As a follow up to my early impressions post I’ve again been comparing my C40, K-Ultra and S5, partly because I’m considering selling one of them.
The Pietro Multipurpose could have been in the mix too, but as its flat burrs and a table top (not hand) grinder I decided not to.
For today’s test, I used a medium-roasted washed Ethiopian coffee that’s honestly a little darker than I usually prefer. I wanted to see which grinder could make the most enjoyable cup out of beans that are a bit dark for my taste as it sometimes happens that a roaster roasts darker then I would have hoped for.
I used the same brewing recipe and approximately matched the grind sizes.
First, ergonomics and grinding speed (10 g):
C40: 21 seconds. Easiest to load beans into thanks to its wide opening, but the least comfortable to hold because its so wide. It also tends to make a mess when transferring grounds into the dripper. Grounds get caught around the catch cup, and I often spill some when unscrewing or transferring. A growing annoyance.
K-Ultra: 13 seconds. So fast! By far the most comfortable to grind with. The narrower, contoured body and longer handle make grinding feel effortless compared to the other two.
S5: 22 seconds. Slightly slower than the C40, but more comfortable to hold. It feels extremely solid and like heavy metal/iron, and I really enjoy using it. The C40 feels a little plasticky in comparison and the K in between, maybe like a light metal/aluminium. Sometimes on lighter roasts it can grind a bit janky, getting stuck, but its not a big problem and on this medium it was smooth.
Now, the cups:
C40: Rounded, blended, medium body. Some bitterness and roastiness remained quite noticeable. The texture felt a little coarse/rough compared to the others.
K-Ultra: Slightly lighter body, less bitterness/roastiness and a nicer balance of sweetness and acidity. It did a good job of making the roastiness less noticeable. Flavours are a bit spread out like the ZP6, but not as much of course.
S5: Probably my favorite texture of the three. A little softer, smoother and more silky. Taste notes integrated in a a nice way without being muddled. The integration of tasting notes and silky texture reminds me a bit of the A4Z, but haven’t side be sided them yet. Good sweetness, slightly more noticeable acidity than the C40, (but a tiny bit less acidity than the K) and also like the K, less emphasis on the roasted notes, which is important to me. A quite enjoyable cup.
The differences were small though.
All three cups were quite similar, and none was bad. The S5 and K-Ultra were particularly close in overall experience, although their textures and acidity differed a tiny bit.
This also fits some of my previous comparisons.
I’ve often found the C40 to be very rounded and blended, sometimes at the expense of nuance. On one Kenyan coffee from Prolog, for example, the K-Ultra brought out significantly more complexity, while the C40 made the same beans taste somewhat less interesting.
The K-Ultra has consistently impressed me with its lively acidity, medium body and versatility. It rarely disappoints.
The S5 is still relatively new to me, but I’m starting to recognize a pattern: sweet, smooth, integrated and very pleasant. Sometimes a little less expressive, but with a lovely texture. And I genuinely enjoy the physical experience of using it. It feels so heavy and robust and makes the other two feel almost more like toys.
I love the Comandante partly because of its legacy. It’s an iconic grinder, and I still truly appreciate its signature sounds and history.
But increasingly, the things that used to charm me are being overshadowed by small frustrations: counting clicks without knowing the current setting and the mess left by grounds from around the catch cup. All other eight hand grinders I own have figured this out - the only other grinders that does leave a mess when transferring grounds is my Pietros and that can be avoided with technique unlike the C40.
My current conclusion: I’d probably keep the K-Ultra and S5 and sell the C40. Not because the C40 is bad, far from it, but because the other two seem to suit my preferences better, both in the cup and in daily use.