RESEARCH TITLE: THE LAW OF NATURE VS UNSCIENTIFIC LAW - WHY NATURE CREATED ONLY TWO GENDERS AND WHY INDIA IS SLOWLY ACCEPTING A THIRD
Student Name: Yogesh Manjramkar
Course: BA Final Year
Place: Parbhani, Maharashtra
Date: 14th October 2026
ABSTRACT
This paper is written to understand who is making laws about 3D Gender in India, why India is slowly accepting it, and what the real Body Science says. This paper is not written with hate. It is written with pure science - from deep roots to advance forensics. The main question is - What is the Law of Nature?
CHAPTER 1: WHO IS MAKING UNSCIENTIFIC LAWS IN INDIA?
Three authorities have made this law without taking a full opinion from Forensic Biology.
1. The Supreme Court of India - NALSA Judgment 2014:
In 2014, the Supreme Court gave a historic judgment. It said that transgender people should get equal rights - Aadhaar card, voter ID, job, education. This was a good judgment for humanity. Everyone deserves to live with dignity.
But the problem started after the judgment. The judgment was about Rights to Live. But it was misinterpreted as Right to Change Biology. Schools and colleges started changing biology textbooks. They started teaching that gender is a choice, not a biological code. The Court gave rights, but NGOs changed science.
2. The Parliament of India - Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019:
In 2019, Parliament passed this Act. It says a person can change his gender by giving an application to the District Magistrate.
But this Act never asked the Forensic Doctor: Can you change XX to XY? Can you change a male pelvis bone to a female pelvis bone? Can you change DNA in blood? The answer is No. So the law gives a certificate, but biology does not change. This makes the law unscientific.
3. Influence of Foreign NGOs and International Pressure:
Many international organizations put pressure on India. They give funding to schools and say "Include gender ideology". Their culture is different. In India, our culture is based on Family and Lineage (Vansh), which runs only on male and female union. So foreign ideology is being imposed on Indian nature without scientific discussion.
CHAPTER 2: WHY IS INDIA ACCEPTING IT SLOWLY?
India is a very kind and emotional country. That is why we are accepting it slowly. There are three main reasons:
Reason A: Lack of Knowledge of Body Science:
90% of students in India do not know how a baby is made inside the womb. They do not know what is SRY gene, what is XX and XY, what is testosterone. When people do not know deep body science, they accept any new word as truth. If you do not teach real science, unscientific laws will be accepted.
Reason B: Misuse of Kindness:
Indians are very kind-hearted. When someone says "We are suffering, please help us", we immediately say yes. We said yes for humanity. But we did not ask - What will be the effect of this yes on a 10-year-old child's mind? Our kindness was used to pass a law without scientific debate.
Reason C: Media, Film and Social Media:
Films and Instagram reels show 3D Gender as modern, fashionable and progressive. A child of 14 years sees it and thinks it is cool. He does not know the forensic science behind it. Media never shows the DNA lab report. It only shows emotion. So emotion is winning over science.
CHAPTER 3: THE REAL BODY SCIENCE - FROM DEEP ROOT TO ADVANCE FORENSIC
This is the science which should be taught in every school.
Part A: The Deepest Root - The Rule of Two:
Nature has only one rule for reproduction of humans. It needs two.
Male provides Sperm with 23 chromosomes.
Female provides Egg with 23 chromosomes.
Together they make a new human with 46 chromosomes.
There is no third type of sperm or third type of egg in nature. If a third gender could produce a child, nature would have made a third type of gamete. But nature never made it. This proves that nature made only two for creation. This is mentioned in Manusmriti 1.32 - Creator divided himself into two.
Part B: Womb Science - How a Body is Made (The Most Important):
For first 6 weeks in the mother's womb, every embryo is exactly the same. There is no boy, no girl.
In the 7th week, nature takes a final decision.
If the embryo has a Y chromosome, a gene called SRY gene becomes active. SRY gives an order - Make Testis. Testis produces testosterone hormone. The baby becomes a boy. Genetic code is XY.
If the embryo has no Y chromosome, SRY gene never becomes active. The baby automatically becomes a girl. Genetic code is XX.
This is the Binary Code of Nature. 100% of human beings are made from this code. There is no third code like ZZZ.
Part C: Then Why Does 3D Gender Appear? - The Science of Variation:
If nature made only two codes, why do we see variation?
Medical science calls it "Variation due to Imbalance, Not a New Creation."
Example: Nature made eyes to see clearly. But sometimes a child is born with cataract. Is cataract a third type of eye? No. It is a disturbance that happened while the eye was being made.
Similarly, 3D Gender is not a new design by God. It is a variation.
Hormonal Imbalance in Womb: During the 7th week, if the testosterone signal comes too low, too high, or at the wrong time, the body development gets confused. In medical books, this is called DSD - Disorder of Sex Development. It happens in only 0.018% of births.
Chromosomal Variation: Sometimes instead of XX or XY, a child gets XXY or XYY. But forensic lab still classifies it as a variation of male or female based on hormone dominance. No independent chromosome for 3D Gender exists in the entire human genome.
Part D: Advance Forensics - The Proof No Court Can Deny:
This is bullet-proof proof.
DNA Forensics: In any police forensic lab, if blood, hair, saliva or semen is found, the DNA test result is always XX or XY. Till today, no forensic lab in India or in the world has a machine that says "This is DNA of 3D Gender". Because nature never made it.
Bone Forensics (Anthropology): If a skeleton is found after 1000 years, forensic doctors check the pelvis bone. Female pelvis is wide for childbirth. Male pelvis is narrow and tall. There is no third type of pelvis bone ever found in human history.
Psychiatry Forensics (WHO ICD-11): The World Health Organization says in ICD-11 - Being transgender is not a mental illness. But the stress a person feels when his body and mind do not match is called Gender Dysphoria. The recommended treatment is respectful psychological counselling and family support first, not surgery first.
CHAPTER 4: WHAT WILL HAPPEN IF UNSCIENTIFIC LAW CONTINUES?
If we continue to accept unscientific law without body science:
Forensic System Will Fail: If a crime happens and blood is found, and the form says 3D Gender, the lab cannot give a clear report. Criminals will take advantage.
Children's Mental Health Will Be Affected: Science says the human brain develops fully till age 25. If you tell a 12-year-old child "You can choose if you are a boy or girl", his brain will become confused. This is against Child Psychology.
Family System Will Become Weak: Our Indian family system, Vansh, lineage - all run on the union of male and female. If we say third can also create lineage, we are going against the law of reproduction.
CHAPTER 5: WHAT SHOULD BE THE CORRECT LAW? - MY SOLUTION
My demand is not based on hate. It is based on science.
Right to Live is Different from Right to Change Biology: Everyone deserves equal right to live, eat, get a job, get education. I fully support that. But Right to Live does not mean Right to Change Biology Textbook. Give rights to live, but do not change the science of the body.
My Proposed Model for Government Forms:
Instead of 3 equal options, forms should have:
Biological Gender (Forensic Proof): [ ] Boy (XY) [ ] Girl (XX)
Additional Support Needed (if any variation): [ ] Counselling Support Needed
This way, everyone gets respect, and science is also protected.
- Bring Back Real Body Science in Schools:
From Class 8, teach children - What is SRY gene? What is XX and XY? What is DNA? What is Forensic Anthropology? When a child understands science, he will not get confused by ideology.
FINAL CONCLUSION
Laws were made by people with good hearts but without taking full advice from forensic biology. And India is slowly accepting them because people do not know deep body science.
The truth from root to top is same:
Root Level (Shastra) says 2.
Middle Level (Womb Biology) says 2.
Top Level (DNA and Bone Forensics) says 2.
What we call 3D Gender is not a third design. It is a natural variation that happens while the two designs are being made. It needs counselling and medical support, not a third compulsory column in children's forms.
God made two. Science proved two. Forensics found two. There is no third.
Research by:
Yogesh Manjramkar, BA Final Year, Parbhani, Maharashtra