Think vampires, witches, necromancers, monsters, etc. Historical/ fantasy settings are preffered but not a strict requirement. It’s also fine if mods are needed to play that way or for a better experience.
Doesn’t need to be a pure sandbox, but I do need to be able to fart around in an open world for extended amounts of time.
Games that I’ve played that sort of work but why they aren’t it:
Skyrim/elder scrolls in general: play as a vampire/werewolf/necromancer yes, but overall it feels half baked.
Warhammer 3: play as undead/evil factions but the scale is too grand.
Bannerlord with the old realms mod: fits the bill in a lot of ways, but burnt out on mount and blade for the foreseeable future.
Prototype 1/2: loved them, played them to death back in the day, and do not want to revisit.
The forest 1/2: while kind of the exact opposite of what I’m asking, it got to the point where I was the monster hunting the cannibals, so the vibe was right. Played to death at this point though.
Games on my radar, but not sold on them yet, feel free to convince me:
Tyranny, pathfinder wotr: both seem to cover the being evil part, but also appear to be too story driven to just mess around in.
Vampire the masquerade bloodlines: seems interesting, but not sure about the level of jank going into it fresh
Vampire the masquerade bloodlines 2: also seems interesting, and certainly less janky, but reviews seem to imply it’s somewhat on the rails and disappointing.
Vrising : reading about it I’m sold, watching it be played I lose interest. Also worried it’s just not that interesting to play solo.
Carrion: just not that into 2D side scrollers. There’s been exceptions, but they are few.
Maneater: a little silly, but if there was a similar game based on land it would probably be scratch the itch.
Open to any and all suggestions.