r/MarvelMidnight • u/Careless-Raccoon-490 • 10d ago

Discussion How would you rank the titles?

Mine (worst to best)

  1. Midnight Fantastic Four

  2. Midnight X-men

  3. Midnight Spider-man

4 Upvotes

84% Upvoted

11 comments sorted by

5

u/prose4jose 10d ago

Agree with your ranking.

4

u/PatienceDifficult344 7d ago
  1. Xmen
  2. FF
  3. Spiderman

3

u/thenycstraightboi 8d ago

Best: X-Men. Vampires and mutants what could be better

FF. Looks like some lovecraftian shit is gonna go down and I’m excited for what comes next.

Worst: Spider-Man. The art just doesn’t do it for me, and while I don’t mind a setup issue I would have liked for something to happen before the last 2 pages.That being said, I could see this as having the best potential

1

u/DrTechPop 4d ago

Yes, thank you. Finally someone calling out this first issue of M Spiderman.

2

u/Ok_Wash511 10d ago

F4 Spiderman Xmen

2

u/midnight_spiderman 10d ago

Spider-man, Fantastic four, X-men (best to bad)

2

u/OrchidAutomatic574 8d ago

  1. X-men

  2. Spider-Man

  3. Fantastic Four

2

u/DisastrousYou4931 7d ago

X Men at #1 for sure (:

3

u/Yeah_Mr_Jesus 7d ago

I think they're all really good. I think they're all doing a good job of setting up the story so far. I'm terms of quality, I think they're all so close that it's not really useful to try to rank them in terms of quality. I can only rank them in terms of my preferences.

I'm not a big horror movie type of guy, but I do enjoy horror literature. I've never really looked at horror comic books before, so this is more or less my introduction to horror comics.

All that being said, I'd say my favorite is Fantastic Four followed by X-Men and then Spiderman.

Sci-Fi is my favorite genre of anything. Literatur, movies, tv, comics. It makes sense that my favorite would be the sci-fi/cosmic horror book. I also like the angle of Reed's addiction. Sue being a shadowy, sketchy corporate type is pretty cool too.

I like vampire fiction a lot! Vampire powers combined with Mutant powers is really cool to me. I'm not Catholic (or religious in any way) anymore, but at one point in my life, I was in the seminary studying to be a Catholic priest, so the church aspect is compelling to me. Stryker seems to be more or less cool with mutant bishop nightcrawler, so I'm guessing his fanatical hatred in this version is focused to vampires and empyres. I'm also really excited to see how the dynamic between nightcrawler and storm pans out

And spiderman. Icky stuff. Terrifying. Gross as hell. I think it's cool but holy shit is it hard to look at lol. I'm interested to see how Peter being the direct reason uncle Ben died pans out. I also think that uncle Ben turns into that gross ass spider growing out of Peter's chest. That guilt is going to eat at him (literally it seems). He's also going to have to come to terms with his hypocrisy being the root of his problems.

All in all, they are compelling titles! I'm subscribed to them. Like I said, I think they're all very close in terms of quality. I very much enjoyed them all! My only reason for ranking them is personal preference.

1

u/Tippydaug 6d ago

Midnight Spider-Man > Midnight Fantastic Four > Midnight X-Men

However, in terms of what I look forward to the most from what we've seen it's:

Midnight Fantastic Four > Midnight Spider-Man > Midnight X-Men

1

u/DrTechPop 4d ago

I agree except your ranking is exactly upside down, s/b best to worst, which means we agree on M X-men