r/videogames • • Aug 19 '26

Image / Video What game is this for you?

Post image
14.4k Upvotes

8.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

48

u/RuzzeI Aug 19 '26

Elden ring

-30

u/PoopsMcScoots Aug 19 '26

I’m trying to be nonjudgmental and make a nonjudgmental space.

But really???

Not trying to criticize or convince, but why?

27

u/CosmosisJones42 Aug 19 '26

Why ask this question and get bewildered when people answer? This is probably the most obvious answer as some people don't enjoy hard games and play games casually.

-2

u/PoopsMcScoots Aug 19 '26

I’m not judging them.

I am bewildered.

I’m not arguing for anybody to like anything.

Just wanna know the reasoning.

That’s called discourse.

7

u/therealknic21 Aug 19 '26

I personally wasn't a fan of the big open world, the combat, or the little to no direction the game gives you. It felt like it wasn't respectful of my time. I don't even mind difficult games. But wandering around and fighting random enemies just isn't fun to me.

9

u/CosmosisJones42 Aug 19 '26

"But really???

Not trying to criticize or convince, but why?"

That's not discourse. That's just gamer superiority complex and it ruins enjoyment for everyone.

-1

u/Uzyf Aug 19 '26

So you just suck, get it

-2

u/PoopsMcScoots Aug 19 '26

How was I disrespectful of their opinion?

At no point did I discount them.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '26

[deleted]

1

u/PoopsMcScoots Aug 19 '26

I’m not a fan of casting broad nets like that.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '26

[deleted]

1

u/PoopsMcScoots Aug 19 '26

???

I don’t think my opinion is do or die as yours…

0

u/eldenringostar985 Aug 19 '26

?????? You are literally doing the EXACT thing you JUST complained about??? They gave you a response that respectfully disagreed and now you get mad and start picking apart their comments? Holy fuck how hypocritical

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Mac4491 Aug 19 '26

I am bewildered.

It's just not my vibe.

I can recognise that a game is incredibly well made while also not vibing with it at all. I would never say that it's a bad game, it's just simply not for me. There's very little about it that appeals to me and after I played it for a good while I just completely lost interest and have no desire to go back to it.

Is it a good game? Yes, undoubtedly. Is it a game I enjoy? No.

-2

u/ChErRyPOPPINSaf Aug 19 '26

While I agree with your first point, the game is as hard as you make with the exception of a few fights and the dlc.

4

u/CosmosisJones42 Aug 19 '26

To many people it is a very hard game. It's advertised and well known to be a hard game. I love it, but to say it's as hard as you make it isn't really what most people would say.

0

u/RuzzeI Aug 19 '26

Difficulty never was my problem, lol

1

u/PoopsMcScoots Aug 19 '26

OK, not to press, but what were your issues?

I love the game, but I will openly criticize it.

Weapons you don’t actively have on hand should not affect your weight.

It wants to be a force you through your decisions kind of game, but then offers a respec.

And the engine and net code is beyond trash.

2

u/RuzzeI Aug 19 '26

This is the 5th iteration of the same game without any significant changes in the combat. Still a good game tho, best level design FS ever did

1

u/PoopsMcScoots Aug 19 '26

I will not fault you for saying that.

5

u/AnomalousExpertise Aug 19 '26

I saw you say you didn’t like the Witcher 3. I’m sure Witcher fans would be like “WHAT” as well lol

Them 3 question marks after saying you aren’t being judgmental…seems judgmental lol

3

u/PoopsMcScoots Aug 19 '26

Totally not judgmental.

i’m not telling anyone they have to like something.

Just wondering why.

Also, criticism towards whitcher three is pretty obvious.

Great game. But glaring problems.

16

u/therealknic21 Aug 19 '26

Elden Ring is so boring.

2

u/Loose-Medium4472 Aug 19 '26

Bitch you said God of War stop acting surprised 😭😭😭

1

u/PoopsMcScoots Aug 19 '26

And I’m more than happy to explain myself why I did not care for God of war.

I’m not trying to convince anyone.

I’m genuinely asking.

2

u/Fackous93 Aug 19 '26

As a fan of fromsoft, Elden Ring felt like a step in the wrong direction. Enemies were easier, open world was super boring and you have no journal. Dark souls and bloodborne felt better because its more linear and metrovania like.

-1

u/PoopsMcScoots Aug 19 '26

You are 100% entitled to your point of view, and I’m not criticizing it.

But dark blade and what’s her face were the hardest fights in the entire genre.

I think Elden Ring was easier for sure to start, but it was more gradual stepping up the difficulty.

The hard fights were the hardest in the genre imo.

1

u/Fackous93 Aug 19 '26

I dont think I got that far. I got to the mountain area and just quit out of boredom. Recycling mobs and bosses really urked me. And it was just the easiest Fromsoft game Ive played. I am not the biggest fan of open world games so it really just wasn't for me. But I am happy to From software and every that enjoyed the game. My personal favorite was Bloodborne.

-1

u/One-Warthog3106 Aug 19 '26

The horse epitomizes the instant gratification culture around gaming. Commit to the journey you impatient baboon gamers. (Not you specifically, unless the shoe fits)

0

u/PoopsMcScoots Aug 19 '26

OK, so just to clarify you’re not saying you didn’t care for it as an outsider of from soft.

You didn’t care for it as a from soft fan?