r/marshall • u/musictherapist99 • 1d ago
Middleton II vs Kilburn III?
Hey there, I am looking to invest in a good semi portable bluetooth speaker. Its main uses will be to connect to a projector (XGIMI Mogo Pro 2) in a 25m2 living room and my smaller bedroom and listen to music in my bedroom, the kitchen whilst cooking or in the bathroom. We have an old but pretty good stereo system in the living room to play CDs and Spotify via aux and will probably move my flatmates record player into the living room as well.
The projector is not stationary and will only be taken out when we watch something and the plan is to put the speaker on the coffee table in front of the couch as the wall we are projecting on is relatively far away. Fixed speakers are not an option due to the walls in our rental and the aesthetics. (I know not a perfect setup but has to work for us)
I do not need the speaker to be portable outside, just comfortably inside. I love the sound of my Marshall major IVs and mostly listen to indie rock, rock, some folk, indie pop and some rap (think somewhere between The Strokes, AM, Miles Kane, Kneecap, The big special, Odezenne, Kae Tempest, Bonaparte, Alt-J, BB Brunes, Franz Ferdinand and Austrian/German indie).
I’ve therefore looked into the Marshall speakers and am currently torn between the Middleton 2 and Kilburn 3. in sound examples on YouTube (I know not super reliable) the Middleton sounds much nicer to me, but the opinions and ratings I’ve found online are inconclusive to me and I am no expert. I like a warm sound a and a good deep bass but also really value when you’re able to distinctly hear all instruments and vocals and am really unsure what works best for watching films as well.
Aesthetics is also a big point for me where Marshall just wins, I sadly find JBL terribly unpleasant to look at for example. But any other suggestions are also very welcome!
TLDR: Semi portable inside speaker for watching films with a projector & listening to music. Middleton 2 or Kilburn 3? Or something else entirely? Budget is around 200-300€ max.
Thank you!