r/CriticalThinkingIndia • • 11h ago

Philosophy, Ethics & Dharma "Doesn't your daughter not have any Hindu friends? Why is she with a Muslim boy" - Hindutva goons ask Hindu girl's parents during Dandiya Night.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

These goons never show up when it comes to demanding justice for Hindu Girls like Ankita Bhandari. And why are the police standing and not doing anything while propels liberties are being violated?

Translation: The girl requests them to not film her. The man with the camera says he will not film her but film the boy and the man on call. The man talking on the phone finds out the mother knows. He lectures her mother to not come to him if her daughter falls victim to Love Jihad.

The call is interrupted by another call. He says on the 2nd call that he has caught many non-Hindus. He tells the caller to stop the event. The girl is apologizing to the boy.

He continues the call. It is revealed that the boy is like her brother. The girl is insisting on not taking the boy to the police. The man then says that it is goddess's festival and they should not have sent a Muslim boy.

The man then calls the tent guy.

https://x.com/RajatJain/status/2111190742630871345

2.8k Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/Fearless_Answer_4278 10h ago

The place is not secular in nature. She went against the rules, they were wrong to moral police her but she did broke the rules.

7

u/user0987777 10h ago

If she broke rules, call police why are they calling her parents?

Or these idiots believe women are properties of their fathers?

Why didn't they call father of that muslim man?

Most importantly when there own members were saying "we buy girls in 300" where was this attitude? Or hindu girls should only be protected from men of a particular religion otherwise they themselves should have rights to do whatever they want.

4

u/Fearless_Answer_4278 10h ago

Every child is a responsibility of their parents till they become independent. Man or a woman doesn’t make a difference.

3

u/user0987777 10h ago

Read constitution, if she's 18+ then she has rights to live her life.

If it's really not about gender show me videos of them calling parents of Hindu men for having muslim girlfriends.

They usually support that calling it "ghar waapsi" it's funny when we actually compare and see how similar both religions are when women are involved.

4

u/Fearless_Answer_4278 10h ago

That is also wrong, but the fact is Muslim women aren’t desperate to come to garba, in fact they are not even allowed by their religion.
It’s a religious place not a Hindu Muslim tinder.

3

u/user0987777 10h ago

They are not "allowed" because of their men.

You still have not answered my question

3

u/Fearless_Answer_4278 10h ago

Are they? Fatwa nikal jayega agar allow kr diya.
It’s strictly haram!

2

u/user0987777 10h ago

Unhi ke fatwe se inspiration le rahe hain na RW goons bhi?

Ye help unka fatwa hatwane mein kyu nhi ho pa rahi if they wish to protect women?

2

u/Fearless_Answer_4278 10h ago

What fatwa? Women attend dandiya freely, no one is stopping them.
But if a Muslim man is stopped all of sudden it’s a big deal. Do your Hindu Muslim tinder outside.

2

u/user0987777 10h ago

Stop being so obsessed with muslims, the Muslim guy is not even the point. Do whatever you want with him, arrest him beat him or do whatever but why the hell is moral policing a woman allowed?

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Born_You4703 10h ago

It’s not because of their men .
It’s because it’s strictly against their religious teachings .

1

u/user0987777 10h ago

That religion is created by men only.

2

u/Born_You4703 10h ago

And their woman follow it with free will , they aren’t necessarily forced .

1

u/train-gone-69 10h ago

she have right to live her "own life" dosent mean she have right to make other's girls life more vulnerable, ur sick man

1

u/Born_You4703 10h ago edited 10h ago

Pretty sure practising Muslim women won’t come to garbha or temples .

2

u/user0987777 10h ago

Actually many do, it's okay if you can't show video in this specific situation then show any other case of them harassing a hindu man for having muslim girlfriend.

When are men of both sides going to stop using religion as an excuse for their misogyny?

1

u/Born_You4703 10h ago

It’s 100 percent haram if u are a practising Muslim . Sooo

1

u/user0987777 10h ago

I don't care about what's haram in their so called religion.

There have been cases, if muslim women are gfs of hindu women they actually support it just like misogynistic muslims become liberal when they want hindu girlfriend but won't allow their own women to even stay without burkha.

0

u/Fearless_Answer_4278 10h ago

You will see my comments under those videos opposing those idiots and goons as well.
What do you want? Directly call the police on the girl?

3

u/user0987777 10h ago

Ofcourse, if she broke rules call police. Calling parents in this situation is useless unless they know that she did not commit any crime so they can't call police.

That's how things are handled in a secular country.

Btw who's giving them authority of doing all this?

2

u/Fearless_Answer_4278 10h ago

Organisers have rights to decide who can enter and who can’t. Don’t know about these guys but if Muslims are not allowed then simply means you should not be found there otherwise be ready for consequences. BTW why aren’t Muslim women allowed to pray in a lot of mosques? They are not even allowed in graveyards.

2

u/user0987777 10h ago

Because islam is the most misogynistic religion and their women already suffer because of that we don't wish to see hindu women having similar state.

Answer my question, why didn't they call police?

Another question in how many cases have they called parents of Hindu men for having relationship with muslim women?

1

u/Fearless_Answer_4278 10h ago

Look I’m not keeping any track. You don’t want Hindus women to be in that state still you are trying to defend the boy entering garba?
Why did he enter?
My cousin was my morally policed for having a Muslims GF because that conversion thing always comes in between and we didn’t want anyone sort of conversion of anyone.

1

u/user0987777 10h ago

I want all women to have freedom to have their choices. My stance doesn't depend upon any religion that's why when these idiots use religion as their shield it's pathetic.

You claim to hate muslims they why do you wish to become like them when women are involved?

1

u/Fearless_Answer_4278 10h ago

I don’t hate anyone.
Women can do whatever they want, but in most cases they end converting to Islam, which is something that is polar opposite of Islam.

1

u/user0987777 10h ago

Then even that's their choice. They're not harming anyone, many women also leave islam would you call them wrong too?

Ideally all women should be anti religion but they're not.

→ More replies (0)

-2

u/Born_You4703 10h ago

Useless ?
You know nothing about Indian parents then .

2

u/user0987777 10h ago

If constitution says that a woman above 18 is an adult then she is really an adult. It doesn't matter what indian parents have to say in this case.

-1

u/Born_You4703 10h ago

Yeah , unfortunately in India most 18 year olds are dependent on their parents for everything .
You can’t enroll yourself into a collage or get an education loan without their sign .

1

u/user0987777 10h ago

This is only valid in case of women for some reason right?

1

u/Born_You4703 10h ago

No , even for boys .
Even boys are dependent.

1

u/user0987777 10h ago

So his parents were called?

→ More replies (0)

5

u/Born_You4703 10h ago edited 10h ago

Exactly ,
You won’t see a Hindu entering a mosque during their special prayers , we all know it’s not appropriate .
Somehow we are expected to open all doors for religious events .
The issue here is both of these ppl know the facts and still chose to be deceptive .

5

u/user0987777 10h ago

If what did is a crime, why didn't they call police?

Why did they call her parents?

I don't give a damn about both hinduism and islam, but if they won't stop controlling women because their religion says so don't expect people to stay silent. We don't wish to become next Pakistan where all this is tolerated.

3

u/Spreaky 10h ago

against the rules

Which rules? Who decides that?

2

u/Fearless_Answer_4278 10h ago

The Hindus who organised this festival and the event.

4

u/Spreaky 10h ago

The Hindus who organised the garba had no issue and gave no objection but some random dude from some Hindu organisation started to moral police about breaking non-existent rules