r/chanceme • u/One-Possibility-4223 • 10h ago
I asked 52 Penn students what actually worked in their applications. Check it out below.
I’m a student here (Wharton), and a good chunk of this info comes from people I know personally. Most applied ED, followed by RD and a few transfers. 19 Wharton students. 21 College. 8 Engineering. 2 Nursing. 2 Dual-Degree (M&T + LSM). I grouped their responses into 3 key takeaways (which I find very crucial), and also will share some particular answers to survey questions that will hopefully be of value.
1) Build one story, out of things you already do
Everyone could name the story their application told, and the essay, activities, and Why Penn all supported it. I think it's CRUCIAL applicants work the admissions process backwards. Be introspective and think about how you want to frame yourself as an applicant. How do you want the admissions team to view you when they read your app? Then, honestly tie together the experiences you've had + things you've pursued, and why you did them, to support his frame. This narrative should be so obvious on the personal statement, and it should also shine through on your supplementals + activities list. Also, about 15 people built that story around something they almost didn’t list: a job, caring for a family member, the weekend farmers market, the family business. So don't try to speed-run this process. Be thoughtful, be intentional, and be honest!
2. Small and specific beats big and impressive
This came up in almost every section of the survey responses. People wrote essays about one scene instead of their whole life. They named actual professors and labs in the Why Penn supplemental. They used real numbers in their activities - even when they look "small." And the most common thing people stressed about that they now believe didn’t matter at all was whether or not some of their extracurriculars were "impressive enough." For example, one of my classmates described her honey business and said "It made $900. It was fine. What mattered was that it was real, and I seriously enjoyed it." So keep it authentic, and make it specific. The authenticity shows you are being honest, and the specificity shows you are intentional and actually care about it. I would make sure to apply this thought process to every single written component of the application.
3. Your voice and your context are the advantage
I get the worry of "How am I going to stand out?" when you’re brainstorming a narrative and drafting essays. It feels super tricky.
Hear this.. 8 rural, international, or working-class students said that trying to look like a "typical" applicant would have been their biggest mistake. One almost padded his list with online clubs to look "normal" before realizing that coming from a rural place Penn rarely hears from was the strongest thing he had. Admissions sees your school profile, so don't forget that you’re judged on what was available to you. The schools reviewing you essentially do the context side for you - but you can lean into where you come from on the written components of your app to really make your essays you.
Also, your voice is something nobody else can copy. One student had to rewrite a polished counselor draft so it sounded like "a 17-year-old who’s annoyed about the current state of political discourse, which I am." Another wrote about her dad pricking his finger at the dinner table and joking about it: "a little funny and a little sad." This isn’t an anti-counselor take. Sometimes it’s about finding the right counselor, one who guides you without replacing your voice.
And here's some of those questions/answers I mentioned earlier:
What made your essay work?
"Small, specific moments read as true."
"Make sure the family member is the setting, not the main character. You’re the main character."
"Engineering essays are better when they show iteration, not just a happy ending."
How did you choose and order your activities? **Common theme of ordering by your story, not by prestige.
"I ordered by relevance to my story rather than by impressiveness."
"For a working student, the time is the point." (List hours first + avoid generic jargon like "guaranteed customer satisfaction")
"Six strong ones beat ten filler activities"
What would you tell your high school self?
"The thing you already do every day might be the most meaningful thing on the whole app."
"Stop apologizing for not having a passion project. Working counts. Side hobbies can count"
"Ask someone outside of your typical life to read your essays. All my hometown friends thought my story was normal. Looking back, I think Penn found it extraordinary."
"You belong in these applications. I almost didn’t send it."
And that's it! Let me know if you have any questions. My dms are open. I've been helping students write their essays + strategically structure their applications for the past few cycles, and this is the first time I've compiled a larger resource at scale from the other past applicants around me. Happy to help anyone one on one ahead of the ED deadline!