Sony has requested to further it but Miazaki specifically told them no, he had a falling out with them and doesn’t trust them to do what he wants with the IP and since they own it, it means it’s dead
...if they own the IP there is nothing Miazaki can say to prevent them to do what they want to do with it, this is nonsense that is being parroted over and over again, game developper don't get a say in how the game publisher publish the game -_-
Idk why the other people you got into arguments with couldn't explain the very obvious point you need spelled out for you.
Yes a dev has no rights over what Sony does with the IP, obviously.
But FromSoft has to agree to make it for it to be good. Sony could hire some company to make what is basically a shitty knock off but people don't buy FromSoft games because of the IP. They buy them because FromSoft makes good games.
Holding the IP makes more sense then burning money just to get spite from gamers and FromSoft alike.
What truth? Sony is the game publisher, they own the IP, Miazaki could throw a tantrum and it wouldn't change jack shit he and FromSoft can't tell the owner of the IP what to do with the IP.
Miazaki would have zero control over what the fuck Sony does with their IP lol, why the fuck people believe this nonsense. And Miazaki has in fact said in multiple interview that he wouldn't mind seeing one!
The way the agreement for the IP worked when written, Sony has to have approval from FromSoft to make content with it, it was part of the agreement they made to get FromSoft to make it PS Exclusive. They had a falling out because FromSoft or Miazaki or someone else higher up in FromSoft didn’t like how Demon Souls Remake was handled and thus they refuse to let anyone touch their IP’s except themselves and they’re busy with new projects thus BB is trapped in dead IP land.
Lol no they don't, you have no idea what's in the contract and no company would agree to those terms. Sony owns the ip and can do whatever they want with it
"You have no idea what's in the contract, nobody knows what's in the contract except for me!!! Only I know about the legal agreement made between these two companies!!! Me and nobody else!!!"
I never claimed to know the details of the contract, lol, but we do know for a fact that Sony owns the IP in totality and don't need Fromsift's permission to continue or remake the game.
"Sony owns the Bloodborne series, but Yoshida said in the interview that he believed Sony would respect Miyazaki’s wishes about not making a remake, and that appears to be how things played out"
Thank you for providing a source that proves MY point. 😂🤦🏼
nobody is debating that Sony own the IP, but that means NOTHING if they wont use the IP without Fromsofts blessing, who are the ones saying no to the remake. Stop arguing semantics.
People agree to terms like this ALL the time lmao, see: Resident Evil movies, literally ALL the live action’s technically have the IP but can’t do whatever they want with it.
123
u/TheGrimmBorne 7h ago
Sony has requested to further it but Miazaki specifically told them no, he had a falling out with them and doesn’t trust them to do what he wants with the IP and since they own it, it means it’s dead