I’ve always wondered how effective air conditioning is vs air purifier. So I did a simple experiment at home, see below for the results!
I’m not revealing the purifier brand to avoid discussions on brands.
EDITED: Added a test where I off both aircon and purifier after opening windows (and closing them). It went from 86 to 72 in 23 minutes. Then stagnated 69-72 for the next ten minutes.
<below results part summarized and graph made by AI>
Setup
- Master bedroom in Jurong West, near Jurong Point
- Room empty throughout
- Ceiling fan on max throughout
- Indoor PM2.5 read from the purifier's sensor
Outdoor (data.gov.sg, West)
- 5:59pm: 1-hr PM2.5 at 147, 24-hr PSI at 205
- 6:30pm: 1-hr PM2.5 at 134
Log (indoor PM2.5, µg/m³)
- 5:45 to 6:00pm, ventilator on, outside air coming in: 99 at 5:59
- 6:00 to 6:20pm, aircon on full blast: 73 at 6:12, 69 at 6:16, 66 at 6:19, 66 at 6:20
- Switched to the purifier because readings stayed at about 66 to 69 for about 5 minutes
- 6:20pm onwards, aircon off and purifier on at speed 10 with 25° oscillation: 46 at 6:23, 37 at 6:25, 31 at 6:26, 20 at 6:32, 17 at 6:38, 16 at 6:41
Summary
- Aircon phase: 99 down to 66 in 20 minutes, then it stayed at around 66 for the last 5 minutes.
- Purifier phase: 66 down to 16 in 21 minutes.