r/TragicallyHip • u/Lemons52 • 14d ago
Now for Plan A Turned 14 Yesterday!
A very underrated Hip album if you ask me, that holds two of my favourite all time Hip tunes, We Want to be It and the title track. What did you think on release day? Has the album warmed to you overtime?
16
u/Chunky-Lover53 14d ago
I was at the surprise gig for the CD launch in Kensington Market.
I got to meet the band after the show and they all signed the CD case.
Gord signed my CD. Scratched out the title and wrote “chunkylover53’s blues” on it.
I now use the image for my iTunes playlist.
10
8
u/BrodAdams 14d ago
A couple really good songs off this one, but j need to revisit it for sure. My favorite is probably Goodnight Attawapiskat. Caught the Moncton show February 2013 on the tour supporting this record. Got one of Rob's picks he flung while playing this song - he tossed it as he started playing the solo, and I watched it bounce off the stage between the stage and the barrier. Got a security guards attention and asked if he could grab it for me. He acted like he was going to keep it at first, but it was all in jest and he ultimately did give it to me. Still have it.
At Transformation first and then Grace, Too second was a really cool way to start off the show. Song had a lot of energy.
Streets Ahead, Man Machine Poem and The Lookahead are all great tunes, as well. Thanks for the reminder on this one!
3
u/Lemons52 14d ago
The version of At Transformation on the recent live album of the last tour goes particularly hard, I think
8
u/Jupiter_Rising2212 14d ago
I had fallen away from the Hip for a while, but this album pulled me back in. Not their best, but far from their worst.
8
u/starslayer88 14d ago
I want to help you lift enormous things A pinch, a sting, I don't feel a thing As the earth revolves around the sun
2
u/Pammyhammy3 13d ago
Whenever a man
tries to be more like a machine
he breaks down
And
Good evening folks we are the silver poets here in our thousand mile suitsYeah this is a solid album
5
u/modestmandrakeman 14d ago
At Transformation is a top Hip song for me so it’s definitely my favourite off this album
4
u/LDeezy324 14d ago
Has some good tunes - At Transformation, really like Streets Ahead, We Want To Be It (which was incredible to hear Gord sing live), The Modern Spirit. I like the final album more in terms of their output in this era but I got to see them in Halifax on this tour and that rocked.
4
u/Lemons52 14d ago
Funnily enough, I've heard from a few people here that hearing We Want to Be It live locked them back in to Hip fandom. It is a ripper! I really like a version of the title track with Sarah Harmer that's on Youtube, too.
1
u/LDeezy324 14d ago
He always got so into it, full body heaves and he’d do the mic kick stand bit a lot during it too. Gonna have to check that version out! Thanks for the heads up.
3
u/Shazbotanist 14d ago
“Lookahead,” “Man Machine Poem,” and especially “Modern Spirit” (which should have been a single!) are bangers. The rest, okay. But decent album, overall.
3
u/Bubbly_Ad6421 14d ago
My wife and I were there for the album release at the Supermarket.
She belted out the lyrics to Streets Ahead point blank to Gord's face. He kind of shook his head and was either impressed, disgusted, or both.
2
2
6
u/Woodbridge9 14d ago
There are a few good tracks on this but this one is a slog for me to listen to the entire thing.
0
1
u/Tony4Tokes 14d ago
Excellent album and songs - Gord really belts the vocals on this one -
but I'm not a fan of the mixing/mastering. It's not terrible per se but it's really squashed, not as dynamic as it should be, sounds a bit bright and thin in areas. Take the lush sound production of The Depression Suite and apply it to these songs please. Unfortunately this is the one that will be less likely to get a remaster but it's the one that would benefit the most from it.
That being said, I still play it often.
1
u/citizen-erased2026 14d ago
This a a great album, lots of good tumes... Man Machine Poem is a stand out for me, also love we want to be it, done and done and about this map
1
u/Theweirdkid_inclass 14d ago
So underrated! It made me realize the band does not have one bad album
1
u/LawstinTransition 14d ago
I get that this post is appreciating the album's overlooked features, but it is easily their worst album, and it's not close.
1
u/SportsCasters 14d ago
We Want to Be It is my third favorite behind Three Pistols and Emperor Penguin. They played a show in Buffalo under the skyway and it was the first time I heard it. It was before the album. For the next 3 weeks I just kept mumbling drip, drip, drip. So many relatable lines. Maybe it’s 2 over Emperor Penguin. Doesn’t matter. It’s 3 Pistols and then those two next.
2
1
1
0
u/DeanCorp80 12d ago
Might be my least favourite of the catalogue. Goodnight Atiwapiskat and at transformation are dope though.
25
u/Dark_Canuck1 14d ago
We Want To Be It is a top song for me. One of Gord’s best vocal deliveries in my opinion. Love the chorus.