r/XboxAlly • u/Aacemyan • 1h ago
🎮 ROG Xbox Ally Discussion X20 Impressions from OneXPlayer 3 owner
I know there's a lot of people comparing these 2 devices right now so I figured i'd give my impressions of both these devices. FYI i've owned my OXP3 since it was released and in the past have also owned the following devices: Steamdeck, Ally, Ally X, Xbox Ally X (briefly), Go, Go 2, Go S, Claw 8 AI+, Apex, X2 Mini Pro.
Feel / Build Quality
First off the bat, I can't underestimate how much better the X20 feels in the hands compared to the OXP3. A lot of things I got accustomed to on the OXP3 such as crappy vibration, hollow controllers, clicky face buttons / triggers, bad dpad, etc - made me realize what I was missing out when I first picked up the X20 in my hands. Everything on this device feels rock solid - all buttons feel amazing, joystick tension is great, and even the rumble (and triggers) is amazing. For context I turned off rumble on OXP3 since it was so terrible
Screen
Honestly, X20 screen is pretty awesome. Don't feel like I'm missing much from OXP3 other than smaller size. May feel a little less immersive on AAA games, but you get used to what you're playing with very quickly.
Size
Love the more compact size of X20 and not needing an obnoxiously large case to fit in my bag. It's not a small device by any means, but just inspires confidence since the build quality is so good and doesn't have detachable controllers
Performance
No need to bring up performance difference between G3E and Z2E. Yes there's a difference if all you care about is performance. I tend to stream from my desktop PC at home, and on the go lower resolutions. Device always stays cool, fans are quite even under load - in that sense it feels little like using a Switch 2 and that stuff disappears in the background
Quality of life
Having owned Lenovo Go2, Claw 8, and various OneXPlayer devices recently, I've gotten accustomed to dealing with a lot of jank. Asus / Microsoft did a bang up job with making the experience feel quite seemless. Armory crate is actually really good and responsive. All the buttons do what they're supposed to do, and having a dedicated xbox button is pretty great.
So where does this leave me? OXP3 win on performance and screen size, but lose out on everything else a handheld is supposed to be good for. I'll be keeping both, but honestly Ally X20 feels so good to pick up and play, that I just want to reach for that one despite the smaller size and slightly lower performance. People shitting on the device due to Z2E are putting blinders on the 100 other things that make a handheld special to use, and the Ally X20 really nails it!