r/LodedDiper • u/Prestigious_Heat4323 • 1d ago

Discussion Which is better?

Post image

The original diary of a wimpy kid book, diary of a wimpy kid 2010 movie, or diary of a wimpy kid animated movie (2021)

96 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

33 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Bubby!

LLB and Meme Resources Megathread

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

6

u/superB_lyke 11h ago

the book and the 2010 movie

3

u/Ok-Low7699 16h ago

First two.

Now, if the 2021 version were done by SONy Pictures Animation...

1

u/PangolinWestern9632 17h ago

Online books. Those were peak.

1

u/CoiledBubble413 17h ago

original film or the book

3

u/y2kkstar creighton the cretin 17h ago

Zachary Gordon greg

3

u/dndhhdndhdj27736 19h ago

The one that has Greg on the cover

6

u/NabbitFan600 19h ago

Diary of a Wimpy Kid

-3

u/Prize-Permit8669 19h ago

book and animated movie

8

u/GB_Alph4 Exploded Diper! 20h ago

The original book and movie win

4

u/Longjumping_Gur_2379 22h ago

live action movie

5

u/DOAWK_Greg_Heffley 22h ago

Definitely original movie but the book is also really good and the animated movie sucks but not as much as long haul that's for sure 

4

u/ItzzMeSiaaa WHEN I WAS LITTLE WAS AN AVID READER OF DOAWK 23h ago

The book ofc?

18

u/UpperRuster32 Roast Roast Beef 🍖 1d ago edited 22h ago

The Live Action movie, story wise.

The original book has more "events", but the 2010 film just works better with the weight and order of events, and, you understand better how some characters actually act like Patty.

The 2021 Disney+ thing is fine, but it barely has a story, so little that the conflict of Greg and Rowley juuuuust makes in as the main plot. The whole School Patrol being removed was a bummer.

Also Greg doesn't really do any remotely negative thing aside from discussing with Rowley, in the book you could see that Greg was influenced by his perspective of the environment, so he played some tricks in order to gain self-status, failing in no time.

2

u/Prize-Permit8669 19h ago

he gets safety patrol in last straw movie tho

1

u/RetardedDeltaruneFan ʙᴀᴅ ꜰᴀʀᴛ ᴀʜᴇᴀᴅ 22h ago

Agreed

5

u/em_i-nem 1d ago

live action

3

u/neverend6789 1d ago

Live action films

2

u/Sometimezay 1d ago

The live action movie

8

u/LiteratureCold7070 1d ago

Is that even a question? Cmon it’s the live action everybody knows that

4

u/anotherdudette72 1d ago

first animated movie is pretty bad. the sequels (that ive seen, havent watched past cabin fever) are alright, though not any better then the live action movies

4

u/Good-Pop-5235 1d ago

The live-action films

2

u/Diva_flipflops 1d ago

I like all tbh- I like the animated movies cus the charcters look so cute :333

8

u/KingPenguinPhoenix 1d ago

Live action movie

6

u/raviolottee 1d ago

Doesn’t matter Uncle Ben, the musical’s better than all of them

5

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

1

u/raviolottee 2h ago

Sorry for the late response but sadly not technically, however there is a bootleg recording of the official 2022 production on internet archive that's not the best quality but still watchable. I'd recommend watching it over licensed productions because they vary in quality and aren't produced by wimpy kid inc

4

u/Budget-Coffee-651 1d ago

honestly all

4

u/Redcar31 1d ago

The animated movie is pantsssss bruh