r/WarCollege • u/chad_kun5145 • 1d ago
How did a formed infantry unit get past a friendly unit already standing in its way?
I'm making a real time battle game set in Warring States China (260 - 220 BC). Each soldier is simulated individually, and units of about 100 men fight in formation. The movement is what I keep getting wrong, so I'd like to know how it actually worked, not how other games fake it.
What I'm stuck on:
- Moving as one piece. When a unit of ~100 marched across a field, did it keep its exact ranks and files the whole way? Or did it move loosely and re-dress when it stopped? How much did the lines wobble in practice?
- Turning. When a block had to face a new direction, did it wheel, with one end pivoting and the outer files walking faster? Or did every man turn on the spot, so the back rank became the front? Which was normal, and when would you pick one over the other?
- Getting past friendly units. This is the big one. Say a rear unit has to move forward, and a friendly unit is already formed in front of it. What happened? Did the front unit open its files to let them through? Did the rear unit march around? Were there deliberate gaps between units for exactly this, like the intervals people describe for Roman maniples? Or did the two units swap places some other way?
- Gaps in the line. In a battle line made of many units, did units stand shoulder to shoulder as one continuous front, or with gaps between them? If there were gaps, how wide, and why didn't the enemy just pour into them?
- Replacing a tired front unit. During a long fight, how did a fresh unit take over from one already in contact? Did the tired unit pull back through the fresh one, or did the fresh one push forward through it?
- The charge. In the last stretch before contact, did men run? Did they keep their ranks at a run, or did the formation loosen on purpose?
Warring States China is where I need answers most. But if the good evidence is Greek, Roman, or early modern drill, I'll take that, and I'd be grateful for an explanation of what probably carried over and what didn't.
Book or source names are hugely appreciated. I'd rather read the real thing than guess.
9
Upvotes
3
u/Gasmask134 12h ago edited 12h ago
I can't really give any answers of the time periods you are asking about, but information from the 19th century, manly the American Civil War, might still be of some use as a general idea (after all they were also attempting to solve the subtlely difficult problem of marching a lot of people in formations)
edit: most of this is about more regimental and brigade level stuff than 100 men as you ask. 100 men is roughly a single company and is usually a small part of a larger unit that actually conducted manuvers