r/TopCharacterTropes • • 10h ago

Characters Characters that present themselves saying that they were always there. And they were always there, actually

​

Blendin (gravity falls): time traveler that work trying to fix time anomalies in gravity falls saying that he's been there for some time and at the end of the episode show him fixing every anomaly caused by Dipper and Mabel. If you rewatch the episodes (or put atention in the background the first time) you were noticed that he was in fact in all those places.

Shou (dorohedoro): man acts as a deus ex machina, manage to move the family from the mansion to a underground base and make a plan to defeat the cross-eyes gang before anyone remember who the fuck he is. Shou simply say that he was there the whole blue moon festival with everyone else, and not only he was there, he's been there since way before appearing in En's movie and in several photos.

Death (puss in boots 2): He talks with puss in a bar acting like a bounty hunter saying that he's been following him for a long time, later reveals himself as death and mention to be there in each death. You can actually see him at the start of the movie when puss die for eight time.

7.3k Upvotes

368 comments sorted by

2.3k

u/JuiceOfTheElderToad 10h ago

Nibbler in Futurama.

In the fourth season, he reveals that he was the one who pushed Fry into the cryopod in the very first episode, and if you rewatch the first episode, you’ll see Nibbler’s shadow by the chair.

1.1k

u/imlegos 10h ago

And yes, people have confirmed that this was there in the original broadcast.

633

u/Conejoformerwars 10h ago

There was even a post I saw of an ancient forum with someone speculating about the shadow

205

u/Extrimland 9h ago

Im curious did anyone correctly guess it was Nibbler? I mean he did debut only like 2 episodes latter

279

u/MeiNeedsMoreBuffs 8h ago

I found this post from 2001 which suggests a lot of people made the connection, and in in 2002 the "Nibbler Conspiracy" was widely known. The episode that revealed this aired in 2003 in Season 4

190

u/Auctoritate 6h ago

in in 2002 the "Nibbler Conspiracy" was widely known.

Shoutout to this comment:

it's just that it was the first time i saw it and i was all like "hey" and then i paused it it and i was like "woah" and then i ate waffles and i was all like "mmfmmmfm"

117

u/Muted_Anywherethe2nd 5h ago

Fry ass sentence

78

u/TheOneTonWanton 5h ago

That's how we all sounded on forums in 2002.

7

u/alex3omg 3h ago

lol sooo random.  

→ More replies (1)

55

u/astronggentleman 7h ago

I absolutely loved this glimpse into the past. Thank you

65

u/MeiNeedsMoreBuffs 7h ago

No worries, if you want to do it yourself for other topics try using the "before:" feature with google search

The way it works is you type something like "before:2003-01-01" (In Year-Month-Day format, but I always do 1/1 for simplicity) and it will only show you search results from before that day.

For example if you type "before:2004-02-15 Half Life Theories" then it would show you what you would have seen if you had searched up the term "Half Life Theories" before Febuary 15, 2004

It's an incredibly useful feature that I barely see anyone talking about, especially because using 2022-01-01 as the cutoff means you can filter out anything made by AI

8

u/I_SHIT_IN_A_BAG 4h ago

saving this comment. thanks for the tip

→ More replies (1)

5

u/CivBEWasPrettyBad 4h ago

I love that people are talking about ancient threads when the 2001 thread gets necroed in 2006... And here we are playing historian 20 years later.

Truly an "Egypt had its own archeologists" moment

→ More replies (1)

41

u/[deleted] 10h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

212

u/Extrimland 9h ago

Idk if it was planned and its a different trope, but i REALLY love how great Futurama was at this.

  1. Fry causes a time paradox by not going to the future. Its later revealed this is because he is only born because he goes to the Future (and time travels back to 1948) meaning he ceases to exist, there-go the universe cannot exist anymore.

  2. Fry is shown to be immune to mind control. We later learn this is due to the temporal shenanigans he got into in 1948

105

u/OperationHumanShield 9h ago

He did do the nasty in the pasty.

45

u/MentokGL 9h ago

Verily!

28

u/Anufenrir 8h ago

Said past nastiness renders him immune to the brainspawn

24

u/dan_santhems 7h ago

As a Cornish person that phrase makes me uncomfortable

20

u/fafarex 7h ago

Given that the last part is the reason why nibbler pushed him into the cryo chamber in episode one the general idea must have been there from the start yes.

14

u/SpaceLemur34 8h ago

"there-go"?

21

u/Charlemangydog 8h ago

Ergo?

9

u/SpaceLemur34 8h ago

Presumably, but I wasn't sure if I was forgetting a joke from the show. Sounds like something Fry would say.

→ More replies (1)

168

u/LovelyLuna32684 9h ago

Another great Futurama one in season 2 episode 1 "I second that emotion" there is a single scene that last about a two seconds were you can see Leela's parents a whole two seasons before they are properly introduced in season four episode two "Leela's home world"

29

u/NoBookkeeper5186 10h ago

Isn't there also one that has Frys Shadow?

44

u/Luster-Purge 9h ago

Might be the episode where the big brain sends Fry back in time to stop Nibbler, only for Nibbler to convince Fry it is necessary and Fry himself gets his past self stuck in the cyropod

→ More replies (1)

16

u/featherw0lf 9h ago

I know he later went back in time to do it himself, but would he still show up if it was Nibbler who originally did it? Since he was rewriting that part? Kinda confusing when I ask about it.

14

u/Captobvious789 5h ago

Yes. Fry's shadow appears with Nibbler's in "Jurassic Bark" (aka the sad dog one) to foreshadow (heh) the events of a later episode in the season "The Why of Fry".

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

1.0k

u/MurkyPatient396 10h ago

in the episode of gumball "The anybody" clayton, the shapeshifter, says that he had shapeshifted into inanimate objects before. It then shows a montage of previous episodes where clayton is objects in the background, such as a trophy or mall fountain. However if you watch those episodes, he actually was the objects, so the writers planned this gag before the episode even aired

550

u/SwellEquis 9h ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/EnZgT1X5bwdaCOBVkQ

Adding onto this, Rob was another character who was always in the background in Gumballs earlier seasons. He was never important in any way though, and when the world realized his uselessness he was sent to the void. He later escaped by riding on the back of Janice, but was disfigured as a result. To take revenge against Gumball for ignoring him so much prior to being sent to the void, he became his arch nemesis

187

u/Ariovrak 9h ago

He’s even shown in the Void trying to get their attention.

15

u/True-Wreck 2h ago

Minor correction. He was shown in the void, but he was not shown trying to get their attention in the original broadcast.

→ More replies (2)

74

u/Upstairs-Ad-5009 9h ago

I mean It could also have just been a regular object when the episode aired, but for the Clayton episode they just chose random objects from previous episodes

198

u/MurkyPatient396 9h ago

no if u look back at the original episodes, his face is actually on the objects

72

u/Upstairs-Ad-5009 9h ago

Oh damn you right. I can't believe I didn't notice that the 12th time I looked at the image 😭, my bad

203

u/OkBand3171 5h ago

In the Odyssey (650BCE), Odysseus arrives home to Ithaca to find Athena waiting for him there. He complains to her that if she was going to help him now, why didn't she help during the entire journey?

She basically admonishes him and asks him who he thinks broke Poseidons waves, kept his ships afloat and got him off Calypsos' island?

65

u/pedanticheron 5h ago

More recently copied with “the one pair of footprints was when I carried you” poem.

380

u/Dodweon 6h ago

The snail from Adventure Time is hidden in almost every episode, waiving to the viewers. It eventually becomes relevant plot-wise so I think it counts

97

u/Steampunk43 5h ago

The Adventure Time DLC for Powerwash Simulator also continues the trend, I believe every map has a snail that waves at you when you find it, it'll retreat into its shell if you spray it.

39

u/GrenVillain 5h ago

Reference to Blue's Clues that ALWAYS had the Snail in every episode, including the remake series and movie

27

u/GuessFriendly6445 3h ago

The snail waving at us for seasons and then actually becoming important is such a ridiculous level of foreshadowing

12

u/Sennten 1h ago

Seems more like an ascended gag than foreshadowing

→ More replies (2)

1.0k

u/JingoboStoplight4887 10h ago

Sam Reich (CollegeHumor and Dropout)
https://giphy.com/gifs/8qbuGuXC0hcuRMMwVY

96

u/CollectionThese 8h ago

But where is he from...?

80

u/Sihle_Franbow 6h ago

Cambridge, Massachusetts

23

u/Jazzlike_Mouse7478 3h ago

Really? Cuz I thought he'd been here THE WHOLE TIME!

GOTTEM

10

u/Flaxy 2h ago

Do they have a movie theater there?

→ More replies (1)

66

u/OutlandishnessOwn893 8h ago

Does he still look at his hands dramatically in the newest seasons? I need to catch up

31

u/alphanumericusername 7h ago

More in passing than dramatically

62

u/Gtweedy 10h ago

You beat me to posting this exact gif lol

18

u/Phantom_tpa 8h ago

I came to the comments hoping to see this and was not disappointed. Good job

22

u/Auctoritate 6h ago

I don't know if anybody else thinks about this but every time I hear his surname pronounced with the 'sch' sound I can't help but think about how it's probably totally pronounced with a K sound as the end, same way as Third Reich, but his family just pretends it's something else to make it less awkward right?

25

u/Butterkeks42 4h ago

As EinBRinDE already wrote, 'ch' is not pronounced as a K in German (except maybe for loan words, which don't count imo). Now there are two ways to pronounce 'ch', depending on context, one softer and one a bit harsher, for that one, using a 'K' would probably be alright, The 'ch' in Reich, however, is much softer and 'sh' would be a much better substitution if one does not know how to pronounce it properly. Describing it with words is not so easy unfortunately, so videos like this might be more helpful: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=55099gBTPFI

Now, since Sam is jewish (according to Wikipedia, at least), one might also look to Yiddish for the 'correct' pronounciation (although that's up to Sam and his family, ultimately). Yiddish is very close to modern German, but as far as I can tell, it does not have the soft version of 'ch' (only the hard one). I couldn't find anything where Sam himself said his surname, but since the people around it pronounce it with a 'sh', I'm going to assume he bases his surnames pronounciation off how it would be pronounced in German.

A bit long of a response, but it irks me how often people say that my native tongue sounds incredibly harsh, when these days that stereotype is mostly based on Americans yelling broken German with the worst pronounciation imaginable.

7

u/Heimerdahl 3h ago

it irks me how often people say that my native tongue sounds incredibly harsh, when these days that stereotype is mostly based on Americans yelling broken German with the worst pronounciation imaginable. 

It's definitely overdone, but admittedly, linguistically our language does have some "harsher" qualities than many; especially in contrast to (politically) Western European languages.

(Very simplified,) it's all about our stops between words. 

This is most obvious when compared to French, and with us being such close neighbours, and our two languages having effectively been the two "continental" ones in the eyes of the Brits, it makes sense why this different "vibe" survived well into our peaceful era. 

French is very fluid with a heavy emphasis on preserving "the flow". Each word smoothly follows the next. This is so central to the language, that if it isn't really possible to smoothly connect two words, the words themselves are adjusted to make it possible. In French, the cohesion of the sentence has the highest priority. Contractions are probably the primary example: le arbre -> l'arbre, il me a embrassé -> il m'a embrassé. Unlike in English, these aren't optional. This absolute requirement to make it work goes so far as to sometimes using articles of the opposite gender, if the correct one simply can't be made to work: "friend "= ami, "my" = mon/ma (m/f), => "my (female) friend" = mon ami (using the masculine), because ma ami is simply unacceptable and m'ami ain't it, either. Imagine calling your best male friend "meine Freund", simply because everyone agrees that "mein Freund" sounds stupid. 

Fun fact: sometimes the French go too far with their love of contractions so that they for example messed up the word for the bird we call "Pirol". The etymology is clear cut. It's a distinctly yellow, or golden bird. So it was called "the golden one": le oriot -> l'oriot. At some point the French "kind of forgot" that the article was already included, added one, and started calling it le loriot.  

German has a completely different philosophy. For us, the flow and overall cohesion of the sentence is less important than the individual word. No matter how fast we speak, our sentences don't turn into "soup", you can always hear distinct words. We do this by adding literal (if very short) breaks/stops between words, but also further accentuate it by ending our words on hard consonants, even if the word is written as ending on a soft one. Notice the difference between "Hund" und "Hunde", "Burg" and "Burgen", "Haus" und "Häuser". If it's at the end of the word, it turns hard.  

It's easy to see how this might make it sound much harsher when side by side with a French sentence.

But there's more.

English shares some of the French style. They for example have contractions ("I am" -> "I'm", "are not" -> "aren't", etc.), even if they're somewhat optional. More importantly for the "German sounds harsh" bit is that English doesn't have our "words end on hard consonants" rule. There's no difference between "dog" and "dogs". For us native German speakers, our hard consonants rule is so deeply ingrained, that it is one of the harder aspects of learning to speak English. It's so hard in fact, that very few of us, even those among us for whom it becomes the primary language, ever properly learn it. I have spoken English as my primary language for nearly two decades, but because my early childhood was in German, my "dog' sounds more like "dock", if I don't make a conscious effort to get it right. More fuel for the "German sounds harsh" fire.

Ninja-Edit: obviously all of the above only really applies to the standard dialects. There's harsh, staccato French dialects and soft, contracting, flowing German ones. 

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/AnticPosition 7h ago

I would've been very upset if this wasn't near the top of this comment section. 

37

u/Jacquesatoutfaire 9h ago

Game-themed changers

→ More replies (4)

499

u/naynaythewonderhorse 7h ago edited 2h ago

Dante in Coco.

The first time you watch the movie, Dante is just sort of seems like a dumb animal who keeps running off and being annoying while Miguel is just trying to get home with the Guitar.

Meanwhile, the movie starts piling on coincidence after coincidence of Miguel running into people, including a random man who JUST SO HAPPENS to be his real grandfather.

But, then near the end you find out that Dante is an Alebrije (spirit guide) and on the rewatch you’ll see that NONE of it was coincidental. Dante was always there. Guiding Miguel to the people he needed to find.

The movie doesn’t even really say it outright, and it’s only really something and I really recommend a rewatch, because watching how Dante “manipulate” is fun.

70

u/HispanicNach0s 3h ago

Frida Khalo does directly refer to Dante as an Alebrije, although she does so in a confused tone and given her eccentric taste, it's dismissed as her misunderstanding the situation.

53

u/MatyKiller800 4h ago

But Miguel does directly say that Dante was trying to guide him back to his real grandfather after being rescued, right? I watched it recently and I remember him saying that

17

u/naynaythewonderhorse 3h ago

Oh, maybe he does say that. Still; it’s cool to see it on the rewatch.

→ More replies (1)

132

u/jamcam3 9h ago

I just realized his name is literally Blend-in

30

u/Silverfire12 8h ago

Oh my god. I’ve seen the show countless times and I just fucking realized that

6

u/tenaciousghost 5h ago

thats blendin blenjamin blandin !

15

u/BestGarden6132 7h ago

NO WAY 😭 bro was literally named for his entire job and we still didn’t catch it.

4

u/thegoodvm 2h ago

even the name blended in 😭

→ More replies (1)

233

u/Kirajudgeoftoons 5h ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/iwX0ct6DasHWSdl2CN

Tow Mater from Cars. "Don't ya remember? You was there too"

54

u/Lykanas 4h ago

Alex Bale theory on this goes crazy btw

23

u/Kirajudgeoftoons 4h ago

Yeah, but i interpet is as Mater merely being a troll

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Automatic-Bid9167 2h ago

What does it say?

13

u/No-Material9127 1h ago

Basically, everytime Mater says "Don't ya remember? You was there too" reality shifts, making the event in question become real.

12

u/Lykanas 2h ago

Mater is an all-powerfull being that takes control over time and space

228

u/KingMe321 10h ago

Soi Purson from Welcome to Demon School Iruma-kun

We don’t officially meet him until the music festival arc, however he is always in the background usually drawn poorly or off model until he gets real focus

34

u/Galle_ 7h ago

I think it's important to mention that Purson's bloodline ability is "detection warding". He comes from a family of spies and information brokers and was sent to the school specifically to hone his stealth skills. So the reason you didn't notice him, even though he was always there, is that his power even worked on the audience.

12

u/KingMe321 7h ago

definitely forgot to mention that bit XD

53

u/NATHAN325 9h ago

This is who i came to say. Its great considering a bulk of the show for the first while is the main character befriending each of his classmates, and you consistently see someone else that never gets a spotlight until i think season 3 of the anime

20

u/KingMe321 9h ago

Season 4, season 3 the last episode is him being pointed out, but season 4 is the music festival!

6

u/NATHAN325 9h ago

Right! And boy does he shine!

9

u/KingMe321 8h ago

Are you caught up to the manga? cause GOD these chapters have been so hype to me

→ More replies (2)

364

u/Potential_Log_3172 8h ago edited 3h ago

Gravity Falls: the Government agents claimed they had been monitoring the Pines family all summer, and it’s true — they can sometimes be seen in the background. And also in the episode “Sock Opera” there’s a bug device in Mystery Shack's interfloor space

1.2k

u/Atelier1001 10h ago

How you fucking dare having Death but not Humpty Alexander Dumpty. He was always there!

349

u/Lower_Baby_6348 10h ago

Cause he reveal to be always there, not presented as someone who was always there

197

u/Womblue 8h ago

Humpty Dumpty is a parody of this trope. He's literally an egg in a shoddy cat costume.

96

u/Aneurism-Inator 7h ago

Not exactly. In the previous scenes he literally was not there, and then the story said he was. This is a slightly different trope being parodied.

→ More replies (3)

27

u/Due_Stranger_7681 8h ago

Exactly, there’s a big difference between a character being revealed as always present and the story actually showing us that. The reveal hits so much harder when you can look back and realize the clues were there all along.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

208

u/Potatrobot 10h ago

They literally called do-over for the twist so they could pull it off better in the sequel.

147

u/Mozzarellus_Pizzus 10h ago

Too bad they failed. Death could never reach the level of aura Humpty Dumpty had.

82

u/insanityking500 9h ago

This sentence is absolutely crazy if you have no context whatsoever

58

u/HenTie3467 10h ago

I love how they did the antagonist was there the whole time twice for Puss. You'd think he'd be more wary of his surroundings after Humpty.

17

u/DarkWaWeeGee 8h ago

Tbf, would you really pay attention to an omnipotent being who you don't even know exists in personification? Like being careful of death as an idea is very different from being careful of Death the godlike being

4

u/HenTie3467 8h ago

It's more about the same person who always appears in many different places that you go to. For example, seeing the same person at a grocery store, on the streets, in a bar, a movie theater. Puss has experienced Humpty appearing in many different places during adventure. He'd have reason to notice a singular person that constantly appears in the places he goes to, even if they are one off locations.

19

u/themanfromosaka 9h ago

“Humpty Alexander Dumpty. How dare you show your face to me.”

→ More replies (4)

143

u/Aguy434 9h ago

Gaunter O'Dimm shows up at the start of Witcher 3 and later during the heart of stone DLC can be seen watching discretely in the background.

45

u/vladart41 7h ago

Before DLC release it was kinda weird, that random NPC in tavern had a unique face model for no reason

21

u/empty_other 7h ago

Not really "unique" because it isn't immediately obvious that all the sightings is the same guy. Easily mistaken for a rarely re-used NPC face.

13

u/Auctoritate 6h ago

Well, you don't know it's a unique face right at the beginning of the game when you've only seen a few characters so far.

9

u/EndOfTheLine00 6h ago

CDPR even held a contest to see if anyone could spot all of Gaunter’s background appearances. No one did (they gave the prize to the one who spotted the most).

→ More replies (1)

72

u/go_faster1 10h ago

In Final Fantasy XIV’s Hildibrand missions, one quest in Stormblood has you discover a Lalafell who has been following Nashu for five years. Though Nashu dismisses it, turns out the little bastard has been stalking her since patch 2.45!

14

u/kuromaus 7h ago

You can always tell when a Hildibrand quest is nearby if that lalafell is nearby, badly hiding. I still haven't started the Dawntrail one, so that lalafell is still there, stalking Nashu.

→ More replies (1)

71

u/JohnApple94 2h ago

In Futurama, when Leela meets her mutant parents, they tell her that while they did leave her in the “normal world” alone to become an orphan, they never truly left her side and kept an eye on her as she grew up. We then see a montage of them being present in her life while remaining hidden. Also, I believe you can spot them a couple of times in the background in some of the previous episodes.

Also in Futurama, Nibbler reveals later on in the series that he was the one who tipped Fry back in his chair and caused him to become frozen and wake up 1,000 years in the future. If you go back and watch the very first episode, you will see Nibbler’s shadow for a brief moment, indicating that he truly was there in the beginning pulling the strings.

55

u/Nekrotix12 3h ago

Dr. Maruki from Persona 5 Royal, he claims at the end of his confidant to have always known who the Phantom Thieves were because he caught us just as we were leaving the Metaverse, right after Ann awakened her persona. If you go back and watch that scene, you can actually catch Dr. Maruki leaving the school, having a direct line of sight with your group.

54

u/AmissingUsernameIsee 9h ago

Purson soi - from Iruma Kun

Until the music festival arc, people forgot about him. Like it wasn't retconned he was always there, he actually was always there in the background of the classroom and basically all the events.

15

u/fightingbronze 7h ago

It ended up being way more obvious in the anime cause of all the bright colors but in the manga this worked so well. From the very first chapters he’s there with everyone in the misfits class, but he just blends in so well.

6

u/Femlix 8h ago

Yep, and was even named at the very start of the introduction to the abnormal class.

6

u/Tnecniw 7h ago

And nobody really notices him which is hilarious.
He is in all the openings to the show!

49

u/Pristine_Poem7623 6h ago

The Observers - Fringe

Before they become part of the main story, one of them appears in every episode, normally in the background

→ More replies (2)

47

u/PanZolnierski 5h ago

I don't think it was ever confirmed, but it's highly possible that the naked character that appears in the background of Smiling Friends s1 finale is Mole Man, a character that stalked Pim and Charlie through the series and reveals itself in season 3

85

u/Biochemistry_173 9h ago

On a more casual note, Katsura and Elizabeth are almost always on stand-by when not appearing in episodes.

24

u/SirCupcake_0 8h ago

I'm guessing this is Gintama?

11

u/FirePydrant 6h ago

There's also an episode where you have to spot Katsura and Elizabeth throughout and they're hidden in the background somewhere

171

u/Wise-Inside1805 10h ago

Lord english - homestuck

His main catchphrase is literally "Hes already here"

50

u/RedBleedingBult 10h ago

DO NOT TYPE IN BIG LETTERS! IT CONFuSES ME

→ More replies (1)

25

u/thekirbykid2006 8h ago

might be my absolute favorite example of this trope, not just "oh they were just there in the background the whole time" but "everything we've been doing up to this point has been entirely orchestrated by this motherfucker, and there is nothing we can do or could have done to stop it"

8

u/SickXigma 8h ago

How exactly does this fit? We don't see him early on or anything, nor do we feel any impact from his presence until much much later.

A better HS example would be John's ghost arms, but that was a retcon, they were added to the panels after.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

102

u/Adienpowerschool 10h ago

Uncle Tsukishima(Bleach)

59

u/Takamurarules 9h ago edited 9h ago

This is a weird case for those who don’t know. Technically he wasn’t there. But his powers give him the ability to retroactively overwrite both a person’s memories and essentially reality itself when he decides to use it.

In this case he saw Orihime, inserted himself into her past and it actually became retroactive history.

24

u/ThePinkReaper 8h ago

The Fullbring arc was pretty wack overall and the final arc et al was pretty rushed but god the payoff of Tsukishima towards the end of the TYBW arc was so cool. His power is so tremendously OP compared to everything else in the series, he's basically a Stand User in the wrong universe.

5

u/Opachopp 5h ago

Just in case you only saw the anime version of this arc I would say try to give the manga version of this arc a shot.

Right before the TYBW anime I decided to reread the manga and I remember having a very similar opinion about the Fullbring arc for ages so I wasn't looking forward to getting there but once I did I was very pleasantly surprised when I actually ended up liking it on the manga.

Maybe it was because I could read it all in one go or because the anime had some pacing issues and fillers between the arcs but I actually found it very refreshing after the non stop fighting from the arcs before.

4

u/SirCupcake_0 8h ago

I love paracausal instances

5

u/VonKaiser55 7h ago

Honestly such a scary power

62

u/phsychotix 8h ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/dxgemX0Huwp4CGosir
Half Life 1 & 2 - The G-Man

An inter-dimensional representative that’s been stalking the protagonist throughout the Half-Life games, and can be seen in-game observing you from far away or inaccessible locations

9

u/teeno731 4h ago

The problem with the G-man is that it's effectively the plot twist of the first game. "That's just a guy on his way to work" "Wait why is he just walking around like the place isn't falling apart?" "Holy shit, he might not even be human?"

But anyone born after 1995 probably recognised him from Garry's Mod when they saw him, if not from his opening sequence appearance in the much more talked-about sequel.

68

u/snouz 3h ago

In Too Many Cooks, there's a murderer that becomes the central character at 4 minutes, but if you look closely, you can see him in half the shots in the background before that.

22

u/1d3333 2h ago

What a beautiful era of Adult Swim, I miss waking up in the middle of the night with the TV still playing and some absurd shit is happening

11

u/Matthew-ii 2h ago

Yeah I loved having the realization years later in life when finding content online that a strong emotional memory of mine was NOT infact my own insane dreams and sleep paralysis but just falling asleep with the TV on haha.

32

u/DrHemmington 7h ago

In Fallout 4, the main character is followed around by a guy named Deacon. He is present at some pivotal moments and just stands around pretending to be a random NPC.

Eventually he will vouch for the player so his faction trusts them, saying he has been observing them.

There is even some extra dialogue if the player managed to out manoeuvre him and avoided the encounters throughout the game.

He had even built a little lookout near the start of the game overlooking the vault that the player emerges from.

58

u/AstralMecha 8h ago

In a dumb twist version of this trope, Zero Time Dilemma

The twist is that a certain spoiler character is present, just off camera, so the player doesn't see them.

20

u/drleebot 7h ago

They do show his shadow in a few shots if you pay attention, so it's not as full a cheat as "just off-camera" makes it seem. But they do cheat in a couple other ways.

26

u/homuhomutime 7h ago

IIRC you can actually see his chair's shadow in some scenes. And characters do mention him occasionally, the game just heavily gaslights you into thinking they're referring to a different character. It's a very dumb twist but also very, very funny.

→ More replies (6)

430

u/Meanteenbirder 10h ago edited 10h ago

Eren Jaeger (Attack on Titan)

If you go back through the series, you’ll see a figure that resembles him in several scenes. Yes, that includes season 1

54

u/Ne9ativeZer0 9h ago

I feel like this isn’t the case, the manga wasn’t anywhere near this reveal when season 1 aired and I doubt isayama told production or even knew himself all the details. I feel as though these figures that look like eren aren’t intentional

44

u/comrade_batman 7h ago

It isn’t. Eren and Zeke do not time travel physically, they travel back through Grisha’s memories using the Paths that connected the Founding Titan to all Eldians. The only time Eren is “seen” is when Grisha realises an older Eren is with him during ep 1 when promising to show young Eren what he’s been working on, and then when older Eren manipulates Grisha into killing the royal family. (And even then, Grisha wouldn’t be able to see Eren, it would have been as though he was looking at himself through older Eren’s POV given how the future memories work for the Attack Titan).

→ More replies (5)

54

u/TotallyObviousBot 8h ago

Isayama knew the ending from the very beginning of the manga, the first chapter is called "To You, 2,000 Years From Now" (referencing Ymir)

He also posted the final page of the manga years before it ended iirc

→ More replies (6)

29

u/Lividlife21 8h ago

Attack on Titan is a rare case in which the author actually had the entire story planned out from ch 1

10

u/SickXigma 8h ago

I thought you were just shitposting, you mean future Eren right

17

u/Womblue 8h ago

I read this entire thread thinking it was a dumb joke, like "hidden detail: eren is in season 1" and now I have no idea what anyone is talking about.

→ More replies (3)

62

u/lazyCoil 10h ago

How would that even make sense ? He doesn't have time travel powers

127

u/Meanteenbirder 10h ago

If you watched the whole show it would make sense

54

u/lazyCoil 10h ago

He can see the future and past due to attack titan but he can't travel there , right ?

106

u/Hitei00 10h ago

The only scene I can think of that they could be referring to is when Eren's dad stares at an empty space in the room when telling Eren he'll show him the basement. We then learn later that when Eren was traveling through memories that he was standing in that exact spot.

46

u/SpiralZa 9h ago

From how I understand it, Eren basically bootstrap paradox himself into existence. The attack titan can see the memory’s of past and future users. Eren used the memories of memories to set events into play

29

u/Hitei00 9h ago

Yup. What specifically happened to make Eren become a misanthrope was seeing the memory of his future self egging his dad on to kill the royal family. Its never spelled out explicitly but the face of dispair he makes after kissing Historia's hand is identical to the one his dad made after being driven over the edge by future Eren, and just seeing the massacre shouldn't have shocked him because he already knew about it

7

u/CalzLight 7h ago

Yeah, that’s the only thing that actually is seen of ‘Eren’ in previous episodes.

The people highlighting random silhouettes in previous episodes are just making things up, Eren didn’t literally travel back in time, he sent memories of himself back in time essentially.

16

u/kdiyargebmay 9h ago

he cant time travel, but he can visit memories, even ones being currently made by the person experiencing them kinda, by giving them the memory of his own of visiting their memory, so the other person can see from their eyes, like the other person said with his dad

→ More replies (5)

80

u/KowaiSentaiYokaiger 9h ago

Nibbler from Futurama

His silhouette was actually present in the original airing of the first episode, before it was revealed that he was the one responsible for Fry getting frozen

44

u/Doomhammer24 9h ago

Ya someone even went and found an original recording of the episode and verified he wasnt edited in either- he was there from day 1

9

u/KowaiSentaiYokaiger 9h ago

This one?

That's what compelled me to post here

53

u/Luster-Purge 9h ago

In one episode of Miss Kobyiashi's Dragon Maid S (a.k.a. Season 2), Kana runs away to New York after an argument and then ends up saving another kid from kidnappers because fuck you 5000 year old electric bird dragon before going back home.

It's revealed at the end that Kobyiashi asked Torhu to keep an eye on Kanna the whole time in the case she was needed, with quick cuts showing amusing things of Tohru doing things to blend in. If you go back through the episode, she is in every place she is said to be, albeit difficult to see if you don't know she's already there.

9

u/krisslanza 8h ago

I thought about posting this one!
I remember when I watched this with a friend, at the end I was actually like, "Hang on. I want to check if she's right."
And yeah as mentioned she is in them. And once you know she is, she stands out even. But when you're watching the first time, you're probably not expecting to see her, so you just won't notice her (probably).

57

u/SlouchyGuy 8h ago

Kosh from Babylon 5.

"I've always been here" and he was

10

u/Lastoutcast123 7h ago

Also …

“What do you want?”

6

u/Chi_Law 7h ago

"Who are you?"

6

u/PaupersSerenades 6h ago

“Why are you here?”

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Lastoutcast123 7h ago

Peak mentioned

56

u/A_Human_Being_BLEEEH 6h ago

while he doesn't make a lot of in-person appearances, Stanford Pines (Gravity Falls) and items related to him make numerous appearances throughout the show, such as when Dipper and Mabel go back in time and his younger self makes a brief cameo

26

u/Setisthename 4h ago

In reverse, Stan's car always has the 'STNLYMBL' license plates from its first appearance in S1x2, despite him impersonating Stanford.

28

u/Junior-Elevator-9951 8h ago

Joshua (The World Ends with You) has a cameo in the first chapter of the game. He's formally introduced in the second week of a three-week-long game

7

u/bodmaniac 5h ago

TWEWY mentioned!

65

u/Mysterious_Man_65 10h ago edited 10h ago

Gibby Gibson protests when his friends, Carly Shay, Samantha Puckett and Freddie Benson, claim he wasn't always around and insists he actually spent quite a lot of them. They reflect and realize he was right but they just didnt truly befriend him until later on (iCarly)

22

u/tokkieee 9h ago

spoilers for black butler

the REAL ciel (our protagonist’s deceased twin brother) had been present for nearly every major event through out the story and we see several panels showing exactly where he had been as he recovered and waited patiently to reveal and reunite with his younger twin

23

u/Herobrinetic 5h ago

Arkham City, during an opening scene you can spot Azrael if you look at the rooftops

→ More replies (1)

20

u/KermitTheFraud92 9h ago

Recently Shayna from Haunted Hotel

She’s introduced as a ghost who has been haunting the hotel for a while but screws up by bumping the breakfast table in the first episode leading everyone to realise she’s alive.

If you go back to season 1 she shows up as a background host several times. One example is when Katherine is auditioning ghosts at one point she’s sitting in the crowd

→ More replies (4)

17

u/Vinon 8h ago

I don't know if its an exact fit. In the anime Baccano!, the opening showcases each character of the varied cast in turn, flashing a nameplate next to a still of them.

During the show, in the 1931 arc on board the train, we learn of the legend of the Rail Tracer, a horror myth monster that disappears passengers on the train.

The identity of the Rail Tracer is in fact Claire Stanfield, an extremely talented assassin. He was there the entire time, as one of the conductors. This reveal is kept secret even by the opening song, as he appears in it like all other characters but doesn't get a freeze frame or nameplate.

47

u/PigeonVibes 8h ago

Bruno from Encanto. He is actually hidden on every movie poster, and is seen sneaking in de the background during the song "We Don't Talk About Bruno"

21

u/ShadeofIcarus 7h ago

So that's actually Camilo as Bruno and not Bruno himself.

Brunos eyes wouldn't glow like that unless he was mid vision and he's super peculiar about his vision ritual.

→ More replies (1)

44

u/Appleonthefloor 9h ago

The spot in into the spider verse

11

u/Meanteenbirder 8h ago

The bagel effect

12

u/Rough-Frosting-2755 5h ago

Boingo from Hoodwinked

Spoiler: that cwazy wabbit’s the goodie bandit.

10

u/teeno731 4h ago

Does it count if everyone knew he was there? Like, making conversation with the main characters and everything?

27

u/Mountain-Ad876 4h ago

Bad Wolf, Doctor Who.

During the 9th doctor's run, the phrase "Bad Wolf" popped up in almost every episode. Eventually, it was revealed that it was Rose Tyler after absorbing energy from the Time Vortex sending messages to herself through time.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/friends-with-fishies 3h ago

In multiple scenes of JoJo's Bizarre Adventure part 4 the upcoming villains can be seen in crowds often. The overarching villain also appears in crowds far before he is relevant

22

u/friends-with-fishies 2h ago

The only picture of the main villain in the crowd I could find has this dumb red circle though 😭

12

u/Zeitgeist1115 3h ago

Strong Bad Email #100: when the episode goes into widescreen, Homestar is suddenly next to the computer desk. He tells Strong Bad he was always there, just that he was always "behind the black". Then again, this being Homestar who's saying this, take it with a grain of salt.

78

u/Then-Mechanic-1099 10h ago

Humpty Dumpty in the Puss in Boots movie

https://giphy.com/gifs/UnjfVDcBbMwzVd823H

70

u/Jepemega 9h ago

It doesn't count as if you go back and watch the original scenes he is not there.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/Zapan99 2h ago

Fat Neil in the series Community. During the first D&D episode, we learn that one member of the study group is responsible for coining his insulting nickname, which caused Neil's depression and near self-deletion attempt. The group helps him regain confidence, and he becomes a series regular who ends up hosting Greendale College radio station under the name Awesome Neil.

17

u/Visible_Pair3017 1h ago

self-deletion

Do you mean suicide

5

u/subs_on_a_sailboat 26m ago

Shhh! Don't get their post demonetized!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/anak_ng_nanay_ko 1h ago

Um actually in pillows and blankets Neil signs off his radio show as “Real Neil with Pipes of Steel”

→ More replies (3)

18

u/omiimonster 8h ago

adventure time had 2:
1. episode 1’s pinata was actually revealed in the last season to be the result of an experiment & lost all her memories
2. the snail that later started the apocalypse

10

u/PavlovKBI 7h ago

Manfried/Lolly doesn't really count because it was just a retcon that they pulled out later.

But the snail being in every single episode and then being a major plot catalyst feels like it has to count, even if they didn't know what they wanted to use the snail for at first (which they may have, I'm not sure)

→ More replies (2)

23

u/Bright_Eyes10 7h ago

Leelas parents watching over her

Hilda season 3 contains this same trope as well

19

u/GGTulkas 6h ago

DanDaDan: Kinta was always there

https://giphy.com/gifs/WRsOa1kedExRC6hlTj

20

u/Saragonvoid 4h ago

In an episode of Miss Kobayashi's Dragon Maid where Kanna runs off to America, at the end Tohru reveals that she was watching her the whole time, and you can actually spot her in the background on some scenes

→ More replies (1)

19

u/confusedmortal 8h ago

Mysterio appears throughout Peter's vacation keeping tabs on him before his official introduction in Spider-man Far From Home.

8

u/Cultural_Ad1331 5h ago

By the time Absolute scarecrow is introduced we find out he's always been there via his vague figures in panels numerous places or with the joker or a murder of crows that always hint to his hand in tragedys

15

u/Leif_Millelnuie 3h ago

Nibbler's shadow can be seen in the pilot episode of Futurama right before he pushes Fry's chair so that he falls in the cryogenic pod.

14

u/Ancient-Chart-9089 2h ago

Bill (Nolstagia Critic)

→ More replies (1)

11

u/darkbutton 2h ago

haunted hotel just did this! in season 2 there is a girl who isn't a ghost and everyone is like "what you aren't dead?" and she explains that her gramps told her someone from their bloodline always had to be there and she took his place when he died. there are hints in season one that were clues to her being there

→ More replies (2)