r/thewalkingdead • u/Kxtra66 • 2d ago

Show Spoiler BETH HEAD

I just finished Ep8 of S5, and Beth just got killed be Dawn (the girl cop), WHY! I woulda rather it be Michonne, Maggy, Glenn, anybody else, not this singing angel 😕

0 Upvotes

30% Upvoted

17 comments sorted by

16

u/Conscious_Pen_9353 2d ago

The concept of trading Michonne for Beth lol

8

u/lunchmoney- 2d ago

can honestly say i’ve never heard that one before

-9

u/SnorlaxShops 2d ago

I would make this trade. I’m a Michonne hater tho. I thought her relationship with Rick and carl seemed forced/written/fake.

Idk there’s something better about a minor character that becomes a primary (Daryl) than a primary character staying popular.

0

u/Active-Contest-9965 1d ago

I hated the Rickchonne thing.
I shipped Andrea and Michonne, but that was never gonna happen.

-11

u/Kxtra66 2d ago

I like Michonne, but she's nothing more than a cold badass samurai, there's no depth no character, she's getting better since Carl grow up tantrum but still

10

u/SuperbSpiderFace 2d ago

Michonne has some of the most character growth on the series. I won’t post spoilers but taking her over Beth at any point is a crazy take.

4

u/Zealousideal-Sea-684 2d ago

To be fair to Beth she got brained before she could get any of that juicy character growth

12

u/lilpinkmushroom 2d ago

Christ. Keep Beth and sacrifice Glen, Maggie or Michonne?

That is truly wild. I mean what exactly does she really do? Watch Judith and sing a bit? I don't understand why people love her so much. She's a very bland watch for me.

I mean I get she has her fans I know everyone has different opinions and that's fine, but I cannot grasp why anyone would choose her over 3 goats like Maggie, Michonne and Glen!

5

u/lunchmoney- 2d ago

“watch judith & sing”
😭😭😭

0

u/Kxtra66 2d ago edited 2d ago

Exactly yeah, watch Judith and sing, I liked her as an innocence reminder, that no matter how cruel and ugly the world gets there's still an innocent girl somewhere, you're thinking about it as value to the team

9

u/lilpinkmushroom 2d ago

I mean I'm thinking about her as in how good of a character she was, seeing as it's a TV show and supposed to be entertaining. She's so vanilla and doesn't really add anything imo. I understand your point but you can be innocent and sweet and still have a personality and some presence. She didn't for me, she's just sort of... there. When she was gone it didn't really change anything at all. I know Beth has fans though so obviously others saw something in her I didn't.

-1

u/Kxtra66 2d ago

Yeah I get it, but it's the vanilla I liked, everyone was special, some tough, some weak, some cruel some kind, she wasn't anything in particular, just a sweet girl who's trying to see another day

1

u/Active-Contest-9965 1d ago

Guess she didn't succeed at that seeing another day part eh?

1

u/Kxtra66 1d ago

Indeed 🙂

6

u/windowshopper97 2d ago

Beth over those three is crazy lmao. She was a good supporting character but nothing more.

1

u/Anxious_Sir_5570 2d ago

beth sadly had to die, hey ark and story sadly ended. i also wish she didn't die but her character just wouldn't made any sense for the coming seasons