Iām looking for some outside perspectives on a career decision and would appreciate some honest opinions. Iām deliberately keeping the details vague because I want to remain anonymous.
Iāve spent a significant part of my career in consulting, working around business performance, planning and related areas. Iāve generally enjoyed the field and have had a good career so far, but lately Iāve started feeling increasingly tired of the consulting environment.
The main issue isnāt necessarily the subject matter itself, but the way the work is structured. There is a lot of variety, but also a constant rotation between projects, changing priorities, short deadlines and pressure to deliver quickly. I have a fairly senior role and there is still room for career progression, but Iām starting to question whether I actually want to continue moving further in that direction.
One thing I particularly value about my current position is the flexibility. I work remotely and have a lot of control over how I organize my time. That has become a significant part of my quality of life.
I now have an opportunity to move to an industry role with a company I have some professional connection with. The position would be more of a specialist/strategic role rather than a traditional management position.
What attracts me is the possibility of going much deeper into a complex business area. Instead of continuously moving between relatively short projects, I would have the opportunity to work on a larger, more complex solution over a longer period, develop deeper expertise, and gain significantly more understanding of the business side.
There would still be project work and stakeholder management, so it wouldnāt necessarily be a quiet job. But I expect the nature of the work to be more long-term and potentially more intellectually satisfying.
The main downside is that I would lose a significant amount of my current flexibility. The new role requires regular office attendance and involves a fairly long commute (3 hours both ways twice a week). Financially, the two options are broadly comparable, although the compensation structures are different: the consulting position has a meaningful variable component, while the industry role is almost entirely fixed. The industry position also offers somewhat better vacation/leave conditions.
So Iām essentially weighing:
Staying in consulting
\-Excellent flexibility and remote working
\-Good compensation and career progression
\-Variety and exposure to many different topics
\-But increasingly feeling tired of the constant project cycle
\-Frequent deadlines and changing priorities
\-Less opportunity to develop deep expertise in one business area
Moving in-house
\-More predictable compensation
\-Somewhat better vacation/leave conditions
\-Opportunity to develop much deeper expertise
\-Greater exposure to the actual business rather than always being an external advisor
\-Potentially more long-term ownership and intellectual depth
\-But significantly less flexibility
\- A substantial commute (
\- Potentially a less straightforward management/career path
Iām struggling particularly with the fact that both options are objectively quite good. Iām not trying to escape a bad employer; Iām wondering whether I should trade some of the lifestyle advantages I currently have for a different type of career experience.
For those who have moved from consulting into an internal specialist or strategic role:
Did you find that moving in-house gave you more depth and a better long-term career, or did you eventually miss the variety, flexibility and pace of consulting?
And how much would you personally value remote flexibility when the alternative potentially offers more meaningful work and deeper expertise?
Iām especially interested in hearing from people who have made a similar transition and later looked back on the decision with some perspective.