Warning that this is pretty long and ramble-y, but I feel like I would've wanted to read something like this before making the leap.
TLDR: Great option for people struggling with excessive short form content use due to its limited software. Significant durability issues, but the phone remains usable; if you purchase this model, buy the protective case. Consider purchasing the Pro instead. Flip phone, so, automatically cool and awesome. Overall, like a 7.5 or 8/10 experience- some significant downsides but the positives are super worth it.
After using this phone as my primary device, I wanted to share my in-depth thoughts and experience with it. I bought the F1 Horizon Eagle more than a year ago after some struggles with a pretty severe dependency on screens and short form content. I included a little more about why I decided to make the switch later in the post because it adds some valuable context as to why I consider some things "pros" that others might consider "cons".
My review of the F1 Horizon Eagle:
Why I chose the F1 Horizon Eagle:
- I needed to have email on my phone for work (at the time)
- It doesn't have an internet browser, so I can't get onto YouTube
- It has Waze
- No app store
- Camera
- Ability to send/receive photos over text
- I wanted a flip phone (because they're fun and really for no other reason)
- It was cheaper than the Pro (I wasn't willing to commit at first, regret that)
First 30 days:
The phone came with its stand charger, charging cord, and use/care instructions. The packaging it came in was memorably well designed, or at least I liked how it looked. There was a pre-installed glass screen protector on the exterior display. Setup was easy- I just switched my Verizon SIM card right into it and it was good to use, same day. I didn't try transferring any data, mostly because I wanted a fresh start, so I don't know how well the number-link works.
It has hotspot which made the initial switch smoother. I could hotspot my old smartphone to use things I wasn't ready to get rid of such as Google Maps and my banking app. I could hotspot my laptop for work. Highly recommend getting a dumbphone with hotspot for your first. You can't take videos or receive them over text. It's been a noticeable downside but comes up less often for me than I expected now that I don't need to for work.
The camera quality wasn't incredible but got the job done when I needed to send my old bosses photos.
Immediately after the warranty expired (aka 30+ days):
(Disclaimer: I am not nice to my electronics; I should have bought the phone case and didn't.)
Two days after the warranty expired, I dropped it for the first time. Immediately, the screen protector shattered and the inside screen broke. I dropped it a couple more times. The blue color on the outside plastic got super scratched up. The touch screen stopped working properly. I started having issues with the GPS. I called customer support and the person I spoke to wasn't very helpful or empathetic to my situation. A few weeks later, the charging/ data transfer port stopped charging the phone without tweaking the position of the cord. After about a year of very spare use, the port stopped working altogether. I work in a humid environment and since there isn't an air-tight seal around the internal components, the camera got salt on the lens within a few months of use and now takes blurry photos.
Some more minor bumps include:
- It's a dust magnet, which gets inside everything very easily
- The stand charger connection isn't super tight, so if the phone is leaning to the wrong side of the stand, it doesn't charge. I've only run into this issue a couple of times since it's obvious when it's not charging.
- Battery life has remained good enough to last all day the whole time I've had it, except when I use hotspot or Waze. Both drain the battery life pretty quickly, but if they're used at the same time, my phone doesn't last more than a couple hours.
- Updates to the OS happen frequently (which is mostly good) but there's a lot of noticeable, small changes which can be surprising (ex: at one point all my contacts didn't have a ringtone anymore unless I set one, so it was like my phone was on silent all the time).
- For some reason my GPS doesn't work unless I hold it in a specific spot in my car (I rest it on top of my steering wheel in front of the gauge cluster). I don't use it for daily navigation, so it's NBD. Although, I initially assumed it was broken and couldn't find any help about the issue, even from customer service.
Once I got used to everything, though, none of these issues were things that disrupted my life. I greatly preferred the time I got back in my day to any small annoyances the phone caused. I could still charge the phone with the stand charger, and the number pad meant the phone is still completely usable without the touch screen. From other reviews, it sounds like I could have avoided most of the downsides by getting the Pro.
Positives:
Despite all the negatives, I would still recommend this phone to someone with similar needs/ wants to mine. I am very happy with everything else. It was exactly what I was expecting in terms of its daily function and I'm so satisfied with that. Here's everything I can think of that I like about it:
- Battery lasts all day with normal use
- Despite all my abuse, it still works!
- I have not found a work-around to getting on the internet/ short form content on the phone
- UI is easy to understand
- Customizability isn't zero: Love all the ringtones and I can set my background to a photo
- Is exactly what I needed to start curbing my phone addiction
My thoughts on dumbphones as a first-time user:
I made the switch because I was very dependent on short-form content. Covid was pretty hard on me, and I was not doing well. My primary vice was TikTok. I caught myself opening it not just every moment I was slightly bored, but also every time I was feeling any sort of negative emotion. There was literally a point where I realized that I was numb to the feeling in my legs while using it- not that they had fallen asleep, but that I was so dissociated into my phone that I wasn't feeling my body. Every second of free time was gone. I had no hobbies. I wasn't interested in improving my situation because it was so easy to ignore it. Eventually, I was scrolling at work and while I was driving. I didn't want to hurt anybody, so I realized it was time to make a change. I attempted for quite a while to dumb down my smartphone so I could keep using it. I tried parent controls, downloading restrictive apps, deleting TikTok completely, using battery saver to simplify my OS, but it always led back to me using TikTok again. If it wasn't TikTok, it was YT shorts or Snapchat. If it wasn't those, it was watching YT shorts using my browser. I realized none of it was working, so I needed to limit myself. I had always wanted a flip phone, and had recently heard of dumbphone finder, so this seemed like the closest logical leap.
The transition was slow, but I was careful to be nice to myself while I was doing it. I knew shaming myself for going back to my old phone over and over was just going to lead to me abandoning the attempt at being a dumbphone user. Scrolling on TikTok isn't good, but it's a lot better than some of my other coping strategies, so when I needed it, I used it (& still sometimes do). It took me a good 6 months to really use it without using the hotspot to turn on my old phone. I had to make a lot of mistakes to know what I needed to stop using it- a camera, some cash stored in a few spots, a notebook, etc. Plus, a big part of the reason I stopped using my old phone was because I got a job that didn't need video sent over text anymore.
How big of an impact has it had on my short form content use? I still watch YouTube shorts sometimes because of my laptop and my smart TV, but it has become much easier to feel when I am struggling thanks to that. If I'm willing to open shorts on my TV and watch them for hours, I know something is wrong and I can identify it easier when I have time to think in the car and while I'm out of the house.
It can be a bit of a bummer to watch people struggle with phone addiction and not even care/ notice because it's so normalized to spend so much time on your phone. Sometimes people don't really take phone dependance seriously because it's so widespread and under-researched.
It isn't the easiest thing to get used to, having a dumbphone. Trying to navigate and getting lost the first few times when your phone dies while you're out is tricky but gets less terrifying each time it happens until it's normal. Figuring out how to be bored again is so hard and addressing the things that you've been ignoring is even worse, but it's worth it. On the other side is something more fulfilling. You realize how nice people really are with day-to-day stuff. Asking strangers for directions to your destination, bumming a few bucks off of someone because you forgot your wallet and ran out of gas, asking for accommodations when certain tasks require a smartphone- people really are very willing to help when you need it. But I'm not dropping money on useless stuff anymore because I don't have my wallet & bank app on my phone, so I actually have to think about my money. I have hobbies again (roller skating and painting have been great!). I'm actually paying attention to my needs. The journey isn't over, but I'm on my way to where I want to be.
Overall, 10/10 would recommend a dumbphone to anyone who's ready to work on their phone dependance. And the F1 horizon is a good one!