r/comics • • Aug 28 '26

OC Gender Ew-Phoria [OC]

13.9k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.4k

u/Mckavvers Aug 28 '26

as a person who grew up around a lot of English people and interacts with a lot of elderly via work none of these terms of endearment are a problem for me. It entirely depends on the tone and context of it been said.

330

u/Nitrogenflux Aug 28 '26

See also - being called 'duck' as a totally normal way to refer to a women or man you don't know lol

1

u/Linix332 Aug 28 '26

Had to spend a few months in Newfoundland and got called Ducky so many times. I'm a 30's large bearded dude. Was a wild time.

2

u/EjaculatingAracnids Aug 28 '26

I just use "ma'am" or "sir" for services and pleasantries in passing. Idc how old you are, im not calling a young girl "sweetheart" cause its way weirder. Duck is cool though. I could see using it like "dude" if im in a conversation with women who i want to assure im not interested in.

3

u/karl2025 Aug 28 '26

It's just a different culture. It's only weird if you don't grow up in it.

1

u/EndlessSiren Aug 28 '26

It evolved from the word Duke interestingly enough. I forgot how weird I must've sounded to people not from the area. Duck? Where? Lol

87

u/Lanky_Giraffe Aug 28 '26

Also in this context, they’re not really gendered in my experience. Maybe sweetheart. But I’ve been called darling and love a bunch by older women and I’m very obviously a dude. Never got it from men though so I wouldn’t be surprised if there is a gendered component when older men use them. 

29

u/LawyerEnjoyer Aug 28 '26

Sweetheart definitely isn't gendered either. As a British guy, I've had many old ladies say "thank you, sweetheart" to me over the years.

11

u/ObscureOP Aug 28 '26

Do other British guys call you sweetheart?

2 way gendered is still gendered

2

u/ChristopherRubbin Aug 28 '26

As someone from a super British family yes that does happen. I get called "my love" "love" and "darling" from a male British customer all the time once he found out I was from there. For clarity im a dude.

3

u/UnstableSuccubus Aug 28 '26

I've heard it both ways. I met an old man who referred to me neutrally, calling me a person with neutral terms. Then after he got my gender right he exclusively referred to me as a "lovely lady," "sweetheart," etc. Before I was just a plain person, afterwards I felt like he was trying to set me up as something smaller. There was a definite before and after for him that I don't see very often.

2

u/karl2025 Aug 28 '26

It's gendered in who can use the term with whom. Women can use it with men, men can use it with women, women can use it with other women, men can't use it with other men.

1

u/CheaterInsight Aug 28 '26

My Australian grandmother says "Ta love" every time she thanks someone. Plenty of older women running small businesses in my town use all of the terms/words in this post. Wouldn't shock me if men exclusively use them with women, but they ARE very normal in a lot of cases.

1

u/Visual-Scallion1535 Aug 28 '26

Im pretty sure thats the joke?

These are things female service workers typically say to men, and the comic is pointing out its strange when the genders are reversed

1

u/lilybug981 Aug 28 '26

Older men can use terms of endearment for younger women, but it is definitely context dependent. If an older man was making a pass at a younger woman, any term of endearment will just intensify the bad vibe and it will always sound creepy no matter which term is used. Sweetheart does seem to be the term people overall find to be the most uncomfortable.

However, when their interactions are normal, something like, "Thank you, dear," is just an older man addressing a younger woman and nothing more. The more familiar the pair are, the more unremarkable it is. Personally, I am the only woman in my department at work, and I'm also the youngest. My coworkers all seem to notice keenly when a term of endearment towards me is weird vs when it is not. Whether it's a stranger or someone from another department, my coworkers always remark upon it derisively after the guy leaves, but only when I also thought it seemed off. So even without experiencing it directly, men do seem to be able to feel the ick too, if they're around to hear it when it's weird.

30

u/ScissorFight42069 Aug 28 '26

There are still rules though. Old men don't call each other "my love." Neither do young men, or any combo of men.

Older women might call a younger woman that, but will use it much less often we ith other old women. Young women typically do not do it amongst themselves either.

1

u/ilo_Va Aug 28 '26

I call my friends sweetheart all the time, though it's to piss them off but I do it

2

u/paulinaiml Aug 28 '26

When I'm a bit confused on what pronouns use I use endearing them respectfully, and it has seemingly worked.

5

u/Majestic-Iron7046 Aug 28 '26

Absolutely! Old lady saying "Thanks dear" if I help her out? Not an issue.
Weird creep at my workplace calling underaged girls dearie and hoping I play along? Fucking disgusting, I hope he died under the faulty machinery that we had to fix everyday.

1

u/PhoenixHavoc Aug 28 '26

Honestly so real

1

u/bronzelifematter Aug 29 '26

Usually older people use it, so I take it as a sign of friendliness. Would be weird if someone my age use it on me.

1

u/Phantion- Aug 28 '26

Thank god for context, if only more people used Context.

0

u/Speartree Aug 28 '26

That right luv.

-1

u/XenonFyre Aug 28 '26

Yeah, forgive me in advance, but where do we draw the line on validating people’s discomfort? A lot of these terms, regionally, are not gender-specific at all nor contextually sexual or invasive.

This post kinda feels like choosing to instigate a “social yellow light”, like “mmmm guys do we think this is problematic” just for the sake of it.