r/dating_advice • u/Fordogsupto11kgs • 15h ago
He’s near perfect but the sex sucks. Now he wants a relationship. Am I doomed?
I (F35) need some outside perspective because I'm starting to fall for a man (M37) who's amazing in almost every way.
We've been seeing each other for six months and I'm developing real feelings for him. He's funny, intelligent, emotionally attuned, and we work in the same industry, so we have heaps to talk about. He cooks incredible food, is loving and present in a way I'm not used to, and has a wonderful little daughter whom I adore.
Now we're talking about being exclusive and calling ourselves a couple, which feels both exciting and terrifying. I really like this man, and I don't want to throw away something that could turn into a wonderful relationship. I can genuinely picture myself with him.
The problem? Our sex life is shit.
And I don't know how big a deal this is or what I'm supposed to do. I am a very sexual person and so does he seem to be.
I'm attracted to him. I like his body, enjoy being physically close to him, and WANT a fun, fulfilling sex life with him. But when we actually get in to it I'm often disappointed.
He's clumsy. Does weird things with his hands. Can go from gently stroking my cheek to having his hand on my privates in two secs. He gets so excited that he seems to want to do EVERYTHING at once, without really tuning into what's happening between us. It's a bit like having sex with a teenage boy.
He seems to think our sex life is absolutely amazing. He regularly tells me how incredible it is with me, while I'm lying there like Yoo - Are we having two completely different experiences?
For context, he divorced five years ago after a VERY long relationship. During the last years of that relationship they had open marriage, and since the divorce he's dated casually. So it's not like he has no sexual experience. And yet when we're together, he just seems inexperienced.
I've tried communicating. Gently and more directly. I've shown him what I like, told him what doesn't work for me, tried guiding him during sex. We've also talked about it outside the bedroom, and he seems to understand exactly what I mean.
But when we get back into it we're right back at square one :((((
Sometimes I try taking the lead, but then he'll suddenly introduce something completely different that throws off the entire flow. I lose my rhythm, get distracted, and have to mentally start over, all while trying to be sweet and affectionate so he doesn't feel bad.
I genuinely just want a man who can read the room and respond to what's happening in the moment.
Six months in and I’m wondering if this is still a matter of communication and practice? Or are there people who simply don't click sexually, even when the attraction and emotional connection are there?
And how long do you give it before you have to be honest with yourself?
I've even wondered if an open relationship could be an option as he's experienced one before. Is it insane to consider opening a relationship before even starting one? I don't want to use other people as a solution to something we haven't managed to figure out between us.
At the same time, I don't want to spend the rest of the relationship missing a sex life that fulfils me.
Am I being too picky? Are my expectations unrealistic? Should I give it more time, be more direct, or accept that this is how it’ll be?
TL:DR
I have met the man of my dreams and he wants to be my boyfriend, but he sucks at sex and doesn’t improve even with feedback and gentle guidance. It’s been 6 months and I don’t know if we should make it official. Is the sex doomed? What do I do?