Hello knowledgeable knife knerds, lend me your expertise?
I'm just a home cook, currently I have a Victorinox chef's knife that I hate, mainly because it does not keep it's edge, and I suck at sharpening it. I have a Sharpal 162N diamond stone, and I've been getting better at using it but I take forever and the results are hit or miss.
So, I recently went down the rabbit hole of looking into fancy chef knives, specifically one that will keep it's edge for a long time so that I'd only have to periodically have it sharpened by a professional. I'm a scientist so looking into all the different steel types and properties is very interesting to me, but I'm also trying to remember that I just need a sharp knife, and 1 good general purpose knife at that.
Anyways, my first thought was to buy a Miyabi Kaizen II chef's knife, but as I dug in I found some other options, but the choices are really overwhelming. Here's what's on my mind:
Fujimoto Nashiji Gyuto 210mm or Ichigo Ao the first one seems highly rated, and they have a higher quoted hardness than the Miyabi while being around the same price. Not stainless cladded but that's ok. There seems to be a lot of other similar knives so I'm not married to any one particular knife. This is a no brainer over the Miyabi, right?
Msicard Basic Gyuto buying a made to order knife would be really cool, but just based on my limited knowledge of the different knife steels, AEBL or 52100 wouldn't have been my first choice. Am I too fixated on HRC?
Hatsukokoro Ryuhyo SG2 or ICHIE x Shibata SG2 Two examples of powdered steel knives. They are a step up in price than the Miyabi and everyhing else listed before. They look cool, and are made of a harder steel. Would I really see that much of a difference for almost double the price, or is it diminishing returns here?
Xin Guo Vanadis 8 Way too expensive for me. But. This is made with one of these exotic steels, if I look at the knife steel nerds charts it seems to have the highest area under the curve in terms of toughness and edge retention. If this is going to be a life changing difference, I'd shell out for it but I suspect its probably not.
Ikea Fjallroding The "don't go down the rabbit hole" choice. I'm probably going to buy one of these in any case to have something I don't mind hacking at things with, but, should I just buy this nakiri and the petty knife from this line, and learn how to sharpen better? (another option would be something from
Thanks for your help!