r/coins • u/Specific_Eagle365 • 1d ago
Advice Hold or Sell?
Got it graded recently. Should I sell now or hold for the next 30 years?
29
u/bobsbananawater 1d ago
Thats one of those coins you pass on to your grandchild ..... if you dont have grandchildren i will accept it on behalf of my grandson
41
u/Equivalent_Net_3752 1d ago
Dude I am jealous beyond words. That is the coolest coin ever. I would keep it under literally any circumstance (except selling it to me).
6
u/arctic-apis 1d ago
yeah this is one of the last coins I need to complete my set of mercs
3
10
u/KNTdynooomite 1d ago
If you are an investor, sell. Interest in this coin is higher right now than it is likely to ever be again. If you are a collector, hold. It's unlikely you'll ever find another one of this quality.
2
u/ubergeeks 21h ago
Disagree strongly on that assessment. For many yes but this one will keep a premium.
9
u/Comfortable_Tiger904 13h ago
Don’t know what I’m doing wrong but I can never see my post. Hold that coin. They were only 5000 of those coins minted! I don’t know what the population is yet.. with the bicentennial year and the dual date that will bring back a nice return!
8
u/PatronSaint7 1d ago
Sweet coin my friend I’d sell it to this guy…me :)
Seriously though, sweet coin I’d hold on to it.
10
u/mikeyj198 1d ago
history has shown that these high grade bullion coins tend to lose value over time (with a few exceptions obviously).
If you want the coin then keep it. If you want palladium i would sell this one and buy more quantity of bullion palladium.
8
u/arctic-apis 1d ago
this one will probably carry a premium for a while. low mintage and ms70cac doesnt get nicer than that.
1
8
u/ProudAmerican632 1d ago
Hold. Palladium will hit over $3K again coupled with the grade CAC and the liberty bell privy mark it’ll be worth a huge sum.
6
u/Specific-Control-652 1d ago
Palladium hasn’t come close to hitting $3000 in over five years…. You got a better chance of platinum hitting 3000 before Palladium.
5
u/beltbucklebellybite 13h ago
My feeling is that they won't appreciate much over inflation in the future and with the current hype interest is higher now than it will be going out. Very limited collector market for these. Look for a premium now
4
u/Flywolf25 5h ago
I just checked the design hands down one of the coolest coins mint has designed in years I’d hold it this is so beautiful
3
3
3
u/TheMarko9 1d ago
Cmon now. Don’t leave us hanging… show us the reverse!
7
3
5
u/SpotIsALie 1d ago edited 1d ago
Eh... Palladium price is generally down atm but I would not keep this for 30 years. Modern bullion like this can easily lose its value in the future when hype goes down. Palladium also really isnt highly-sought after or desireable pm.
5k minted seems low but it really isnt. All of those 5k will be uncirculated and in BU condition and all of the scarcity is purely artificial with modern stuff. You can buy them now for about $2.5k, which is ~$1.5K of premium. The market for these seems niche at best.
I dont see this going much higher unless the price of the metal moves and even then, anyone buying palladium for the metal value would never buy this.
If it were me I would sell it and buy pre-33 gold instead in a heartbeat and feel much more comfortable with my investment.
0
1d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/coins-ModTeam 1d ago
Your post/comment was removed because the mods feel it doesn't show due respect to the hobby, and to our fellow collectors.
1
u/SpotIsALie 1d ago
Sold out by scalpers looking to quick flip it. I specifically stated numerous times that I am not confident in it retaining value in the coming years.
You want to buy $2500 modern palladium bullion @ $1500 over melt, by all means please do.
2
u/kazoodac 1d ago
Wish I could have gotten one, my first child was just born and I wanted to get something special to commemorate the occasion! I had an order but sadly they cancelled it, so I’ll just be watching the secondary market for the next few years.
2
u/Specific_Eagle365 1d ago
I was so worried mine was going to get canceled. It was processing for two weeks and eventually shipped
2
2
2
2
2
3
u/QuinnHart 1d ago
I’d sell, but I’m not interested in bullion. If you like it, keep it.
The premium for a MS-70 will lower the longer you wait, and, if you don’t care for it, now is the time to sell. However, the value will eventually rise with the metal content’s value. Will it increase in value above the rate of inflation? Who knows!
1
1d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/coins-ModTeam 1d ago
Your post/comment was removed due to political or religious discussion which is not relevant to numismatics. We do not allow any kind of political or religious commentary that can lead to arguments.
2
2
u/Comfortable_Tiger904 13h ago
Hold that piece! They only meant 5000 of them. I’m not a big fan of Palladium, but in this case that coin is worth it to hold! Can I ask what you paid for it?
2
2
1
u/indomike14 1d ago
What would you sell it for?
3
1
1
1
u/Hillmantle 1d ago
If you’re looking to make money, now’s the time. I have a bunch of 76 silver sets I got for melt.
1
1
u/Energy_Turtle 1d ago
Depends on your goal, but I'd personally sell it. Every single one is going to be in this good of condition or extremely close. Combined with the current hype of CAC slabs, and this is the king of manufactured, pay to play scarcity. I don't trust anything made to a collectible to actually remain a long term collectible. I definitely wouldn't bet on it to be a boost to my retirement or anything like that. If you like it, keep it. If you don't, sell it and buy something you like. If you're trying to invest, sell it and put the money in your retirement account.
1
u/intrepidagent4444 1d ago
If you like it keep it. If not sell it and try to profit from any remaining semiquincentennial fervor.
1
23h ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/coins-ModTeam 23h ago
Hello! Your comment was removed because commercial activity is not allowed here.
You can buy, sell, or trade coins in several other subreddits, e.g. r/CoinSales, r/PMsforsale, r/CoinBay, or r/CoinSwap.
We also limit links to commercial sites.
If you have a coin-related service or product to offer, please check the pinned posts to see if there is a current "r/coins Self-Promotion Thread".
1
1
1
1
1
u/metalaxeyyd 7h ago
I would say sell now. Palladium is at a good market price plus with this being a current coin, you can get more if a premium since more people are aware of the mintage and all the series. My fear would be if you hold it, you will only get palladium melt and not premiun on the coin itself in the future if you go to sell it
1
1
u/Plane-Intern5687 1h ago
Doesn't the CAC sticker usually mean it's a higher grade than the billed grade? And it can't be higher than 70 so I'm confused
1
1
1
u/Ok_Palpitation_1622 1d ago
If the liberty bell privy commands a substantial premium right now I would sell. All this gimmicky cash grab stuff the mint is pumping out now is probably not going to age well.
1
1
0
u/berlenba 1d ago
Do you need the money? If yes, then sell. If you don’t need the money, then don’t sell. Why so hard the thinking?
0
0
32
u/spock1117 1d ago
Only 5000 minted….SAVE!