r/comics • Smuggies • Jul 28 '26

OC Please resist responsibly

24.1k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

889

u/NoBizlikeChloeBiz Jul 28 '26

Yeah, this is a huge (purposeful) revision of the history of change and progress. Disruption is an integral part of advocating for change, sometimes violent sometimes not. If you can be ignored, you will be.

But when the dust settles, the people in power say "we're really doing this because of all of the kind, non-disruptive people. In fact, this would have happened faster without all of those pesky disruptive protests." And the news and the history books and the biopics all start to reflect that narrative until people have forgotten the relationship between disruption and change.

264

u/Extension_Problem223 Jul 28 '26

It's genius, really. They had a perfect narrative of MLK and the "peaceful protest wing" being the good guys and Malcom X and his "radical violent Black supremacy wing" as the bad guys. Very easy for kids to understand, and now the kids who learned those lessons are adults who think you get what you want from our owners by asking nicely. Any protest that isn't a completely useless clever sign-making competition on a sidewalk is illegitimate and the grown-up liberals have to distance themselves from it.

I seriously think the strategy of posthumously de-fanging MLK and separating him from the broader Black Liberation movement has almost single-handedly allowed the rise of fascism and the erosion of labor and civil rights and living standards. Not to mention the fact that they killed all of the leaders of the various movements, so they're not exactly around to give us their thoughts today.

114

u/Zombies4EvaDude Jul 28 '26

Honestly it needed both to succeed. Malcolm X made MLK’s demands look reasonable, but they capitalized on that fact to manipulate the history books.

13

u/Extension_Problem223 Jul 28 '26

"This Nonviolent Stuff'll Get You Killed" by Charles Cobb provides a great history of this