Nine fifth-year Slytherins occupied the corner nearest the fireplace.
Draco Malfoy had claimed the largest armchair, with Pansy Parkinson perched on its arm. Vincent Crabbe and Gregory Goyle sat nearby, sharing a bag of sweets that Goyle had apparently acquired from somewhere.
Blaise Zabini was stretched across the opposite sofa, looking thoroughly bored. Theodore Nott sat beside him with a book resting on one knee.
At the small table, Daphne Greengrass and Tracey Davis were ostensibly completing their Charms homework, although neither had touched a quill in nearly twenty minutes.
Millicent Bulstrode sat on the rug, leaning against the sofa.
"Montague's gone completely mad with it," Blaise remarked.
Draco looked up. "With what?"
"The Squad. He's been stopping third-years in the corridors and asking where they're going."
"He's supposed to," Draco replied.
"At half past eight in the evening?"
"There's a curfew."
"Not at half past eight."
Pansy gave an impatient sigh. "Honestly, Blaise, you complain about everything."
"Only things worth complaining about."
Tracey smiled into her parchment.
Draco leaned forward. "Montague's doing exactly what Professor Umbridge expects of him. Someone has to keep order around here."
"Yes," said Daphne, without looking up. "Because Hogwarts was in absolute anarchy before Montague started interrogating twelve-year-olds."
Crabbe snorted.
Draco shot him a look. "What's funny?"
"Nothing."
"Then shut up."
Goyle passed Crabbe another sweet.
For a moment, only the crackling of the fire could be heard.
"Well," Millicent said, "personally, I don't mind Umbridge giving us a bit more freedom. Filch practically bows whenever he sees one of you lot coming."
"That's because he knows we have authority," Pansy said proudly.
"Authority to do what, exactly?" Tracey asked.
"Take points. Report misconduct. Enforce school regulations."
"And annoy people," Blaise added.
"That's a bonus," said Draco.
This time even Daphne laughed.
Theodore turned a page.
"Oi, you’ve been awfully quiet this whole conversation. What's your problem with it, Nott?" Draco asked. “You've been sitting there looking miserable for an hour."
"I’ve been reading," said Theodore.
"Well, you could at least show some interest."
Theodore slowly closed his book. "All right, Draco. Would you like my opinion?"
"Go on."
"I think Umbridge is considerably more interested in controlling the school for the sake of control than actually improving it."
Pansy rolled her eyes. "Oh, not you as well."
"She hasn't taught us a single practical defensive spell all year," Theodore continued. "And we're sitting our O.W.L.s in two months."
"Professor Umbridge knows what she's doing," Draco insisted.
"Does she?"
"Of course she does!"
"Then perhaps she'll explain how we're supposed to defend ourselves against a curse by reading about it."
Blaise grinned. "Careful, Theo. That's almost a reasonable argument."
Draco's expression darkened. "You're all missing the point."
"And what's the point?" Daphne asked.
"That Dumbledore's been running this school however he likes for years, and now someone from the Ministry is finally doing something about it."
"Father says Dumbledore's losing his influence," Crabbe contributed.
"Mine says the same," Goyle added.
"Your fathers seem to agree on an awful lot," said Tracey, as she glanced toward Daphne.
Crabbe shrugged. "Because they're right."
"Naturally," Daphne murmured dryly.
Draco straightened in his chair.
"Anyway, the Ministry wouldn't have sent Umbridge here if there weren't serious problems. Potter's been spreading rubbish since June, and Dumbledore's encouraging him."
At the mention of Potter, Blaise gave an exaggerated sigh. "Oh, here we go."
"What?"
"Nothing, continue."
Draco ignored him. "Potter claims the Dark Lord's returned, and half the school acts as though he's some kind of prophet."
"Not half," Millicent said. "Mostly the Gryffindors."
"And half the Hufflepuffs," Pansy added. “And a few Ravenclaws here and there.”
"Well, they're idiots," Draco declared.
Theodore said nothing. Daphne noticed. "Do you think he's lying, Theo?"
Theodore looked at her. "Who, Potter?"
"Yes."
Theodore hesitated. "I think Potter genuinely believes what he's saying."
Draco laughed. "That doesn't make it true."
"No," Theodore agreed. "It doesn't."
"But you think it is?"
"I didn't say that."
"Then what are you saying?"
Theodore regarded him for a moment. "I'm saying Cedric Diggory went into that maze alive and came out dead. Potter came out with his body, claiming something happened that the Ministry doesn't want to discuss. And rather than investigate it properly, Fudge seems determined to convince everyone that Potter's gone mad."
Pansy folded her arms. "Perhaps Potter has always been mad."
"Perhaps," Theodore said.
"He's always been an attention-seeker," Draco added.
"That doesn't explain what happened to Diggory, though," Tracey replied quietly.
There was a short silence.
Millicent shifted against the sofa. "Could've been an accident."
"An accident that killed him?" Daphne asked.
"Well, something happened in that maze."
"Obviously something happened," Blaise said. "The question is what."
Draco looked irritated. "You're all acting as though Potter's the only person who knows anything."
"Then enlighten us," Blaise said.
"I don't have to."
"Convenient."
Pansy leaned closer to Draco. "Don't bother with him."
But Theodore was watching Draco with an expression Daphne couldn't quite interpret. "Your father must have an opinion," he said.
Draco hesitated. "My father knows considerably more about what's happening than Potter does."
"That wasn't what I was alluding to."
"Well, perhaps you should ask your own father."
Theodore's face changed almost imperceptibly. "I have."
The words hung in the air. Crabbe stopped chewing. Goyle looked between them.
Draco shifted in his seat. "And?"
Theodore reopened his book. "He doesn't discuss everything with me."
For several seconds nobody spoke.
Then Tracey broke the silence. "Well, whatever's happening outside Hogwarts, I don't see how making Montague patrol the corridors is going to solve it."
"Montague's a seventh-year," Millicent said. "He likes being important."
"He's always liked being important," Daphne replied. "Now he's got a badge to prove it."
Pansy frowned. "You're being awfully critical of the Squad for someone who benefits from it."
Daphne looked up. "Do I? Benefit?"
"Of course you do. We're Slytherins."
"And?"
"And we're finally getting treated properly."
Daphne exchanged a glance with Tracey, then turned her head back to Pansy. "Being treated properly is one thing, Pansy. Being allowed to do whatever we like simply because Umbridge dislikes Gryffindors is another."
Draco scoffed. "You almost sound like Granger."
Daphne's expression cooled. "Don't be ridiculous."
"Then stop talking like her."
Tracey put down her quill. "She doesn't have to agree with everything you say, Draco."
"I wasn't talking to you, Davis."
"Well, you are now."
Blaise made a quiet, appreciative noise. "Wonderful. We're finally having an interesting evening."
"Shut it, Blaise," Draco snapped.
"Gladly."
Crabbe leaned toward Goyle. "Greg?"
"What?"
"Got any more of those?"
Goyle looked into the empty bag. "No, Vince."
"Brilliant."
Millicent groaned. "Can you two think about anything besides food?"
"Yeah," Crabbe replied.
"What?"
"Quidditch."
Blaise burst out laughing. Even Draco's mouth twitched, despite himself. For a moment, the tension lifted.
Then Theodore spoke again. "There's something else." Everyone looked at him. "If the Dark Lord really has returned, Umbridge's Defense lessons are going to be the least of our problems."
Draco's smile vanished.
Pansy stared at Theodore. "You shouldn't say things like that!"
"Why?"
"Because! You just shouldn't."
Theodore looked toward the dark window, where something enormous moved slowly beyond the glass. "That's not much of an answer."
Draco stood. "Well, in any case, I think Potter's a liar, Dumbledore's losing his mind, and Umbridge is the best thing that's happened to this school in years."
"Good for you," Blaise said.
Draco glared at him. "Come on, Crabbe. Goyle."
The two boys got up, Crabbe brushing crumbs from his robes.
Pansy rose as well. "Are you coming, Millicent?"
"In a minute."
Draco headed toward the boys' staircase, with Crabbe and Goyle following, but at the bottom step, he stopped. "And Nott?"
Theodore looked up. "What?"
"Perhaps you ought to be more careful about what you say."
Theodore met his gaze. "Perhaps you ought to be more careful about what you believe."
Draco said nothing. Then he turned and disappeared up the stairs. A moment later, Pansy departed for the girls' dormitory. The common room settled into silence.
Blaise stared at the ceiling. "Well. That was pleasant."
Millicent shook her head. "You really shouldn't wind him up like that, Theo."
"He asked."
"That's never stopped you before."
Daphne began gathering her parchment. Tracey leaned toward her. "Do you think Potter's telling the truth?"
Daphne hesitated. Across the room, Theodore was once again pretending to read.
"I don't know," Daphne admitted.
Tracey lowered her voice. "Neither do I."
Blaise sat up. "For what it's worth, I think Fudge is frightened of something."
"Fudge is always frightened of something," Millicent said.
"Precisely."
Theodore closed his book. "That's what worries me."
Beyond the windows, the black water pressed against the glass. None of them needed to say anything else. The atmosphere pretty much encapsulated what they were all thinking. If Voldemort has in fact returned, the wizarding world status quo wouldn't be able to protect anyone.