r/videogames • • Aug 19 '26

Image / Video What game is this for you?

Post image
14.4k Upvotes

8.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

36

u/IntrepidAstroPanda Aug 19 '26

Ive always assumed pokemon is so profitable that it falls into this weird void where the expectations of revenue are so high they never have the margin to make a quality game

Edit: quality 3D game

26

u/PoopsMcScoots Aug 19 '26

No, you are 100% correct.

Do not apologize.

But it really bothers me that Nintendo is doing absolute voodoo with breath of the wild, but at the same time telling their most profitable side studio to fuck off.

It’s perplexing. Downright perplexing. Why their most profitable IP from a third-party studio doesn’t have access to the engine.

0

u/raxitron Aug 19 '26

I don't think it's very perplexing. Quality over quantity? Nintendo does not have some moral imperative to always produce the highest quality games, they have a mandate to show profit to shareholders so they do both.

Zelda has few super high quality releases and as long as sweaty 35 year old nerds are still buying billions of Pokemon TCG packs they will keep pumping out a high quantity of shitty games.

1

u/PoopsMcScoots Aug 19 '26

Okay, but that’s not how software works.

There’s no reason the tools and render pipeline from breath of the wild couldn’t be handed over to game freaks.

It feels like they just don’t even care.

I understand there’s nuance, and juggling memory is a big deal, but the Pokémon games on switch are clearly doing the bare minimum.

1

u/LightOfMithras Aug 22 '26

I said BotW was a "this game" for me. But I do have to acknowledge that it did open world better and on the original Switch system (and technically Wii U) than whatever the newer Pokémon games have been attempting to do. I hate Scarlet & Violet, honestly, and Paldea as a region bores me.

It isn't as simple as "give this engine to gamefreak" but there is definitely someone who could take a GF dev aside and explain to them how they really need to make their games ... playable. Maybe even ...stable?