Hey all, I'm after some fall/winter recommendations, or anything warm that works in the cold. Fair warning: I'm picky.
I've always leaned fresh (see my collection). My all-time favourite is Creed Aventus Absolu (although kinda prefer the Afnan Supremacy Collector's Edition). Now I want a really nice warm scent for the colder months, and I'm struggling.
I want something loud, not what’ll fizzle into skin scent quickly.
What I can't stand:
Boozy: Kilian Angels' Share is a hard no. It smells like straight cognac, and I can't do alcohol notes.
Incense/frankincense: most Amouage just isn't for me.
Dark and heavy: Blonde Amber and anything in that vibe. Too heavy and dark.
Leathery: Lattafa Musamam. I know it got super popular, but it was way too leathery for me.
Floral and spicy: Brompton Immortals didn't work for me either.
Plain vanilla: I recently picked up Drunk Lovers and Liquid Brun, and honestly they just smell like straight vanilla to me. Dead boring.
Edible scents: stuff like Oajan that smells straight up like a bakery or cinnamon. I don’t wanna smell like a dessert.
Smokey / tobacco: Find Naxos genuinely atrocious.
What I actually like:
Stronger With You Intensely
Afnan 9PM Night Out
Babylon Penhaligon’s
Montale Arabians Tonka: probably my favourite warm scent right now, but it's not very work friendly. And I don’t want anything Middle Eastern-leaning now.
Terre d'Hermès Eau Intense Vétiver: LOVE it, but I'm not after another vetiver since I already have Bois Impérial, which scratches a similar itch. I also have a Dior Homme Intense dupe.
So basically I want something warm, cosy and masculine that isn't boozy, smoky, incense-heavy, tobacco-y or super dark.
I know I can enjoy warm scents, I just haven't found the right one. Open to designer, niche, or clones. What would you suggest?