h ago

Well, not "over salt" but for pasta, I have a rule : 1 / 10 / 100

1 liter of water, 10 grams of salt, 100 grams of pasta,

That's a trick an old nonna gave me.

6

u/MomentSpecialist2020 12h ago

Not for carbonara, you use some pasta water to make the sauce.

9

u/Nocritus 8h ago

I am the one who cooks in our family and I am together with my wife for 8 years.

When I make pasta and she sees my aalting the water she is still surprised and says : "This much salt?".

3

u/prodical 5h ago

Same thing happened a few years ago with my ex. Her pasta was coming out bland when she cooked it. I showed her how much salt to add and she was in disbelief that’s how much I had been using for years. She thought I was trying to kill her via heart attack.

2

u/FreudianSlipperyNipp 4h ago

I literally have to add the salt when my husband isn’t looking, otherwise he’ll experience an involuntary muscle spasm that makes him bitch about how much salt I’m using. Just go sit down, honey, and enjoy the meal ☺️

1

u/Bearded_Pip 3h ago

Different boiling, but when making mashed potatoes, I was taught to make the water for boiling the potatoes be as salty as the ocean. It is an aggressive, but correct amount of salt.

8

u/Coryball7 6h ago

“Salty like the sea.” My Italian MIL told me this about pasta water and she’s not wrong!

31

u/Practical_Tap_9592 15h ago

It should be as salty as the ocean.

40

u/noggin-scratcher 13h ago

That's the idiom, but it underestimates just how ridiculously salty actual seawater is.

Putting several tablespoons of salt into a small pan of water, to bring the salinity up to 3 or 4 percent, would genuinely be too much.

10

u/brickmaster32000 13h ago

Still an experiment I would advise people to try once. It really drives home how much of a difference it can make and you can dial down to reasonable amount after.

1

u/J_FROm 12h ago

Just so I get an idea... iI were to boil say 1 quart of water for pasta, about how many spoonfuls of salt should I put in? I know it's a rough estimate

5

u/BatDubb 12h ago

Measure with your heart.

7

u/joeboo5150 12h ago

153 at least

1

u/aksers 11h ago

Like a teaspoon for one quart. But that's not much water to boil in...

1

u/Ran4 10h ago

Quart? Wtf

9

u/Welpe 11h ago

I was about to complain about this commonly repeated phrase because it’s so nonsense. And untrue. Properly salted boil water should be 0.5-1% salt. Thats 10g of salt per liter, or for fellow Americans it’s about a tablespoon per 2 quarts if using Diamond Crystal and a teaspoon per quart if you use Morton.

The ocean is way saltier than people realize. At 3.5% salinity you need to dump in 7 tablespoons of Diamond Crystal salt for a gallon of water, and that’s completely inedible and will ruin pasta.

Do not make it as salty as the ocean. But you may need to use more salt than you think, people putting a single pinch of salt into a massive amount of water are being stupid. Unless you have high blood pressure or other heart issues and need a low sodium diet, most people should be using more salt in their home kitchen if they want food to actually taste good.

1

u/ILikeLenexa 4h ago

If I'm making 30 people spaghetti, I salt the water; if I'm making 4 people spaghetti, I just salt the noodles at the end.  

But, hey, Salt's cheap,so do whatever. 

1

u/Linubidix 2h ago

There is definitely a limit though.

The phrase "salty as the sea" has lead to me making one or two horrible bowls of pasta.

1

u/FunctionBuilt 11h ago

Yeah, it’s like a handful.

0

u/Theletterkay 11h ago

Salty like the sea. Anything less and you are just wasting salt.

99

u/Strikerjroar1 15h ago

Well, thats not actually why you do it though. Oil in the water floats to the top and helps resists the protein foam boilover. There's other methods for that too though, laying a wooden spoon along the top of the pot can do the trick. Or I guess you can always watch the water boil.

52

u/knoxblox 14h ago

Or just dont overheat your pasta water. Boil over comes from a rolling boil making bubbles. Once the pasta is in just drop the heat to medium and it wont foam at all. Pasta doesn't cook better in water that is at a full boil, and it could be argued it cooks worse

45

u/Gr8fulFox 13h ago edited 10h ago

I actually learned this from a textbook written in the 1920s; water at a rolling boil is no hotter than at a gentle boil; it's 212 degrees at atmospheric pressure, regardless, so you're just using more fuel and wasting water by keeping it at a rolling boil the whole time.

ETA: It was this book, The Science of Common Things.

10

u/Strikerjroar1 13h ago

Thats correct... the temperature is what does the cooking. gentle vs rolling boil just refers to the amount of heat or cooking pressure applied that accelerates the conversion of water of the steam which doesnt do anything to cooktime other than steaming up your kitchen. Has 0% to do with cooking quality though.
You cannot overheat a boil, well, until you run out of water.

•

u/thisusernameismeta 34m ago

Thing is on my stove there seems to be just two settings: not hot enough to keep a boil going, and intense rolling boil. Getting the temp right for a gentle boil might be possible but I haven't figured out the trick of it yet and it is just easier to keep it at a rolling boil than to turn it down and then realize the water stopped boiling 5 minutes ago when I go check on it.

0

u/Ran4 10h ago

Water ain't gonna get 212 degrees...

-2

u/Bigtits38 12h ago

Or, don’t boil your pasta. There is no need to.

11

u/edgeplot 12h ago

The oil prevents the water from boiling over.

4

u/prodical 5h ago

If the water is threatening to boil over, you either used too much water, or a pot which is too small. Less water is better for pasta as you want some of that starchy water at the end for emulsifying the sauce. Too much water in the pot and the water isn’t very starchy.

2

u/edgeplot 1h ago

Or you just add a couple drops of oil and you don't have to worry about how big the pot was.

-1

u/prodical 1h ago

I agree that is a savvy trick if you fuck up basic water skills.

7

u/StaticVoidMain2018 9h ago

It sounds like people just the oil for boil over prevention. But to me this isn’t worth the end result of slippy pasta that doesn’t stick to my pasta’s sauce

7

u/faceless_nameless1 15h ago

I put a little oil in the pasta water to help keep it from boiling over, and it works.

17

u/knoxblox 14h ago

You have water boiling over because your heat is too high. Once the pasta releases starch the bubbles formed from a rapid boil dont pop as easily and build up, leading to boil over. The thing is, you shouldn't be cooking your pasta at a full boil. You turn the heat to high to get the water to boiling, but once you add the pasta you can turn down the flame to medium. A consistent simmer and regular stiring is all you need.

I have never had pasta water even begin bubbling, much less boil over, and it cooks the exact same. Perfect al dente every time and with less risk of scalding steam or overcooked pasta

-8

u/DigNitty 13h ago

The water boils over before we’re putting the pasta in.

10

u/WildPotential 12h ago

What else is in the water? How much headspace is in your pot? I have never had water boil over that doesn't have food in it. Plain water or salt water won't foam up the way water with pasta (or potatoes, etc) in it will.

So I can only imagine that you have the pot so full that there's not enough space for even a rolling boil of plain water. But in that case, oil won't help.

4

u/knoxblox 12h ago

Then your heat is WAY too high. Also, a rolling boil makes bubbles, but they dont "froth" like pasta water bubbles do. How are you boiling over before adding the pasta unless the water is like, filled all the way to the lip of the pan?

1

u/luluhouse7 7h ago

It sounds like too much water. Most people think you need a ton of water (including me) but my partner insisted it would be fine, pulled up a bunch of chefs that tested it and really you actually want the least amount of water possible to cover it because then the pasta water has a higher starch concentration, which if you mix a spoonful into whatever sauce you’re using, helps it emulsify and stick to the pasta.

1

u/SunShineNomad 12h ago

You're staying too much water then.

5

u/askmrlucky 12h ago

That may work, but the downside of sauces not adhering as well to the finished pasta would lead me to the other ways of not boiling over, like using a larger pot with the water not so close to the top.

1

u/indehhz 12h ago

I thought the oil is for once it’s been boiled and drained..

10

u/OnlyOneGoodSock 11h ago

I was taught not to put olive oil on cooked pasta because it makes it harder for the pasta to hold onto your sauce. You should be cooking your pasta so that it finishes after your sauce and the two can be mixed immediately after draining.

2

u/indehhz 10h ago

Oh I see makes sense, I hadn't heard of the olive oil when boiling it before though. I never bothered oiling it after I drained my pasta anyway so laziness wins..? haha

2

u/Legionof1 14h ago

Dunno, works for me. I have to stir constantly to keep it from clumping if I don’t but if I put some oil in then pour the pasta over it, no sticking. I just let it boil and stir once when it softens to get it all under water.

3

u/Delcasa 11h ago

All you need to do is stir once the pasta is in the boiling water and loosen it all up. After that it won't clump. Also without oil

-3

u/Legionof1 10h ago

Nah, especially once it's drained, with no oil its all clump.

•

u/thelionofthenorth 57m ago

I use the oil too for similar reasons to you but if it clumps a lot after cooking it's usually because it's overcooked

1

u/d0rf47 14h ago

This actually does help with water boiling over tho 

1

u/CodyHodgsonAnon19 6h ago

A drip of olive oil in pasta absolutely serves a purpose. It stops it boiling over. And dump a ton of salt in that pot for really good pasta too.

1

u/SpicyNacho74 5h ago

It stops the water from boiling over the pot.

1

u/Tackit286 3h ago

Not to mention it also stops all that lovely sauce from sticking to it nicely!

1

u/Ruadhan2300 3h ago

The purpose of oil in the water is to break up starchy foam bubbles that might otherwise overflow the pot.

Salt is the only seasoning I add that is intended to flavor the pasta, and I swear by it.

1

u/Bearded-and-Bored 1h ago

True, it does nothing to the pasta at all. But it does dramatically cut down on starch foam. So it can prevent foamy boil overs...or you can just turn the heat down or use a bigger pot.

•

u/Cndcrow 19m ago

It doesnt actually cook your food any noticeable amount better, but it does add an extra layer of seasoning. By adding salt to your water you might increase the temperature by a miniscule amount, but it realistically doesnt change how it cooks

-4

u/West_Abroad1817 15h ago

Oil in the water helps it from clumping after it's cooked as well as adding flavor. The you can use your pasta water to bind your sauce. I pour the oil in the water and on the pasta after if it's going to sit in the fridge.

2

u/ohyouretough 11h ago

You shouldn’t add oil to the water especially if you’re trying to use the water to emulsify.

1

u/West_Abroad1817 4h ago

I do it all the time and my sauces are tight, despite what Google says. Hahaha!

2

u/luluhouse7 7h ago

Adding oil prevents the sauce from emulsifying properly and adhering to the pasta.

0

u/MaddoxJKingsley 8h ago

My main reason for not doing it is simply to make cleaning the pot + strainer + spoon a teeny tiny bit easier to wash afterward... because I'm lazy and touching oil is gross

-1

u/ravia 11h ago

I think the main idea is that it stops it from foaming. If you are making a ton of pasta in a limited size pot, it will foam and oil will stop it.