r/AmItheAsshole • u/Queasy-Captain9226 • 1h ago
AITA for refusing to pay $300 after I returned a lost wallet and he accused me of taking cash from it?
Last Saturday, when I was taking a walk with my dog in the park, together with my friend Caleb, I noticed a brown leather wallet lying on the floor near the picnic tables. I picked it up and tried to find the owner through the ID card. The wallet belonged to a man called Gary. He lives several streets away from my place. I've met him before but I haven't spoken to him.
As there was a big amount of cash in it, I wanted to make sure that nothing would go wrong. Before doing something with the wallet, I opened it in front of Caleb and took a picture of its content – the cards, ID and $340 in cash. Don't know why I did it but I didn't want any problems later on.
Anyway, I went to Gary's house and returned his wallet. When he saw us, he was very grateful to us. He counted all the money and the cards on his porch and thanked me for returning it all back.
The following night, he came to my door and told me that $300 was missing from the wallet. He “wasn’t thinking clearly at that time" and that “someone must have taken it while we were walking from the park to our home.” When he was saying this, he was looking straight into my eyes.
I remained very calm and showed him our picture along with its timestamp. And I informed him that Caleb was with me all the time and could vouch for everything. But he said that “the picture didn’t prove anything” and that “I could have taken out the money later after photographing it.” Then he went on to say that if I would just confess to it and give the money to him, they would let it go.
I said, no. That I gave back all that I received, that he verified the receipt in front of two witnesses and that I wouldn’t confess to something that I never did”.
Gary has also added that the proper way out of this fiasco would be if I confessed my wrongs and paid him off.
I don’t think I should apologize and pay them something that I have never done.
AITAH for not apologizing and not paying up?