r/TopCharacterTropes • • 1d ago

miscellaneous Media Made to Prove the Haters Wrong

Tunak Tunak Tun (Daler Mehndi) Critics claimed his music videos were only popular because they featured attractive women dancing. Mehndi responded by making a music video featuring nobody except multiple green-screen versions of himself. It became a massive hit and his most famous song.

Five Nights at Freddy’s - Scott Cawthon previously made a family-friendly game called Chipper & Sons Lumber Co. Critics complained that the characters looked like creepy animatronics. Rather than abandon that visual style, Cawthon decided to turn them into an actual horror game using scary animatronics.

Superman Kingdom Come - Mark Waid and Alex Ross were reacting to the 1990s trend of increasingly violent, cynical superheroes.

Their story deliberately challenged the belief that traditional superheroes like Superman were outdated. It portrayed the consequences of abandoning heroic ideals and argued that compassion, restraint, and morality were still essential to superheroes.

17.9k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

5.2k

u/SatoruGojo232 1d ago edited 1d ago

Spider-Man being created by Stan Lee and Steve Ditko despite Stan's publisher telling him that people hate spiders and nobody would care about a mainline teenager superhero with personal problems (since at that time most teens in superhero comics were sidekicks, and superheroes were mostly role models without flaws)

2.2k

u/Careful_Welcome7999 1d ago

Its kinda funny that they thought people wouldn't like to read about a teenager going through the struggles of life like losing a parental figure and having to find a job to help his family when people LOVE these kinds of stories

618

u/WJMazepas 1d ago

But there werent many teenager stories like this back then

And especially not stories like superheros aimed at children and teenagers

229

u/phdemented 1d ago

Teen comics back then were stuff like Archie and other comedy/romance stuff

93

u/South_Dakota_Boy 1d ago

This is part of why “The Catcher in the Rye” (1951) is so beloved as well.

It’s basically the angsty teen archetype.

→ More replies (4)

632

u/kitsunewarlock 1d ago

"Teenager" (as we know it) were a relatively new concept. The word itself was coined in 1910 and only became widely known as a marketing term after WW2. Before then people of "teen age" were just considered children or adults, depending on the context.

And by "depending on the context" I mean the same 14 year old would be called "just a child" if he was killed during wartime, but one of likely several "men" if he died in a coal mine collapse.

128

u/o4zloiroman 1d ago

I honestly never thought of it. TIL.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

113

u/botte-la-botte 1d ago

Yeah, but you have to see it in full context. Those people might have said this to Stan, but they still published Amazing Fantasy #15 with a tease for a future Spider-Man comic.

Marvel back then had an extremely limited distribution system. There was a strict limit to the number of comics they were able to publish each month. So taking a chance on an unproven concept was very risky, and yet those same people who were unconvinced still did it.

23

u/AlmendraJota 1d ago

Hindsight is always 20/20

18

u/RedGuyNoPants 1d ago

The 60s was the first time a significant number of “teens” had disposable money and could be catered to. People hadn’t spent much time beforehand thinking of what type of things teens wanted

→ More replies (3)

134

u/FiaGiolla 1d ago

Iron Man is another case of this, Lee set out to take the most unlikable kind of person and make him likable

→ More replies (3)

277

u/MCdemonkid1230 1d ago

And now look at Spider-Man Brand New Day making $2.5 billion at the box office, a worldwide hit, second to Endgame.

Wonder what the publisher would be saying now.

222

u/Warm-Requirement-769 1d ago

111

u/Feedback-Mental 1d ago

"Boy I'm so glad to have been proven wrong" is the most sane answer, I think.

49

u/Party_Advantage_3733 1d ago

Or maybe "Good job I trusted my staff and let them do that thing despite my personal doubts about it"

→ More replies (2)

52

u/Party_Advantage_3733 1d ago

Probably "Thanks for all the money Stan"

19

u/Dropbeatdad 1d ago

"I'm in charge here, they pay me a shit-ton of money to give my put of touch opinions on things and then face zero consequences when I'm completely wrong."

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Soulful-Sorrow 1d ago

The publisher who told them that Spider-Man was a bad idea saw Amazing Fantasy #15 fly off the shelves then said that Spider-Man was a great idea.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (18)

1.3k

u/Yoshichu25 1d ago

“[T]rend of increasingly violent, cynical superheroes”

You’re telling me we’ve been here before?

1.1k

u/jbwarner86 1d ago

You should've seen the '90s. It was a rough scene - Superman died, Batman got replaced with a murderous maniac, Spider-Man's symbiote suit came to life and started eating people, and Rob Liefeld was actually considered talented.

409

u/brionneverysexy 1d ago

Death of Superman is a great story. Superman being asked what its like to never be scared of being defeated and responding by talking about how he fights people all the time that could kill him but he knows he has to do it while Doomsday is absolutely destroying The Justice League is one of my favorite comic sequences

212

u/jackofslayers 1d ago

Death of Superman is so wonderful because it is so good and so influential to both DC and comics as a whole. I love talking about it.

But it also came right before comic writers figured out that they were having their backs broken by preexisting lore. So, I can't really tell people to go and read that run, because I don't want to explain why Supergirl is a shapeshifting alien that is dating Lex Luthor, who is actually Lex Luthors son, but actually he is a clone of Lex Luthor that Lex transferred his consciousness into.

75

u/DaemonG 1d ago

yeah, people joke about comic retcons, reboots, and just wiping out whole eras of the continuity, but holy shit has it been needed. we whine about how bloated the MCU is getting now, but comics get soooo much worse.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

63

u/extraboredinary 1d ago

Remember when Superman turned into Santa and stole Batman’s 6 barreled Gatling gun to kill Hitler and Hitler?

→ More replies (4)

60

u/LemoLuke 1d ago edited 1d ago

'90s comics summed up in one cover

  • Excessive number of pouches ✅
  • Huge sci-fi guns ✅
  • Boob windows ✅
  • 'Cool' jackets ✅
  • Holographic cover ✅

Only thing missing is introducing a brand new character with a name like 'Bloodmeat Deathfist'

→ More replies (9)

34

u/zakary3888 1d ago

Stan Lee never considered Rob Liefeld talented, for evidence, I submit this video of Stan Lee openly mocking Liefeld’s process to his face. https://youtu.be/RmLFGWAyajU?is=tMoIH7Odvo1Sz7zb

→ More replies (3)

30

u/YesImKeithHernandez 1d ago

Rob Liefeld was actually considered talented.

Liefeld is such a case of right place, right time. He is so bad as an artist.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (18)

312

u/Still_Mood6959 1d ago

It's a cyclical thing.

"Superheroes are too goofy" --> More serious storylines and genre deconstruction --> Cynicism becomes the norm --> "Superheroes are too depressing" --> More lighthearted storylines and genre parodies --> Silliness becomes the norm --> "Superheroes are too goofy" --> Repeat.

It's not even restricted to superheroes. Most forms of media go through this sort of thing.

113

u/Interesting-Quit8017 1d ago

art is emotion -> there is no realistic art -> art depicts real world -> there is no emotion, emotion should be in art -> there is no realistic art -> repeat

the same with nature -> humanity -> god, based on your religion -> nature -> humanity -> repeat

humans are not on the world long enough to get out of cycles, we repeat everything, hell we cant move from antic roman/greek art, still saying its the best style and moving back/from it

22

u/ExternalPromotion542 1d ago

Philosophy even does this to an extent honestly.

71

u/davicos2005 1d ago

History doesn’t repeat itself, but it often rhymes.

→ More replies (1)

49

u/deathschemist 1d ago

if anything it was more violent and more cynical in the 90s

40

u/Coidzor 1d ago

Time is a donut, or something along those lines.

→ More replies (8)

96

u/AlabasterRadio 1d ago

Time isn't a flat circle, but culture kinda is.

→ More replies (1)

57

u/Darkpoulay 1d ago

When do you think Watchmen was made ?

23

u/Ill_Reflection9367 1d ago

Watchmen was written in 86/87 and preceded the 90s angst and glorified violence. It was purposefully constructed/written/drawn to depict what these character/heroes would look like in the real world - the violence was uncomfortable and not “badass”. It actually unintentionally started the trend bc other creators took the violence but left the real message, story depth, reasoning behind. However, if you are going off the Snyder film, then yeh all that gets lost and it falls into the ultra-violence to look cool 90s schtick.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

54

u/AdagioOfLiving 1d ago

Generally speaking, the better the economy is doing, the more people like anti-heroes and darker stuff with their superheroes. Grim and gritty and all.

Conversely, when the economy’s in the shitter, people start wanting stories about hope and the importance of being uncompromisingly good in the face of evil.

→ More replies (6)

20

u/Caravanczar 1d ago

Same as it ever was

→ More replies (10)

1.6k

u/Coherently-Rambling 1d ago

Buffy the Vampire Slayer has an episode “Hush” where monsters steal everyone’s ability to speak.

This episode was written in response to the claim that witty dialogue is the only thing the show has going for it.

380

u/CaptainMikul 1d ago

My wife and I had to look up the behind the scenes of how they made the guys float in this, cos it's so fucking smoooooth and just so much better than any other effect in the show.

Turns out, rails, wire, and very good editing. Its all practical.

133

u/yeswearerelated 1d ago

The other reason the Gentlemen look great is because at least one of them is Doug Jones, IMO the greatest monster actor of all time.

48

u/andre5913 1d ago edited 1d ago

Doug has a very unique elegance to his movement. He has mastered the ability to toe the line of inhumanity with his body language. He's without equal if you want to portray a humanoid monster imo.

→ More replies (4)

231

u/Scuttling-Claws 1d ago

And it's definitely one of the more iconic episodes

48

u/plz_dont_perceive_me 1d ago

It's the first bit of TV that gave me nightmares.

64

u/Digit00l 1d ago

They still managed to get in some quippy dialogue type stuff even in mute

49

u/HailMadScience 1d ago

Buffy miming staking and it looks like something else is perfection in acting.

→ More replies (2)

46

u/Chaetomius 1d ago

*accidental jerk-off motion*

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (20)

393

u/DM-me-naughty-Cats 1d ago

Five Nights at Freddy Example is actually proving the critics right though..

254

u/First_Blankie 1d ago

Yeah... That one is more of a "Hey... You guys are on to something!" Moment.

85

u/bitch_fitching 1d ago

Seems like an even better trope, turning weaknesses into strengths.

27

u/RikuAotsuki 1d ago

Hell, one of the complaints people have about the series is that it moved away from the creepy animatronic style into a plastic shell robot style.

→ More replies (7)

672

u/ussrowe 1d ago

Marilyn Monroe doing a photo shoot wearing a potato sack as a dress was created in response to a gossip columnist claiming “her studio should see to it that the public doesn’t see her looking cheap and vulgar. They’d find that a few thousand $$$ invested in a wardrobe, hairdos and charm schooling for Marilyn would pay off.”

The studio decided to prove she’d look good even in a burlap sack.

https://www.instyle.com/marilyn-monroe-potato-sack-dress-story-11908854

170

u/KatieCashew 1d ago

That dress must have been so uncomfortable. Burlap is the worst. I remember when it was really popular in decor a few years ago. It's so itchy and sheds everywhere. I'm glad that trend ended.

34

u/aquascape_dude 1d ago

That's what I thought but then I figured the seamstress would add underlining or something let cotton or whatever

→ More replies (2)

158

u/Buttered_Carnage 1d ago

And indeed she does

64

u/HailMadScience 1d ago

Honestly one of her best shots IMO. I dont know if they found that exact bag printed or made that print but it fits her figure...well, like a piece of art.

47

u/Caboose127 1d ago

While I'm sure Marilyn Monroe would look good even in a regular potato sack, all they're saying in this picture is "she looks great in a professionally tailored, form fitting dress whether it's made of scratchy material or soft!"

→ More replies (1)

2.8k

u/Slow_Bowler8285 1d ago edited 1d ago

Occasionally comedic actors, comedians turned actors and action stars will do dramatic roles to show critics that yes they can act

E.g. Adam Sandler

  • Punch Drunk Love
  • Reign Over Me
  • Uncut Gems

Sylvester Stallone

  • Copland
  • King of Tulsa

Jim Carrey-

  • The Truman Show
  • Eternal Sunshine of The Spotless Mind
  • The Majestic

These movies might get critical acclaim and even award show buzz, but they rarely make as much money as the actor's standard comedy or action fare.

557

u/AfraidNectarine7558 1d ago

Hugh Laurie was known in the UK as a great comedian, a member of projects like Blackadder and A Bit of Fry and Laurie. Then he went on to play Dr. Gregory House. While House contains a lot of jokes and comedy, it's definitely not a comedy.

https://giphy.com/gifs/t4JyMssal3qKYJEQIf

140

u/andre5913 1d ago edited 1d ago

The character of House is fairly absurd and exagerated though.

Laurie definitely used his comedy chops to bring it to life. I wouldnt say its a fully dramatic performance (and its no lesser bc of it, he sure earned all those emmys).

→ More replies (1)

52

u/CeleritasLucis 1d ago

Then why do i laugh soo much when i binge it ?

/s

27

u/Magic_ass1 1d ago

Did you take the hygiene drug?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

319

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

71

u/LosAngeLukaGOATCIC 1d ago

He also got two others movies where he is bad guy, one with Al Pacino and Photo Obsession or something like that were great too.

→ More replies (15)

23

u/brionneverysexy 1d ago

The episode of Homicide with Robin Williams, Bop Gun is the best episode of television. He goes from being strong for his kids, to raging at the system to being completely broken sometimes all in one scene

→ More replies (8)

619

u/Stickin8or 1d ago

Bryan Cranston and Robin Williams are both good examples of this too

255

u/Tiredohsoverytired 1d ago

Robin Williams was so unsettling in One Hour Photo. 

102

u/Caleth 1d ago

His work in Good Will Hunting was great. He was restrained and delivered that you're just a kid speech so well.

Many times before then he's known for being the Genie, or Patch Adams, or Mrs. Doubtfire where there are moments of restraint or heavy bits, but then he's doing his high energy clown bit.

This was one of the first times that a wide audience got to see him be that character. Sure Dead Poets and Fisher King were there but they weren't drawing in the attention the way that Good Will Hunting did.

36

u/snow38385 1d ago

I don't know why it bothers me so much that you think dead poets society wasn't drawing attention so I looked it up.

It was the third most successful movie the year it came out and had 4 Oscar nominations including best picture.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

202

u/Amazing_Working_6157 1d ago

He was known more for comedy and romance/comedies at the time before Bruce Willis starred in Diehard. Now if someone sees the name Bruce Willis, most usually think of an action hero like John McClane (I'm not exception to this).

50

u/Just1neObserveR 1d ago

People really forget/ aren’t aware of the early part of Bruce Willis’s career. He was the lead in Moonlighting (tv comedy drama) and his first two credited film roles were in Blind Date (rom-com) and Sunset (comedy western). Then he started in Die Hard, and was a very unlikely choice given the hyper muscled leading men of the 70s and 80s, and the rest is history.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

93

u/Twostepsfromlost2 1d ago

Will Ferrell played in stanger than fiction a romance and was quite good in it. My cousin put it on toward the end of his anchor man, elf era and I was really not feeling his comedy style that day only to be pleasently suprised.

43

u/Soy_ThomCat 1d ago

I'm someone that doesn't really like Will Farrells schtick. I tried watching Anchorman and Ricky Bobby and what not and I just...don't get it.

But I love Stranger Than Fiction. So now when I meet a kindred spirit who doesn't like Will Farrell, I usually ask them if they've seen that one.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (6)

159

u/thymepockets 1d ago

Adam Sandler was great in The Meyerowitz Stories as well. Great story about adult children working out their stuff

→ More replies (1)

46

u/HumbledoreThe3rd 1d ago

It’s the complete inverse of what you said, but isn’t this why Arnold Schwarzenegger had that period where he did a bunch of comedies back to back? To show people that he can play as characters that aren’t just a muscular military guy with a gun?

→ More replies (2)

44

u/Okrumbles 1d ago edited 1d ago

Sylvester Stallone has always been able to act! I still think First Blood's ending is a highly underrated piece of acting.

20

u/YesImKeithHernandez 1d ago

First Blood in general is underrated and is still incredibly poignant.

→ More replies (3)

21

u/MakeItHappenSergant 1d ago

First Blood and Rocky are both fantastic movies with sequels that forgot what the originals were about.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

143

u/MysticalMarsupial 1d ago

Not including Bryan Cranston in this is a crime on par with running a meth empire.

→ More replies (3)

57

u/Zombie_Cool 1d ago

Tom Hanks is another big one for this I think. Apparently he actually used to do a lot of comedy movies back in the 70's/80's but after starring as the gay lawyer in Philadelphia in the 90's his career did a complete 180 and from then on he pretty much only appeared in big-budget drama movies afterward.

22

u/RotundBananas 1d ago

A lot of it had to do with his look as well. He used to play th young, charismatic, loveable goofball in romantic comedies.

Thet becomes harder when you aren't as young anymore.

And even in those esrly films it was clear the man had RANGE.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

27

u/shewy92 1d ago

Adam Sandler in Click too, it's not a dramatic movie until the end. But he nailed it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (44)

713

u/Cheeseish 1d ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/3o6Zt0eY7PwD1Nvb4A
South Park was criticized for having a super simplistic art style so they made the Canadians even simpler

56

u/That1pansexualkaiju 1d ago

Was wondering about this for the longest time so thank you

111

u/Salvius 1d ago

The Terrance and Phillip show was specifically them responding to critics, "Oh, you think South Park is nothing but bad animation and fart jokes? No, no, this is nothing but bad animation and fart jokes."

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

238

u/profilename99 1d ago

Never Rent From Cindy (ft. Cindy)

Two musicians got illegally evicted so they made a music video exposing all their landlady’s crimes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_70ISq4l7-c

97

u/Lv_InSaNe_vL 1d ago

MGMT was made off a bet too. The story goes that the guys were complaining about how dumb pop music is and how easy it is to make so someone said "okay then you do it" and they made electric feel haha

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (7)

404

u/[deleted] 1d ago edited 1d ago

[deleted]

210

u/Time_Traveling_Idiot 1d ago

hmmmm, I kinda see the resemblance.

40

u/Gullible-Cup2294 1d ago

I'd rather have Farquaad

60

u/Top-Session-3131 1d ago

For all that he was basically a classist/racist piece of shit, Farquaad actually honored his word when it was given. Shrek's swamp was empty when he got back after handing Fiona over.

→ More replies (1)

67

u/Turbulent-Prior-2253 1d ago

Farquadd is obviously a slight at Eisner. They literally named the villain Lord Fuckwad.

47

u/Deely_Boppers 1d ago

Also, this example really doesn’t prove the haters wrong.

Katzenburg was extremely talented, and was heir-apparent to the Disney empire. He got fired because he was petty and vindictive. Robin Williams refused to work with Disney over the way Katzenburg treated him, going so far as to mention it in his awards speech for Aladdin. He also drove a lot of their top internal talent away.

Shrek just proves Eisner was right. He was talented, petulant, and a pain in the ass.

20

u/rhino36-dropout 1d ago

And apparently, the people making Shrek were practically a B-Team, people sent on Shrek as punishment (cause the prestige project for Dreamworks at the time was Prince of Egypt. It bombed.)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

2.4k

u/talking_joke 1d ago

Sony Picture's Into The Spiderverse

Right after the disaster that was the Emoji Movie, the very next year, they decided to lock in and create one of the most revolutionary modern day animated films of all time that set new standards among audiences and also in the animated film industry.

Which also not only resulted in Sony Pictures making their most iconic comeback, but also winning and stealing the spotlight on the Oscars Best Animated Feature back in 2019

501

u/Skullface95 1d ago

I remember when Wreck it Ralph breaks the internet came out Disney was so sure they'd win they made the dvd store display with the Animated film of the Year award plastered all over them, only to lose to Spider-Man Into the Spider-verse

165

u/Draken1870 1d ago

Still haven’t finished more than a third of that film. First is amazing and watched too many, it’s such a basic cash grab and even in that first third I’ve seen ruins the message of the first movie.

While me and my pal saw spiderverse on its last cinema day as a thing to do and were blown away! No comparison.

78

u/StarsForget 1d ago

If nothing else watch the two Disney Princess scenes, they're quite clever (even if the "Vanellope introduces royals to comfortable loungewear" is also a blatant marketing push for Disney-themed clothes.)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

64

u/Traegs_ 1d ago

decided to lock in

Development of Into the Spider-verse was rough. Just go watch the original first trailer. It paints a different story where Miles is already an established Spider-Man in his universe in the beginning of the movie. They pivoted quite late into making it an origin story for him. Knowing this, you can see some scenes later in the movie that feel repurposed instead of rewritten, like Miles' Dad doesn't seem to question or acknowledge that there's a new Spider-Man after the original one died.

→ More replies (1)

392

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

244

u/talking_joke 1d ago

Mitchell VS The Machines and Kpop Demon Hunters up there with the current Spiderverse duology as well

115

u/Weird_Candle_1855 1d ago

Mitchells vs The Machines mentioned

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

56

u/sniper91 1d ago

Iirc Sony executives had no interest in meddling with this movie, which would help a lot for it to not be terrible

→ More replies (1)

153

u/Pitiful-Victory-2234 1d ago

Also Im pretty sure this was the one that made marvel fans accept miles as Spider-Man, his reception before thst was kinda mixed

91

u/ziggaby 1d ago

The movie totally improved him from the comics. The Miles Morales of comics pre-Spiderverse was pretty bland to me when I tried reading them originally. Compounding this was the fact that the MCU's spider man stole Miles' main differentiating thing--having a best friend helper (Ganke Lee vs Ned).

The movie improved him a lot.

18

u/DatBoiSaix 1d ago

Really ? I thought quite the contrary at the time when I read it, and it's an opinion I just don't understand. Miles' character in the original run was really original to me, he was a kid, even younger than most other heros that weren't sidekicks, where everything in his life went wrong and he still managed to be a hero despite the circumstances.
His uncle died insulting him, he wasn't the "right" spider-man, the previous spider-man once he came back was an asshole to him, and he still rose up to the challenge.
Once he got pulled into 616 though, I stopped reading because to me it became uninteresting, and that's without the whole stupid burger

→ More replies (7)

40

u/PowerPigion 1d ago

Waiting for the third one: 💀

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (26)

573

u/SoVeryTroublesome 1d ago edited 1d ago

Adriano Celentano, an Italian singer, released a song in fake-English, "Prisencolinensinainciusol" because he supposedly wanted to prove that songs in English went to the top of the Italian charts, simply because they were in English. So he wrote a song in fake-English and released it, it got to the top 5 in Italy, France and Belgium

Edit: I had its music chart location wrong.

251

u/Pako_Pako_ 1d ago

Kinda undermined by the fact that the song's is straight fire even if you know he's speaking gibberish tbh

95

u/Mikhail_Mengsk 1d ago

He can be absolutely insufferable, but he knows art. I begrudgingly consider him one of the best modern Italian artists.

24

u/Sol_Bjarnardottir 1d ago

god, really. Is a good italian artist, but his Ego is as big as his fame as the "Molleggiato". He's insufferable as a person.

43

u/RotundBananas 1d ago

The drums and trumpets in this banger are just

https://giphy.com/gifs/fV8GbAh4cmNl3cBKe9

→ More replies (1)

22

u/akatherder 1d ago

Here's the music video version, it's kinda fun https://youtu.be/fU-wH8SrFro

→ More replies (4)

38

u/Frenchitwist 1d ago

Except that despite the lyrics hurting my ears, the song is, in fact, a goddamn banger

→ More replies (7)

224

u/KalenCrux 1d ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/gKkcYSsnxvCpy
Ed, Edd n Eddy

The shows creator Danny Antonucci was known for making crude, gross and violent animated short for MTV at the time. He was approached by another show runner from Cartoon Network who basically dared Antonucci to make a show suitable for children. Antonucci took the challenge and thus, we got the Ed’s

53

u/Command0Dude 1d ago

The ending to that show still sticks with me. Somehow a crude, gross, violent kid's show has one of the most profound conclusions I've seen in any show for that demo.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/pajamakitten 1d ago

He was approached by another show runner from Cartoon Network who basically dared Antonucci to make a show suitable for children.

And God bless that man for accidentally helping create one of the best animated shows of the 90s.

29

u/StygianBlakc 1d ago

This was my favorite cartoon growing up. I learned my first word in English watching this show. God bless Danny Antonucci.

544

u/SpookieSkelly 1d ago

Marilyn Monroe's potato sack dress photos.

A columnist called her cheap and vulgar, and that her studio should invest more money into making her look better.

Marilyn responded by wearing a potato sack dress to show that she can wear literally anything and still look good.

61

u/BardicLasher 1d ago

Gods damn she DOES.

81

u/bankrobba 1d ago

That pic makes curly fries straight.

→ More replies (3)

238

u/XP0T 1d ago

Critics mocked the inclusion of a rainbow in the grim gothic world of Diablo III, with some jokingly comparing the new style to "My Little Pony".

So, just after launch, players discovered a hidden level, Whimsyshire, an over-the-top, pastel-colored landscape filled with:

• Happy little clouds and rainbows

• Smiling teddy bears and pink unicorns

• Health globes replaced by cupcakes

• Treasure chests shaped like presents

114

u/Ayotha 1d ago edited 1d ago

I love this one. All because people whined a small rainbow formed in a spot where a small waterfall fell on some rocks causing a bunch of mist to cause the small waterfall.

It was quite pathetic, and was deservedly mocked with whimsyshire and even rainbow diablo 3 shorts at blizzcons

41

u/Emergency_Basket_851 1d ago

Honestly, I think having shit like rainbows in a grimdark setting makes it darker...  It makes the setting much more believable and provides contrast. 

30

u/Relliks-D-Ban 1d ago

Juxtaposition. One of my favorite words. It truly elevates any kind of art.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/Dr_Wheuss 1d ago

Let's not forget the extremely gory deaths of said unicorns and bears.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

83

u/Disposable-Squid 1d ago

What exactly was Cawthon "proving wrong"? Because leaning into his designs being fucking creepy is kind of the opposite

→ More replies (3)

75

u/Forger_of_Days 1d ago

The album 14:59 by Sugar Ray was titled as such due to many critics claiming that the band was falling off and had used up their "15 minutes of fame" as the saying goes. This album went on to contain several of their biggest hits and continue to chart very well.

Also, on a similar note, Vol. 3: The Subliminal Verses was the third album by the band Slipknot. It was also the first album by said band to not feature a parental advisory sticker. This was at least in part due to lead singer Corey Taylor responding to claims that he relied on the use of profanity in his music. The album only features 2 instances of profanity.

28

u/UrinalCake777 1d ago edited 8h ago

Corey Taylor don't need to curse to sell records.

Well I do, so fuck him, and fuck you too.

→ More replies (6)

787

u/themoosic 1d ago

Garth Ennis wrote the Boys out of spite. Garth Ennis writes everything out of spite, because he hates superheroes and it’s the only thing people will hire him to write in the comic medium. I think the only thing he wrote with passion was Crossed, which is unfortunate because Crossed is edgy garbage

78

u/AxisW1 1d ago

He writes all of his war stuff with passion, and he certainly wrote punisher with passion. You can tell because they’re amazing.

The only parts of boys he wrote with passion are the military/politics stuff, when he gets more explicit into critique of the bush Cheney administration. Those parts are usually the more interesting.

I really don’t think he wrote crossed with passion; it was basically just an edgy experiment and he stopped writing it after the beginning.

→ More replies (3)

409

u/R0b0uteGuilliman 1d ago

Fans of the show love to glorify the comic… but the comic version of The Boys is actual trash. there is not a single aspect of the story that has some deep message outside of shock value, and the author fucking hating superheroes. That’s all the comic is a hate letter to superheroes.

265

u/demonsdencollective 1d ago

Sometimes I mentally slip into toxicity and start hating on everyone and everything. Then I remember how fucking dogshit The Boys is and correct myself to be more open minded and positive again before I start ruining the things I'm passionate about too.

158

u/Motivated-Chair 1d ago

Series so dogshit made you a better person.

63

u/demonsdencollective 1d ago

It's incredible. I hope it leads to some golden age throwback hero movies. Maybe we could call those types of movies Incredibles. Wait...

https://giphy.com/gifs/g0Ub5PgMoLqaNKBpDH

→ More replies (2)

73

u/chronoflect 1d ago

Had a similar realization when I was watching Toy Story 3 with friends and they asked me to stop being a cynical asshole, constantly pointing out "mistakes" and such.

Permanently stopped watching cinema sins after that.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

90

u/iamamotherclucker 1d ago

"The Boys" comics must be up there for "most larped pieces of media", because I keep seeing people talk about how it's so much better than the show and posting edits (that consist of the same five pages) only to never talk about anything actually in the comics

51

u/ThisIsFrigglish 1d ago

I once described it to a friend as

Look, it's Martian Manhunter - but he's a pervert! Look it's the X-Men - but it's a groomer cult! Look, it's a crude pastiche of Teen Titans/Young Justice/New Warriors - but they're r----ds who just rescue cats from trees and have ice cream parties! Look, it's Thor - but he's an alcoholic groper! Look, it's all the 'my superpower is money' heroes - but he's a degenerate rapist! All so Ennis' quartet of the most agonizingly late-90s Donut Steel edgelord OCs plus Simon Pegg have someone to gruesomely disassemble in full color with super-strength. Essential plot lines include a Superman expie going from "that varsity kid who used to shove Ennis into lockers, but with powers" to homicidal god-complex by mistake, a central protagonist killing a superpowered baby (this is presented positively), and a drooling sub-70 IQ crude parody of Cheney knocking the President unconscious in the secure White House bunker during 9/11. It's just a subway wizard shoving his grubby finger in your mouth because he saw you reading a comic book.

→ More replies (2)

69

u/jackofslayers 1d ago

"OH you like Aquaman? Well MY Aquaman is a piece of shit that does drugs. and also he gets killed by My edgy OC characters. OH you like the Flash? Well MY flash rapes people and also he gets killed by my edgy OC characters."

Literally just that on repeat.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)

36

u/WJMazepas 1d ago

He actually loves Superman

20

u/Hamblerger 1d ago

And wrote one of the best Superman stories out there.

→ More replies (6)

67

u/Okrumbles 1d ago

To be fair he doesn't hate ALL superheroes, he just hates most of them (he also specifically hates Captain America, considering his love for the military industrial complex I'm almost not surprised)

He likes Superman a lot! He's actually written some very good depictions of him. He's also a fan of Wonder Woman, Punisher, and Spider-Man but I don't know if he likes any more.

17

u/hambonedock 1d ago

he seemly like spiderman, didn't stop him of sorting the most ridiculous over the top one shot villain for that one issue

Also, I have red other stuff of pennies and he still write it with almost as much spite as they hero stuff, I don't. Know what is his life but you can't tell me there is a reason to hate THAT much James bond spy stuff on the daily basis

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (58)

140

u/VT_Squire 1d ago

Eddie Murphy told Richard Pryor he was doing a music album, and Richard hated on it, going so far as to wager $100,000 that Eddie couldn't do it. So Eddie called up Rick James and made Party all the Time, reaching #2 on Billboard's hot 100 in the US and selling over a million copies.

19

u/Sad_Manufacturer6352 1d ago

In his defense, the rest of Eddie’s music is not good.

For example, his music video that was voted 3rd worst by MTV viewers and retired from the channel.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

65

u/nopingmywayout 1d ago

Tunak Tunak Tun is such a banger, and the music video is such cheesy fun. It’s like watching your friends’ dads get down at a party. Man, now I gotta rewatch it!

→ More replies (2)

61

u/justhereforhides 1d ago edited 1d ago

The Straight Story was David Lynch making a mainstream family-friendly Disney movie to show he could. It's just as good as the rest of his other works and was unsurprisingly his only G-rated movie.

69

u/killchopdeluxe666 1d ago

Scott Cawthon, despite being kind of a weird guy, has honestly a super unique art style. I would not call myself a fan, and I would honestly say I don't really like FNAF much at all, but some of his designs are just so fucking crazy that its hard not to respect the craftsmanship at least a little (and then you remember that screenshot is from a game where a robotic coffee pot travels through an abandoned dystopian factory laden with questionable christian imagery to rescue a fetus being used as a scientific specimen).

34

u/Conte_Von_13 1d ago

Scott has 2 key features: 1. Cannot model humans 2. Goes NUTS on anything sci-fi

→ More replies (2)

373

u/Coherently-Rambling 1d ago

Inverted?

270

u/Coherently-Rambling 1d ago

179

u/DoctoreCRZ 1d ago

It's cute And surprisingly well done, I could see it in an independent animated series.

21

u/Perfect_Currency_250 1d ago

Forreal though. The lighting hitting the eyes from two different directions is quirky and cute.

→ More replies (3)

114

u/Miserable_Mail_5741 1d ago

I like how they say "recruit" as if it's some ploy to get people to join a cult and not just... Encouraging people to draw instead of typing words to output an image based on other people's work. 

→ More replies (3)

39

u/Tight_Grapefruit5280 1d ago

"Wait, people actually like me? Maybe Human art isn't so bad"

→ More replies (5)

123

u/estheredna 1d ago

Kinda indirectly fits...
The US was deeply isolationist in 1940. Joe Simon and Jack Kirby wrote a character designed to combat American apathy. Publishing explicitly anti-Hitler literature was a creative and financial gamble. And they did get hate about it, but mostly it was very popular. It actually helped move the needle on public opinion.

Joe Simon's father was a Jewish immigrant from Russia, and Jack Kirby's parents were Austrian Jewish immigrants.

30

u/soulreaverdan 23h ago

This dovetails into my favorite story about Jack Kirby.

“…Jack took a call. A voice on the other end said, ‘There are three of us down here in the lobby. We want to see the guy who does this disgusting comic book and show him what real Nazis would do to his Captain America’. To the horror of others in the office, Kirby rolled up his sleeves and headed downstairs. The callers, however, were gone by the time he arrived.” -Jack Kirby: King of Comics biography by Mark Evanier

→ More replies (1)

303

u/X_Ender_X 1d ago edited 1d ago

My friends and I found tunak tunak on the internet when we were in high school years and years ago. I've never ever ever ever ever heard anybody else ever mentioned it until now. This is hilarious to me.

Edit: I just went down a rabbit hole. This guy was convicted in a human trafficking case. Fuckem.

111

u/Good_Background_243 1d ago

For me it started with a video about where all the WoW dances came from - the Dranae male dances the Tunak Tunak Tun.

From there it was down a rabbit hole

23

u/X_Ender_X 1d ago

HOLY SHIT I NEVER MADE THE CONNECTION!!!!!

23

u/Good_Background_243 1d ago

It was a 'huh, neat' moment for me back in the day too.

...17 years ago, I feel old. https://youtu.be/2risjiYeWlM?si=h3hs6gCyODKTVpiP

I swear I remember it having more pixels though.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/GVmG 1d ago

similar story here, it was a meme in an old small community I was in between me and like six other people tops lmao

→ More replies (18)

113

u/DondyTrap2007 1d ago

I see FNaF more as Scott using the haters to his advantage

"My models look creepy? Well let's do something creepy then!" Instead of actually trying to prove them wrong

44

u/Pervius94 1d ago

Yeah. It's like, the opposite of proving haters wrong. People criticized his animatronics looked creepy as hell, and he used that feedback to his advantage. Proving the criticism right by just cranking up the creep and changing the genre to use that to his advantage.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/Illustrious-Set-7907 1d ago

Yeah that one seemed like "the haters have a point. I should switch genres" 

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

59

u/LovelyLuna32684 1d ago

Kingdom is a great story, though the picture you used is from it's kinda sorta sequel JSA storyline Thy kingdom come, which has KC Superman end up in the mainline DC earth and temporarily joining the JSA

110

u/bior1993 1d ago

Handful of famous creators in software come to mind.

Garry Newman (of Garry's Mod; Rust fame) had at least one blog post about how his early commitment to the development of GMod was greatly spurred by a rival mod and creator that was being developed in parallel. CBA to look up the post if it even exists anymore but I believe he said the project succeeded out of spite.

John Carmack (Wolfenstein 3D; Doom; Quake; Facebook VR) is a pretty mellow guy nowadays in his rarer public appearances. But he maintains strong opinions and in earlier career established public rivalries with others. Including I wanna say the creator of the Build engine (Duke 3D; Blood). Silverman?

Then there's Linus Torvalds (Linux) who's had years (decades?) long public arguments about OS design fundamentals which I couldn't really begin to cover for lack of understanding. But I'm pretty sure his influence speaks for itself.

All three strike me as a fairly distinct Type of Guy.

24

u/1UpBebopYT 1d ago

Carmack highly respected Ken Silverman. Here's an interview from 1997 where he listed Ken as one of the smartest people in the industry - https://advsys.net/ken/carmken.htm

Carmack was always pretty mellow and gave everyone their praises - it's how he recruited people like Abrash and such. Romero is the one that has mellowed A LOT. Like a SHIT ton. Here's a story where he printed out another programmers photos, hanged them in the office, and encouraged the office to walk by and stab them every day.

"Romero stapled Bill’s picture to the chair, then grabbed a steak knife from the drawer. It was time for revenge." - Masters of Doom.

The person in this story is Rebecca Heineman, a legendary programmer who was great friends with Carmack, but Romero hated and still Romero has popped up every now and then to sort of diminish their programming stature. Kinda weird.

→ More replies (3)

44

u/Swaibero 1d ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/YcMs3OGd89Pxu
Community season 3 episode 1 was a song including lines like “we’re gonna get more calm and normal”, “we’re gonna stand holding hands in a brand new land far away from the borderline”, and “we’re gonna seem like a mainstream dream and appeal to all mankind”. Dan Harmon wrote it in response to the studio exec’s demands for the show’s direction.

85

u/weerdbuttstuff 1d ago

Doesn't Five Nights at Freddy's prove the haters right? Like the aesthetics were mismatched after all?

→ More replies (4)

168

u/Eran-of-Arcadia 1d ago

Someone: "You can't write a compelling fantasy series with some random premise like . . . Pokémon meets the Lost Roman Legion!"

Jim Butcher: "Bet."

85

u/supremo92 1d ago

Codex Alera is the name of the book series.

Tbh, the challenger was a fool because they accidentally chose two things that sounds extremely compelling together.

→ More replies (3)

29

u/Plannercat 1d ago

He learned after the success of the Dresden Files (he intentionally made the first book out of nothing but cliches and thought it would fail)

25

u/Chris22533 1d ago

He wrote it to prove his creative writing teacher wrong and accidentally proved her right.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (16)

35

u/Zapdos_Molquatro 1d ago

Hemingway wrote Old Man and the Sea because he was angry at bad reviews for his previous book. 

→ More replies (1)

34

u/UrlacherButkus 1d ago

The aura in th kingdom come art style 🔥

→ More replies (2)

35

u/SorryForMyEnglish 1d ago

In Snatch (2000), Brad Pitt speaks with an almost unintelligible accent. It's said that Guy Ritchie did this in response to critics, especially American ones, who complained that the accents in his previous film, Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels (1998), were too hard to understand.

https://giphy.com/gifs/124qHhp74Mg9ri

→ More replies (1)

32

u/DangerMacAwesome 1d ago

Supposedly, Adriano Celentano wrote a song just to prove he could make something that would chart even if it was nonsense. Not 100% sure it fits, but it sprang to mind. Plus it's a banger.

From Wikipedia here

Prisencolinensinainciusol is a song composed by the Italian singer Adriano Celentano, and performed by Celentano and his wife Claudia Mori. It was released as a single in 1972. Both the name of the song and its lyrics are gibberish, but are intended to represent what American English sounds like to people who do not understand English. The song charted in several European countries.

→ More replies (7)

274

u/ProfIanHadrian 1d ago edited 1d ago

The Avatar sequels. People said the first one would never make its budget back. Then they said he could never do it twice. The third one less so, but it still made bank on its gargantuan budget for a third time in a row.

63

u/rdhavoc5 1d ago

"I stare out of my window again"

182

u/Renonthehilltop 1d ago

I feel like people didnt doubt its ability to make money but more often just lauded its lack of cultural staying power

68

u/Bauld_Man 1d ago

Avatar just completely blows my mind. It continually blows out every single box office record, but I have never heard it spoken about except to occasionally riff on it. The only thing I know about the sequel is that the most racist man alive gets a native gf, or something, and that it also broke every box office record. Again.

28

u/Ok-Fisherman334 1d ago

I mean… technically he’s not the most racist man alive

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (8)

118

u/Informal_Dude 1d ago

Eminem released a whole ass album about this

→ More replies (5)

120

u/Coherently-Rambling 1d ago

Marilyn Monroe did a photoshoot wearing a potato sack that’s been converted in a dress.

This was either done in response to the claim that she only looks good because she has expensive clothes, or to a fashion critic insulting one of her dresses.

41

u/Terminal_Insomnia_ 1d ago

Goes to show the importance of good tailoring. I'm about to start making my own clothes because I'm tired of off-the-shelf clothes, both in terms of fit and materials.

→ More replies (2)

35

u/JeffButChinese 1d ago

I just watched a video with Akon talking about sticking his neck out to Interscope Records on behalf of Lady Gaga.

Akon's label, KonLive, is a joint venture to have Akon help develop artists under the Interscope umbrella. Gaga was signed to it in 2007 and was mainly writing songs for other artists. Akon loved her voice on reference tracks and her ability as an artist. Gaga recorded Just Dance, and Akon sent it to head of Interscope Jimmy Iovine. Jimmy liked the track and wanted to give it to The Pussycat Dolls.

Akon apparently passionately pleaded about how impressive Gaga was and bet his label on her success. Saying something like "The Pussycat Dolls are already all-stars, this is the kind of track that creates a new all-star." Jimmy said okay let's do it, and the rest is history.

33

u/Kooky_Celebration_42 1d ago

Tunak Tunak Tun was so popular, Blizzard used his dance as the dance the Male Dranei did when they were introduced in WoW's first expansion, The Burning Crusade in 2007

→ More replies (1)

61

u/nicksey144 1d ago

Beyonce's Cowboy Carter

From Wikipedia: "In a statement accompanying the release of her eight studio album, the country-rooted Cowboy Carter, in 2024, Beyoncé made reference to an experience of exclusion from the country music establishment that inspired her to delve deeper into the genre and formed the impetus for the album; this was widely believed to refer to the "Daddy Lessons" performance at the CMAs.[26][27] The album's lyrics further invoke this controversy, as she sings on opening track "Ameriican Requiem": "Used to say I spoke 'too country' / Then the rejection came, said I wasn’t country 'nough".[28]"

→ More replies (2)

48

u/brionneverysexy 1d ago edited 1d ago

The Meat Puppets started as a hardcore punk band. The hard core punk scene rejected them for having long hair and not dressing the right way so they got spit on and bottles thrown at them. The Meat Puppets then decided hardcore punk fans suck and they were going to make country music. Their version of country was not traditional but they went on to become pretty successful

73

u/TheKingsPride 1d ago

Punks booing a band for not conforming to their ideals and norms is a really funny bit of situational irony

31

u/Lakan-Tangkan-1337 1d ago edited 1d ago

"Punk ain’t no religious cult

Punk means thinking for yourself

You ain’t hardcore when you spike your hair

When a jock still lives inside your head." - Jello Biafra

Basically, the less punk a band looks, the more punk they actually were.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

112

u/wyrmiam 1d ago

The fnaf one is quite literally proving the critics right

→ More replies (6)

21

u/OHHHCRUD_ 1d ago

Rush - 2112

After the band’s third album, Caress of Steel, the band went on what they called the ‘down the tubes’ tour. Caress of Steel had no hits for them and received very mixed critical acclaim due to its very ‘out there’ high fantasy theming and intense conceptual vibe. Their label gave them an ultimatum, record an album with hits or they’d be dropped. What did they do ?? Recorded another insane concept album, with the titular first track being 20 minutes long. The band refused to do something that wasn’t true to themselves. The album ended up being one of their most well-received, ever.

40

u/motion360 1d ago

Nickelodeon's "Splat" era

Before that, it was the "Silver Ball" era which was not well received among target audience (aka children) and the channel became the butt of the joke among children-oriented channels.

That's when two people (whom I forgot their names) stepped in & gave the channel a total makeover, replacing the silver ball with the shapeshifting orange splat. The reaction from execs were less than pleasant. They even disapproved the channel's new theme song. Despite this, the two pushed through & Nickelodeon became the top channel for children.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Negative_Prize1587 1d ago

Didnt FNAF prove the haters right when his art style for a kids game fit perfectly for a horror game?

18

u/Dry-Principle2627 1d ago

Green eggs and ham was a result of a bet that dr seuss couldn't write a poem With a límites use of words.

→ More replies (3)