ā ļø Looong post ahead āš»
Problem/Goal:
I'm a 35-year-old woman in a relationship with another woman who's 38. We've been together for 10 years now, and for roughly the past five years, I've wanted us to live together and start building a life as a couple.
I love her, and I don't necessarily want to break up. But I'm starting to question whether we're truly compatible in terms of what we want from life, and this situation has been weighing on me emotionally.
Context:
Here's the situation. My girlfriend is the eldest in her family. Her parents are seniors, and her father has health issues that require regular medical attention, including checkups. Her family is also helping care for the baby of one of her younger siblings, who works away from home and only comes home on weekends. Because of this, the baby relies heavily on the grandparents for support.
I understand that she has significant family responsibilities. I'm not asking her to abandon her parents or disregard their needs. I recognize that her situation is complicated, and I understand why she might feel obligated to stay involved in her family's life. At the same time, I've been wanting to build a life with my partner for years. I'm now 35, and I want the kind of relationship where we share a home, have everyday routines together, make decisions as a couple, and are consistently present in each other's lives.
Our current arrangement is that she comes home to stay with me approximately once a month. Sometimes she stays for two or three weeks, while other times she only stays for a couple of days. When we're together, she does things that make me feel she wants a future with me. We can enjoy our time together, and I can picture what our life might look like if we lived together permanently.
But when she leaves, we're back to our separate lives. And despite having these stretches of time together, it's still not the same as actually sharing a life with someone.
I've tried asking her about our future and whether we'll eventually live together. The problem is that I don't feel like I'm getting clear answers that help me understand what to expect. I don't know whether she genuinely wants the same future but feels trapped by her responsibilities, whether she wants it but can't imagine when it would happen, or whether she's comfortable with our current arrangement and doesn't really want to change it.
I sometimes feel that her family situation has become a reason she never has to give me a definitive answer. I don't know if that's fair to her, and I don't want to assume she's intentionally avoiding commitment. But after wanting this for around five years, I'm struggling with the uncertainty.
The difficult part is that I don't think I want to break up with her. I love her, and I don't want to lose her. But I also don't want a relationship where my partner isn't consistently available when I need her. I know nobody can be available 24/7, and I'm not expecting that. What I want is a partner who's a dependable part of my everyday life, someone I can turn to and share life's ordinary moments with without our time together always depending on when circumstances allow it.
I want to feel like we're actively building something together, rather than waiting indefinitely for the right circumstances to come along.
Sometimes I feel selfish for wanting this when she has a father with health issues and aging parents who need support. I know her family needs her, too. I don't want to put her in a position where she feels she has to choose between me and her family.
But I also wonder: How long am I supposed to put my own needs on hold? Is it wrong to want more from my relationship when my partner has legitimate responsibilities that make it difficult for her to give me what I want?
There are also practical reasons why the thought of breaking up scares me.
We have a mutual circle of friends. Most of these friendships originally came through her, although we've become close to these people ourselves. I'm afraid that breaking up might mean losing not only my partner but also the friendships and social circle we've built together.
One of her close friends is also my neighbor. I've already committed to a mortgage, so moving somewhere else isn't a realistic option for me right now. Even if the relationship ended, I'd still have to navigate the possibility of seeing her friends regularly and dealing with the awkwardness of a shared social circle.
I know these shouldn't necessarily be the reasons I stay in a relationship, but they're part of what makes the situation feel more complicated.
What makes this particularly difficult is that I can see both sides.
I can understand why she feels responsible for her family. I can see that she makes an effort to come home and spend time with me. I don't want to dismiss those things or act as though she does nothing for our relationship. But I also know that what we currently have isn't enough for me. And I feel guilty admitting that because I know she's dealing with circumstances that aren't necessarily easy to change.
I don't know whether I should be more patient, whether I should have a more serious conversation with her about setting a realistic timeline, or whether I need to accept that love alone might not be enough if we want different things from life.
Thinking about this situation sometimes sends me into a spiral, and it's emotionally exhausting. I don't want to make a decision based on fear, frustration, or a particularly difficult day. I want to understand my situation more clearly and make a decision I can live with.
I'd appreciate honest advice, especially from people who've been in long-term relationships where one partner has significant family obligations. A few questions I'm struggling with:
\- Am I being selfish or unreasonable for wanting to live with my partner and build a shared life together, even though I understand her family responsibilities?
\- How do you distinguish between a partner who genuinely wants a future with you but is dealing with difficult circumstances and a partner who is comfortable keeping the relationship as it is?
\- After approximately five years of wanting this, is it reasonable to ask for a concrete plan or timeline, even if the timeline is flexible?
If she genuinely cannot commit to living together for the foreseeable future, how do I decide whether I can accept that without building resentment?
\- Has anyone ended a relationship they still deeply loved because their long-term needs weren't compatible? How did you deal with the grief, especially when you shared the same friends and social circle?
\-How do I make this decision without letting my fear of losing her, our mutual friends, and the life I've built around the relationship make the decision for me?
I'm not looking for people to tell me that she's a bad partner or that I should immediately leave her. I love her, and I know the situation is complicated.
I just need an outside perspective because I'm struggling to figure out whether I'm asking for too much or whether I've been trying so hard to understand her circumstances that I've stopped giving my own needs enough consideration.
Thank you for reading. š„²š