I’m 21F, and my boyfriend is 21M. We’ve been together for almost two years, and my parents have never really approved of our relationship, mainly because of concerns about his education, career, and financial stability.
We’re both Punjabi, so family approval and expectations surrounding marriage are a pretty big deal.
A couple of nights ago, my boyfriend finally sat down with my parents to have a serious conversation about our relationship and our future together.
My dad started asking him questions about his education and career. He asked what kind of student he was in high school, and my boyfriend admitted that he was pretty average and mostly got C’s.
My dad then asked why it took him around two years after graduating high school to figure out what he wanted to do. My boyfriend explained that he initially pursued architectural technology but realized he wasn’t interested in it and eventually switched to sheet metal.
My dad also asked him whether he understood the responsibilities that come with marriage and providing for a family. He explained that I’m their only daughter, that I’m extremely precious to them, and that they want to make sure whoever I marry can provide for me and give me a stable future.
During this conversation, my boyfriend started getting very quiet, shutting down emotionally, and eventually crying.
I understand that meeting your girlfriend’s parents when they already disapprove of you must be intimidating. However, I personally don’t think my dad’s questions were unreasonable. He wasn’t insulting him or yelling at him. He was asking about his education, career plans, and whether he understands the responsibilities of marriage.
My dad has been extremely strict about my education and future since I was in elementary school, so I’m used to these kinds of conversations. However, I’m starting to wonder whether my boyfriend grew up in a completely different environment and simply wasn’t prepared for that level of questioning.
My dad also demanded that he bring his mom and dad over so that they can all talk and make sure that his mom and dad won’t set them up with someone else as an arrange marriage and waste my time, however, he did not seem enthusiastic about that idea and I don’t think he’s going to do that because according to him his dad’s more traditional and more strict than my parents, but that makes no sense and I still haven’t met his dad.
My parents also noticed how anxious and restricted he seemed regarding his own family.
For example, he was concerned about needing to pick up pizza for them that night, even while dealing with this serious conversation. They commented afterward that he seemed almost afraid of disappointing his family or telling them no.
After the conversation, my boyfriend went home and basically started ignoring me.
He didn’t call me afterward to talk about what happened, and his communication has been noticeably different ever since.
Yesterday, he barely texted me, although he did respond occasionally. Today, it’s even worse.
For example, I texted him good morning at around 5:30 a.m. He woke up around 7–8 a.m., and I noticed he was active on Snapchat, but he didn’t respond to me until 11 a.m. Normally, he texts me almost immediately after waking up.
What makes this more concerning is that he was already acting somewhat dry and distant in the days leading up to this conversation.
Another thing that’s bothering me is that I recently put together a Halloween boo basket for him. I spent my own money buying him gifts and putting everything together because I wanted to make him happy and show him how much I care.
But his reaction felt underwhelming, almost like he didn’t appreciate the effort I put into it.
I know gifts shouldn’t come with expectations, but combined with how he’s been treating me lately, I feel really unappreciated.
I’m genuinely frustrated because I’ve spent so much time defending our relationship to my parents, arguing with them about him, and trying to make this relationship work despite their disapproval.
And now that he’s finally had a serious conversation with them, it feels like he’s emotionally withdrawing from me.
I’m trying to understand whether he’s overwhelmed, embarrassed, intimidated by my dad, or genuinely starting to lose feelings for me.
So, men of Reddit, I have a few questions:
If you were in my boyfriend’s position, would you consider my dad’s questions harsh or reasonable?
Why might a man cry or emotionally shut down during a conversation like this?
Could being questioned about his grades, career, and ability to provide have made him feel inadequate or emasculated?
Why would he start ignoring his girlfriend afterward instead of communicating how he feels?
Does this sound like someone who’s overwhelmed and needs space, or someone who’s reconsidering the relationship?
Is it unreasonable for me to expect him to communicate with me after something like this, especially when I’ve been defending him to my parents for so long?
From a man’s perspective, what would you want your girlfriend to do in this situation?
I love him, and I genuinely want a future with him, but I’m getting exhausted from feeling like I’m the only one fighting for us.
I’d really appreciate honest perspectives, especially from men who have experienced disapproval from a girlfriend’s parents or felt pressured about their career and financial stability