r/SipsTea • u/CurvyChristina • 13h ago

Chugging tea Did Metallica get the message?

Post image
13.4k Upvotes

78% Upvoted

4.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

56

u/VendettaPenguin 13h ago

Being antisemitic and antigenocide are 2 very different things boyo.

-31

u/RoozGol 13h ago

You cannot arbitrarily call an event a genocide and expect everybody else to follow.

19

u/HeavyCartographer550 13h ago

They want to wipe out the entirety of a single ethnicity. That's genocide.

-10

u/LimpAd1859 13h ago

They don’t tho, there’s no real evidence of this.

8

u/HeavyCartographer550 13h ago

Other than the things their politicians and military leaders say.

0

u/LimpAd1859 13h ago

Other than out of context quotes and extremists with no real authority, they haven't said that.

1

u/HeavyCartographer550 12h ago

Netanyahu literally presented a map to the UN general assembly without palestine on it. What do you not understand about that? You can say you're after hamas, but if your actions show you're indiscriminately killing Palestinians in general, and you openly desire the destruction of their nation, then you're doing a genocide.

0

u/LimpAd1859 12h ago

Netanyahu literally presented a map to the UN general assembly without palestine on it. What do you not understand about that?

Let's just entertain the idea that this is in any way demonstrating a genocidal intent, so logically anti-Zionists also want to wipe out the entirety of a single ethnicity because they want Israel destroyed?

You can say you're after hamas, but if your actions show you're indiscriminately killing Palestinians in general,

Their actions don't really show that, 20-35% of the casualties are Hamas, and given that Hamas is nowhere near 20-35% of the population, this being indiscriminate is highly unlikely.

and you openly desire the destruction of their nation,

Again, there's no real evidence of Israel wanting to wipe out Palestinians.

then you're doing a genocide.

Showing a map without a state that doesn't even exist and waging a war with reasonable civilian to combatant casualty ratios (for urban warfare) isn't the definition of genocide, no.