Hi r/3Dprinting! I know next to nothing about this stuff.
I'm piecing together a project guitar (a Univox Hi-Flier for the guitarists/Nirvana fans out there) and purchased a pickup and pickup ring on Reverb. The seller listed it as an original pickup and mounting ring circa 1968. It arrived today, and while the pickup is definitely as advertised, the mounting ring doesn't quite pass the smell test. I'm more familiar with guitar parts than 3D printed things, but it certainly doesn't look like something that would've been injection molded in a Japanese factory back in the '60s. The top view looks about right (at least as far as wear relative to its age and the pickup itself is concerned), it has a very faint layered look when you flip it to the side, and underneath is where it really throws me off.
I'm not exactly shooting for 100% period correct with this project or anything, but thought I'd call in the experts before I have an awkward conversation with the seller and try for a partial refund or something.
What's the verdict?
EDIT: Thank you to everyone who shared their insight and expertise. I reached out to the seller. As a few people suggested, it seems to be a case where he purchased a guitar and this part was on it. It was either sold to him as original or SEEMED to be original and we're dealing with a 50-60 year old instrument here so it's not like it's possible to know where exactly every part came from. There wasn't a bottom view of the part in the listing so I didn't catch this.
I'm somewhat inclined to believe him, based solely on the fact that if you look at the pickup ring next to the pickup itself the wear on the two looks surprisingly similar. Like the top view of the 3D printed part might look like a hack job in isolation but it comes pretty close to matching the authentic wear on the real, old guitar electronics. Not able to post a pic at the moment.
Not sure where I'll go from here since it's kind of a mixed bag. I don't think there was anything malicious going on with *this* seller (but maybe on the part of whoever sold it to him), the part is technically functional for me for now, and I have the working electronic piece. We'll see what happens.