r/BeAmazed • • 6h ago

Skill / Talent How was this all calculated?

11.5k Upvotes

925 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

23

u/Reasonable_Archer_99 5h ago

We won't ever be able to go very far into space for a few reasons. Space, or rather the galaxies, are expanding away from eachother at about 1,300,000 mph. So even if we could somehow do the speed of light, you'd never catch up to most of the observable universe. We'll likely never leave the Milky Wayn

15

u/captnkurt 4h ago

Milky Wayn was my pornstar name.

2

u/BlkSubmarine 3h ago

Really? Mine was Milky Wang.

1

u/LLLowEEE 3h ago

Favorite comment today. Had to screenshot, highlight and send to the group chat. Thanks 🫶🏻

13

u/ScratchLatch 4h ago

Galactic space-travel is within the galaxy. That’s already possible over long time scales. Intergalactic travel between galaxies is unlikely for those reasons.

2

u/Reasonable_Archer_99 4h ago

It is problematic even within the Milky Way has a diameter of 100,000 light-years. We're in the middle-ish of one of the arms. It's not likely we ever leave the arm we're in.

9

u/poiskdz 3h ago

Well not with that attitude.

3

u/Blackhawk510 2h ago

I mean shit, pretty much all of the halo universe takes place within the orion arm, so it's not like even a single arm isn't pretty fantastical.

1

u/PM_ME_DATASETS 12m ago

Why would that be unlikely? Ignoring human problems like self-destruction. Given enough fuel, couldn't a spaceship easily pick up enough speed for significant time dilation, then GTFO of the galaxy?

•

u/6a6566663437 8m ago

That’s already possible over long time scales.

No, it really isn't. Humans do not do well in low gravity for extended periods of time. We do not have a remotely practical way to artificially generate gravity.

Spinning the ship would require a gigantic diameter, which would require massive weight, which means moving it through space requires too much fuel (which requires even more fuel to move the fuel).

And we haven't even started touching on the problems we've run into trying to create sealed biosystems.

These may be addressable in the future, but we very much can not move people in generation ships now.

9

u/GeneralKang 3h ago

1000 years ago, humans couldn't cross oceans.

200 years ago, humans couldn't fly.

100 years ago, it was impossible to visit the Moon.

50 years ago, visiting Mars was something only a robot could do, and it wouldn't last long.

Now, after 50 years, we're going back to the Moon, this time to establish a base.

If humans can survive the next 1000 years without going through another dark age, we'll be able to leave the Solar System. In another 1000, we'll be able to navigate our spiral arm, maybe even the Milky Way Galaxy. It's just a matter of time, innovation and progress.

5

u/MrRourkeYourHost 2h ago

We should stop fighting each other and start preparing for war with the Klingons. It’s only a matter of time.

1

u/EvilWarBW 1h ago

That's ridiculous. The Klingons aren't our enemy. The enemy is clear. Romulans.

6

u/Reasonable_Archer_99 3h ago

Maybe, but we're also far more aware of our limitations now.

4

u/OGCelaris 3h ago

At each of those steps we understood our limitations. That's why we found ways around them.

3

u/Reasonable_Archer_99 2h ago

The light barrier is mathematically impossible and even if you could achieve it, nothing with mass can go the speed of light and even if it could, the speed on light is too slow. You'd need to exceed the speed of light by an order of magnitude to get anywhere in a timely manner.

2

u/Karatechoppingaction 2h ago

That's what tearing holes in reality is for. Nothing could go wrong with that.

0

u/OGCelaris 2h ago

That is where the Einstein-Rosen bridge comes in. We may not know how to make them yet but that doesn't mean it's impossible.

0

u/PM_ME_DATASETS 11m ago

You're being downvoted because it's impossible according to our current knowledge

1

u/OGCelaris 10m ago

Thats why I said yet

1

u/awkreddit 2h ago

Yup just because a sf novel said something doesn't mean it has to happen somehow

1

u/SOMETHINGCREATVE 3h ago

Who exactly is trying to establishing a moon base? Please don't say Elon and the maga dipshits I can't today

1

u/Jesus_of_Redditeth 1h ago

If humans can survive the next 1000 years without going through another dark age, we'll be able to leave the Solar System.

The only way we'll be able to legit leave the solar system is if we somehow discover a technological solution to the distance problem. Literal FTL travel is physically impossible for us; even close to FTL travel is just totally infeasible. If we discover a way to warp space-time to get around FTL travel and traverse vast distances without actually physically moving that fast (think: wormholes) then that would make it possible. But right now that's just an idea on paper. Otherwise, it's just never going to happen no matter how long our species manages to to keep existing. At least not unless and until we get out of these flesh sacks and turn ourselves into silicon-based life. But then if we did that, we wouldn't be human anymore, so what would be the point?

•

u/PM_ME_DATASETS 8m ago

Sorry are you saying we can't visit another star without faster than light travel? Why would that be the case?

2

u/Krell356 2h ago

I mean, that's assuming we never make any groundbreaking discoveries. Stuff that sounded impossible a single generation ago is daily life now. All it would take is finding out teleportation, folding space, etc. is a real possibility to completely change that.

Not saying it's a reasonable assumption, but it is still a non-zero chance at this point.

1

u/nifty-necromancer 3h ago

Even if we could travel FTL, we’ll never leave the Milky Way

1

u/DisasterEqual1703 3h ago

We'll get the entire local cluster if we survive. Outside of that is generally heading away, inside is coalescing.

1

u/PM_ME_DATASETS 16m ago

We won't ever be able to go very far into space for a few reasons.

You fail to mention any of those reasons, nor do you specify "very far" (imho we've already gone "very far" like 50 years ago)

Space, or rather the galaxies, are expanding away from eachother at about 1,300,000 mph.

False. The rate of expansion depends on the distance between two points

So even if we could somehow do the speed of light, you'd never catch up to most of the observable universe.

The speed of light is much higher than 1.3 Mmph, and there's also the benefit of time dilation. Sure we'll never "catch up to most of the observable universe", but that was never mentioned as a goal, and it's definitely a far stretch from "go very far into space".

We'll likely never leave the Milky Wayn

Given enough fuel, leaving the Milky Wayn will be trivial

1

u/hollywood_imagery0 3h ago

With our current understanding of Physics no but we’re actually progressing absurdly fast in terms of technological advancement, we went from the Wright Brothers first flight to landing on the moon in less than 60 years, From no electricity to absolutely insanely powerful A.I. in less than 200. who knows what we may accomplish in the next 100 years

1

u/Below-Average-528 2h ago

Speed of light is a pretty hard limit so far. There is really nothing on the horizon to get around that. I am sure we will continue to improve our tech within the current limits. But for interstellar travel we need something totally new.