r/AcademicQuran • u/Cool_Plantain_7742 • 1h ago

Book/Paper The Shiit Surah of Two Lights

• Upvotes

The history of the Qur‘an, Nöldeke

Question What were the Test given to David and Solomon in surah 38(Sad)

• Upvotes

Verse 22-25 describes David acting as an Arbiter between two people. After settling the dispute, He realized he was tested and sought forgiveness. Are there any late antique tradition regarding this incident and why he asked for forgiveness?

In Verse 34-35, Solomon is also tested with a body on his throne and he asks for forgiveness. What exactly was this test?

1 comment

r/AcademicQuran • u/AutoModerator • 20h ago

Weekly Open Discussion Thread

3 Upvotes

This is the general discussion thread in which anyone can make posts and/or comments. This thread will, automatically, repeat every week.

This thread will be lightly moderated only for breaking our subs Rule 1: Be Respectful, and Reddit's Content Policy. Questions unrelated to the subreddit may be asked, but preaching and proselytizing will be removed.

r/AcademicQuran offers many helpful resources for those looking to ask and answer questions, including:

0 comments

r/AcademicQuran • u/chonkshonk • 22h ago

Thomas Eich's new research on the historical context of the Qurans anti-infanticide verses!

13 Upvotes

3 comments

Subreddit

Posts

Wiki

AcademicQuran

r/AcademicQuran

A forum for the discussion of academic Quranic studies, including questions about the Quran's formation, interpretation, historical context, manuscripts, etc. Topics including pre-Islamic Arabia & late antiquity, Islamic origins and early Islam, hadith studies and more are also discussed in a friendly yet engaging way.

Members Active

23.6k

Sidebar

A subreddit dedicated to the discussion of the Quran, the Sunna and early Islam from a scholarly perspective. Here, such topics as Quranic exegesis, Biblical and extra-Biblical parallels, textual criticism, history of interpretation, pre-Islamic literature, etc. can be discussed in a friendly yet engaging way.

RULES

Rule 1: Be Respectful

On this subreddit, you will encounter people from a variety of different perspectives, Muslims and non-Muslims. Respect this fact and treat each other with kindness, always being polite even if you strongly disagree with one another. Be aware that this includes no profanity, flaming, trolling, bullying, harassing, stalking or spamming.

Rule 2: All content must remain within the boundaries of academic Islamic studies

The subreddit is focused on the academic (and not traditional) study of early Islam, and all content must remain in these boundaries. Other subs exist for traditional Islamic studies, discussion of contemporary events, inquiries for prayer requests and questions about personal belief and practice (do you believe in God, why does God allow suffering, etc).

Questions requiring ethical judgements (e.g. was Islamic slavery more moral than European slavery) are also not permitted.

Rule 3: Back up claims with academic sources

When discussing a subject, back up your claims or answers with at least one modern academic source. An example would be when you are discussing how to translate a Qurʾānic verse. This is not the same as reiterating or citing reiterations of traditional sources of knowledge.

Your answer and source should be verifiable by other users. Translations must accompany non-English quotations.

Rule 4: Do not invoke beliefs or sources with a religious framing

Theological debates and discussions (e.g. whether the Qurʾān is divinely inspired, whether non-Muslims go to Jannah) are not allowed. We ask everyone to abide by Qurʾān 109:6, “to you your religion and to me my religion.”

Use of sources which are framed in a religious or counter-religious perspective is not allowed, especially explicitly apologetic (eg IslamQA) or counter-apologetic (eg WikiIslam) material whose stated goal is to prove or disprove the truth of religious doctrines.

Rule 5: No low-effort posting. Answers should be substantive and relevant.

Low-effort posting: can include dropping a link to a video and just asking: "Is this true?"

Substantive answers: Answers should be more than one or two short sentences, unless they are pointing the questioner to another resource. Some degree of effort is expected when answering a question (and comments shouldn't be copy/pastes of ChatGPT).

Relevant: Comments should not be off-topic with respect to the question they are posted under, and should try to provide an answer.

Rule 6: Don't rely on AI/ChatGPT

Any content copy/pasted from and/or heavily written by ChatGPT, and/or any other AI and large language model (Grok, Gemini, Claude, Perplexity, etc) will be removed.

Rule 7: No Removal/Ban Evasion

If your comment and/or post has been removed, do not copy and immediately repaste it as a new comment/post. If you have been banned, do not circumvent it with a sock puppet account. Violations of this rule will immediately result in a temporary or permanent ban.

Rule 8: No Bad Faith Posting

All posts and comments must be made in good faith, with the intent to learn or discuss Islamic history, texts, and traditions academically. This means asking genuine questions and giving honest, evidence based answers in a respectful manner. Content meant to provoke, mock, misrepresent scholarship, polemicise or ambush users is not allowed. Loaded questions, selective quoting without context, and ignoring scholarly responses in order to restate the same claim may be removed.

What is AcademicQuran?

AcademicQuran is a community of individuals who are dedicated to the study of the Quran along with other early sacred Islamic works, such as the hadith and sira.

Ours is a community of diverse viewpoints and backgrounds where all are welcome to debate, discuss and learn about early Islamic literature and history, as well as the Late Antique Near Eastern cultural context in which the third Abrahamic religion was born.