r/predator • • Sep 11 '26

Books/Comics It will never happen due to film rights issues. But this comic could have made a cool movie

Post image

Never been a big DC/super hero film fan, but I'll a bit of wiggle room Batman depending on the iteration. I just re-read this classic (admittedly #2 and #3 suck) and dreamed of this being turned into a movie. It actually works well as a one-off story; much better than it actually sounds on paper. Obviously with Disney owning 20th Century/Predator and WB owning DC it'll never happen unfortunately.

215 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

15

u/South_Buy_3175 Sep 11 '26

Yeah Batman v Predator was a surprisingly solid crossover, would be a dream live action project but it’ll never happen.

I’d settle for Disney reprinting it in a big omnibus though, Predator had a few crossovers with DC and it’d be nice not to have them collected.

Plus with Marvel comics doing crossovers with DC recently there’s a non-zero chance it could happen.

5

u/James_Jim_Downing Sep 11 '26

Stimmt oder predator vs judge dredd bleib auch noch in weiter ferne Aber sie könnten fire and stone. Life and death etc eine chance geben die fans würden es lieben

2

u/UncleSkrewtape Sep 11 '26

Can’t forget Predator vs. Billy the Kid

1

u/James_Jim_Downing Sep 11 '26

Predator vs Tarzan in the lost world was ok too

6

u/MerpingtonDad Sep 11 '26

I’m sure we’ll see a collection at some point. Both DC and Marvel seem to have settled their differences post-Quesada, so they’re back to not leaving money on the table.

5

u/Ashamed_Ladder6161 Sep 11 '26

I was so surprised how good it was. Great writing, grounded aesthetic, mature, bloody, and some great set prices. Love the boxing match opener, inspired, and I always felt sorry for the woman who dies saving Gordon.

15

u/SecretlyImRetarded Sep 11 '26

Check out batman dead end. Maybe it would scratch your itch a little

5

u/Milhouse2078 Sep 11 '26

Great short, highly recommend.

5

u/MerpingtonDad Sep 11 '26

I forgot about that! A friend of mine bought it on DVD at a show back in the days before YouTube.

2

u/bygtopp Sep 11 '26

Finally found a Red Predator action figure at a sale for steal. 30$ opened. Sad it was from an estate sale from a comic guru in Columbus Ohio but I got it.

7

u/James_Jim_Downing Sep 11 '26

Ja aber vielleicht bekommen wir die storyline mit broken dusk und machiko

6

u/guydoestuff Sep 11 '26

loved this comic as a kid. was so cool seeing Batman taking on the predator. disney owns it so it would have to be marvels batman which i guess would be iron man. that could be intresting.

3

u/LFTL56 Sep 11 '26

Nah Iron Man vs Predator I don't think would be that interesting tbh. Or at least coming from what the general audience now expects Iron Man to be. Same with any Marvel propery. Something about Batman lends him to a much more grounded story than almost any other mainstream super hero (Marvel, DC or otherwise)

2

u/guydoestuff Sep 11 '26

Ehh I think if you have good writing and direction you could do it.

Might also be wishful thinking. The AvP movies were meh at best so I had felt that the predator franchise was dead till Prey gave me hope. K of K wasnt perfect but it was pretty awesome and Badlands was amazing. Would love more predator lore movies not just human hunting.

4

u/MerpingtonDad Sep 11 '26

This is the kind of thing that can only ever happen in comics, and one of the reasons I always loved this stuff as a kid. I remember BvP was one of the big ones, alongside Robocop v Terminator.

5

u/steamdeck88 Sep 11 '26

Would love to see this as a animated film, but the chances of that are slim af now

2

u/balboakeepspunchin Sep 11 '26

I always said that , it’s great story .

2

u/KrakenKrusdr84 Sep 11 '26

Oh, absolutely.

2

u/flyingman17 Sep 11 '26

Loved that book

2

u/NIGHTUFURY 💀 The Ancient 💀 Sep 11 '26

I read this, it was really awesome... It specially shows the detective skills of batman...

2

u/RegretNew5752 Sep 11 '26

This comic imo is the greatest crossover of all time. You know its fantastic because it could slot in perfectly as either a Predator movie, or an episode of Batman The Animated Series.

2

u/Grumpy-Cars Sep 11 '26

This is as close as we will get.

2

u/jahjahbinks420 Sep 11 '26

one of the best top tier crossovers ever, I wanted it to happen so bad but now disney owners predator...

1

u/Internal_Cesspool Sep 11 '26

Fun comic but personally never wanted to see any superheroes or random characters with Aliens or Predators on film. I prefer the films stories stay within Alien, Predator and AvP universe.

1

u/Illhunt_yougather Sep 11 '26

same here. when i watch the 87 predator (still the best, by quite a bit) it has a "realistic" feel to it. not that it is realistic, its a crab faced alien monster. but my brain can buy it as a realistic scenario, so i settle into the film more. as soon as theres a batman or whatever in there, all that goes out the window, im now watching a totally different thing.

1

u/ReactionPlus4538 Sep 11 '26

I’d like to see Batman vs pedos

1

u/Braindead_Is_King Sep 11 '26

It is a really good series. Would love this as a movie, stay with me here, just replace Batman with a city wide bounty hunter in maybe Detroit, MI.

1

u/rogue7891 Sep 11 '26

The one thing that actually leaves the door open just a tiny bit is the existence of the Batman vs Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles animated movie. Anything's possible.

1

u/exorcissy72 28d ago

WB played ball with Disney to get those Amalgam Omnibuses released, so maybe…

1

u/rogue7891 28d ago

ya never know

1

u/dittybopper_05H Sep 11 '26

I'm still waiting for the Predator vs. Cherry Poptart crossover...

1

u/UncleSkrewtape Sep 11 '26

Batman vs. Aliens is really good too👍

Honestly all of the Dark Horse Alien/Predator/Terminator stories are great

1

u/Good-Spiritual Sep 11 '26

Check out Batman Dead End short film

1

u/Novel_Illustrator_67 Sep 12 '26

Batman doesn’t stand a chance

1

u/StandUpSafetyWipe Sep 12 '26

I had Batman VS. Predator III. Such a great mini series

1

u/northstarghost Sep 14 '26

I have this issue 😩

1

u/SandStinger_345 Fugitive Predator Sep 15 '26

Wait. I read somewhere that batman is gonna go public domain in 2035. Sooooooo this is quite possible

2

u/LFTL56 Sep 15 '26

Technically possible. The original 1930s version of Batman becomes public domain. So you could adapt that with no issue. But you can't use anything from future works (e.g. The Batmobile, the Joker) until they become public domain too.

1

u/SandStinger_345 Fugitive Predator Sep 15 '26

Thats why a predator crossover is perfect

1

u/DarthCivicus Sep 15 '26

There are fan films on YouTube.