r/AusLegal • • 19h ago

QLD Shine Lawyers. QSuper class action. Up to their old tricks.

193 Upvotes

Can I start by saying: My expectations were low, and I'm still disappointed.

For those unaware, Shine Lawyers took on QSuper and won a $67,000,000 payout for their clients. Of which they claimed a whopping $30,990,000 in legal fees. They later sent emails to the clients advising them that upon review, they were no longer eligible for payment due to some loophole they found (myself included).

I never expected to get anything. But this is pattern behaviour from Shine Lawyers where they claim exorbitant legal fees because the class action requires "so many" resources. When they launch the class action they will claim to be representing 10k to 100k+ clients. When the reality is that AFTER the payout is received they pull the rug out and the reality is far fewer resources were required because they already knew that only a handful of QSuper clients were actually effected.

If you want more information about Shine Lawyers being deceitful just research previous class actions they took on. They are profiting massively off everyday people, getting massive payouts and finding ways to keep most of the money for themselves. Afterwards, most clients found the repayment process was lengthy, confusing and often advised they were no longer eligible due to some loophole.

2025 Stolen Wages Class Action, Western Australia. $180,000,000 settlement. $42,500,000 paid to lawyers.

2022 Pelvic Mesh Class Action, vs Johnson and Johnson. $300,000,000 settlement. $78,000,000 paid to lawyers.

Let me know what you think. Are these legal fees justified?


r/AusLegal • • 1h ago

VIC Foreign property manager unlawfully entering, taking my things and harassing us :(

Thumbnail
• Upvotes

r/AusLegal • • 16h ago

WA Sperm donation and can responsibilities be contracted out?

71 Upvotes

My friend, male, Australian, 50, Became friends with her but isn't interested romantically or other.

She approached him about donating his sperm. He has agreed, with the provision that he carrys no financial or parental responsibility (he has been pretty much single his whole life). She has agreed and said she'd draft a contract as such.

I however believe that he may still end up responsible, and in Australia, you can't out-contact responsibility.

Is my mate about to get baby trapped?


r/AusLegal • • 37m ago

QLD Testamentary trust or regular will - confused .

• Upvotes

Please explain like I’m 5, I’m overwhelmed and whilst I know I need a lawyer to draw up my will I want to have a clearer idea before I go in and not be ‘sold’ something.

My children are 13&14. I want to leave everything to them. They can have it at 18.
They have a parent who lives overseas who is independently very wealthy. Doesn’t have care currently and shouldn’t need it for their care.
I will nominate a legal guardian here in Australia for them.

I have a PPOR, some super, ETF’s & HISA.
If the other parent continues to pay child support then anything I leave will be for the children at 18 years old. If he doesn’t their care costs can come from the estate.

Children don’t wish to go live with Father and I’m unsure if he would even try fight for that. I don’t want him to have access to their funds.
Would like to keep PPOR and it not be sold (so guardian can reside there with them)

I will nominate a family friend as the trustee - but do I need to add terms to make sure it’s handled appropriately?

It feels so complicated that I’m currently doing nothing and just hoping I don’t pass until at least the oldest is 18. I know it’s foolish.

Doubly confused as I thought testamentary trust was the way forward but I think I’ve read that’s been hit by the tax changes , so is it even worth it now?


r/AusLegal • • 21h ago

ACT Employer asking me to pay back 1 week of wages to be withheld due to improper notice.

30 Upvotes

Hi I have received an invoice from a former employer for me to pay them back 1 week of wages due to providing improper notice. This is not unearned wages, but rather a penalty for not serving the notice period

The reasoning for me not giving the full notice is because I had a close family member who past away. I worked with them to provide the best handover I could given my circumstances and partially worked out my notice period.

Would I have an argument that this is unreasonable deduction given my circumstances and the effort I made during my notice period under fair work?


r/AusLegal • • 12h ago

AUS question on retail donations as a retail worker

2 Upvotes

Hey guys!,

I am an employee at a large retail business and was wondering on what i can do about incentive donations apart of a current collaboration. we have a daily target but it’s hard sometimes to reach due to the state of the economy ( whole different conversation 😓). Anyways i have a manager who has repeatedly has warned me that if im not making enough of a contribution ( trust me i ask each person) that i can get hours cut. now i am a law student and have basic knowledge on employment law but surely they cannot cut back hours or make me feel bad for not being able to meet my targets right ?.

any help would be appreciated!!


r/AusLegal • • 21h ago

NSW Need this invoice explained like I’m 5 years old

9 Upvotes

Unfortunately can’t post a photo but recently rented a car from Hertz. $500 deposit for utility. I was told I’d get that deposit back. But upon receipt, refund to card will only be $410. The only thing I can see on invoice that makes up that $90 is GST. Should that not be included in the original price of the car and not the deposit?
Forgive me if I’m so wrong with this, first time hiring a car.

Pasted invoice :

RENTAL CHARGES
DAYS 8 @ 44.98 HOURS 2 @ 22.49 Discounts, Promos, & Adjustments 359.84 ga
44.98 ga
-80.96 ga
SUBTOTAL 323.86 ga

Maximum Damage Waiver 474.57 ga
Vehicle Rego Recovery 76.50 g
Administrative Recovery 27.95 g
GST @ 10% 90.29
TOTAL CHARGES $ 993.17

Deposit Paid: -1403.17
Refund VIS 4816*8514 410.00
Amount Due: 0.00

Total Km Driven: 491
Fuel Out: 8/8
Fuel In: 8/8
Fuel Charged: 0.00

KEY g Subject to GST
c Subject to Location Fee
a Subject to Administration Fee
l Subject to Location Service Charge
THIS IS A SUMMARY OF YOUR CHARGES. THE AMOUN


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

VIC My landlord owes me ~$800 in sales inspection compensation payments, is withhold that amount of rent a legal way to force them to pay?

11 Upvotes

Over the last 10 weeks or so we've had ~20 sales inspections at our rental properly which has been put on the market and since taken off the market. We cleaned each time to the level they requested and organised to be home to let them in etc.

In Victoria at least the law states the renter is entitled to $30 or half a day's rent in compensation, whichever is more. ​For us this equates to about $800.

The real estate was up front about all this but now that the house has been taken off the market and we have enquired about the payment via email they are ignoring us.

We are also moving out of the rental in a few weeks since we needed a more ​assured living situation and not the possibility of the house being sold and then receiving our 3 months notice to vacate afterwards.

Our final (partial) monthly rent payment is due this week coming and we are considering paying the rent amount minus the amount they owe us since they are ignoring our emails. Would this be legal on our behalf?

If not, what other course of action can we take?

edit: title should probably say "real estate agent" owes me rather than "landlord"


r/AusLegal • • 12h ago

VIC Will I get a red light ticket?

0 Upvotes

I know this is entirely my fault, I was driving while I was stressed. I turned right here:

https://www.google.com/maps/@-37.8508258,144.9842441,17a,90y,3.15h,87.93t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1smHzkKFtb70cad92eYP7iFQ!2e0!6shttps:%2F%2Fstreetviewpixels-pa.clients6.google.com%2Fv1%2Fthumbnail%3Fcb_client%3Dmaps_sv.tactile%26w%3D900%26h%3D600%26pitch%3D2.0656507242717908%26panoid%3DmHzkKFtb70cad92eYP7iFQ%26yaw%3D3.1527634011682473!7i16384!8i8192?entry=ttu&g_ep=EgoyMDI2MTAxMy4wIKXMDSoASAFQAw%3D%3D

There is a red light camera there, but on the other side. I didn't notice being flashed, but it was daytime. I don't really remember how it happened. I remember as I was in the middle of the road giving way, I noticed the traffic light was green, but there was a red arrow. I didn't turn right until there was a green arrow. So I guess maybe I somehow didn't notice the red arrow at first, and assumed it was a normal right turn.


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

AUS Getting Child Support Arrears

12 Upvotes

My ex owes me tens of thousands in child support, and the CSA told me their hands are tied. His assets are all in someone else’s name and he’s walked away from his job. There's a departure prohibition order but he never leaves the country, so it’s not pushing him to pay a cent. Is there anything else I can do within the legal system to pressure him into paying? It’s the principle of it that gets me.

Update - Thanks for the warnings that it could cost me more than I’d recover, but I’m not fussed. I’ve got the money to spend and he owes me a lot. Reckon a bit of pressure will get him to pay up.


r/AusLegal • • 15h ago

AUS Interstate licence transfer

0 Upvotes

Hi, I’m looking at moving interstate from QLD to WA. I am currently on a good behaviour period, still have 9 months left on it. Do you know if I am able to attain a WA license or does any of that carry over?


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

NSW Startup contract

5 Upvotes

I’ve been invited to work on a startup. The person behind it is promising equity and pay in the next 6-12 months.

I believe they think it’s going to be successful. it’s in a saturated market so they could be profitable if they get the marketing right but it could be dead in 6 months

My question is if I do work is there a way to structure a contract such that I would be considered a secured creditor if it implodes - like we agree on an hourly rate and if it goes pear shaped I’m considered as a creditor.

I should say from what I’ve seen it’s 50/50 and the guy was selling the opportunity not the business plan so there’s already red flags


r/AusLegal • • 9h ago

QLD Court appeal for hardship

0 Upvotes

Hello all, I am just seeking out some advice hopefully from those who might understand the case well. One of my parents has been on good behaviour for about a week, but has had the misfortune of receiving a new officer issued infringement ticket for performing a u-turn in an otherwise not allowed section. Seeing that the only option he has if he outrightly accepts the ticket is a special hardship order which will likely impose an out-of-work driving ban, he is debating the possibility of making a court appeal to have a hearing by a magistrate about how this infringement will throw his family’s life in hardship should it go in his traffic record.

About my parent: Aged 65, with stay at home wife and a 7 year old child, is the sole earner in the household. His only job of UberX is reliant on his eligibility to drive. He currently services all the living bills of the household including a $1000+ per week mortgage repayment of approximately $450k remaining. He’s also the only licensed driver that can do grocery runs and shopping for everyday necessities. Out of the sheer amount of driving he performs, unfortunately he has just about racked up 12 points for the past 3 years and has been on good behaviour for a week until now. As my parent is a first gen immigrant of old age, his English speaking skills aren’t exactly suited for a professional workplace or manual labour, besides jobs as the likes of ridesharing.

Now what we would like to know is that if this is something that can be freshly presented to a court will all supporting documents of the work, payslips, bank statements, family dependency, outstanding loans and signed affidavits to back his circumstantial claims. And if this court appearance where he assumes guilty and remorseful of the infringement, is something that can produce a result where this infringement can be served without a driving ban or recording demerit points, and more importantly without risking the possibility of recording a criminal conviction/further fines.

All inputs are very appreciated!


r/AusLegal • • 22h ago

VIC Cousin not sure whether to pursue lawyers following a split with his fiancée - VIC Australia

1 Upvotes

My cousin, 36m, Location: Victoria, recently separated with his partner after about three years together. They have a two-year-old child and are currently sharing custody with her (nothing in writing, it’s basically whenever the mum wants her looked after he will go and get the daughter, 2-4 nights a week depending) - they both also have kids from previous relationships. Throughout the relationship Her kids aged 5&8 stayed at their house 50/50 (shared with the other father) my cousins kids (10-17) had to stay at my grandmas house until they got a big enough house for the whole family.

My cousin has a sole trader carpentry business (since before they met) His ex is tech savvy and he’s not so when they got together she took over all of his business communications and finances. She also works and her wage went into her dad’s account for “savings”. His business income got paid into her account and it went toward household/living expenses (including family holidays for everyone) and he received an allowance out of it.

She recently (6 months ago) bought a house in her name for about 1million dollars. This was the dream family home so everyone could move in (his and her kids) He renovated the entire place including borrowing $20,000 dollars to renovate that house and did unpaid labour. She then kicked him out and asked for a separation.

He’s now left with that $20,000 debt and no assets. He doesn’t want to pursue anything if it’s just going to be eaten up by lawyers (he honestly still loves her and doesn’t really want to pursue anything at all) but if there’s a case there he doesn’t want to just walk away with nothing either… His only motivation is to ensure he can look after his kids moving forward.

Not asking for promises just a rough idea whether he has any rights here and whether it’s worth pursuing?


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

VIC [VIC] Does an estate's executor/trustee have a legal obligation to inform the parents/guardians of a minor who has been left an inheritance under trust?

8 Upvotes

It's been 8 months since grant of probate, a copy of the will has been seen (via probate records, unbeknownst to executor) and a minor (12yo) has been left a modest inheritance under trust, until age 25.

Executor and trustee named in the will is a sibling of the deceased, who has been known to be very manipulative and deceptive in the past, and relations are.. strained, to put it mildly. Neither the minor nor their parents have been told about the inheritance.

What are the options for the parents in this situation? How concerned should they be about not being informed? And what options are there to protect the child's inheritance from everyone involved (the parents would prefer independent oversight - no sole access by either the executor or themselves), as well as from legal/admin fees eating most of it away?


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

VIC Separation

0 Upvotes

My husband and I have been arguing for so long now....

I just can't do it anymore.

I do not work (illness) awaiting disability pension and super. No savings. The best I could do for now for accommodation would be shared in somebody's house.

My husband and I own a business. I am worried he will lock me out accounts etc if I leave.

Will Centrelink help at all in a desperate situation?

Thanks all just need to know what i can do.


r/AusLegal • • 17h ago

VIC Family friend passed more than a year ago but property still not sold

0 Upvotes

I found out that some of my friend’s asset were not handled as she had told me before her passing. When I query with the lawyer, her response was that it’s not in her notes, I then ask about the property and she said it was to be sold in Feb. it’s Oct now. Concerned dodgy lawyer/executor behaviour. Can I ask to see the will? I don’t trust this lawyer.


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

VIC Title transfer

1 Upvotes

My grandma’s house was left to my mum and uncle. Mum died 5 years ago and I haven’t yet got around to transferring mum’s half into my name (I was the sole beneficiary of mum’s estate). Who do I get to do this? A conveyancer or a lawyer? And what is it likely to cost? A few hundred? A couple of thousand? Thanks.


r/AusLegal • • 22h ago

NSW NSW Employment Law – Was I incorrectly advised that domestic violence leave isn't protected from discrimination?

0 Upvotes

NSW – Employment law, domestic violence leave, discrimination and settlement deed

I'm hoping someone familiar with NSW employment and discrimination law can clarify whether I may have received incorrect advice before signing a settlement deed.

I was employed by a NSW local government organisation. During my employment, I experienced domestic violence and accessed DV leave and other workplace supports.

During this period, my employer became involved in matters concerning my former partner, including communicating with him and police. I have documentary evidence that raises serious concerns about how these interactions occurred and whether my personal circumstances were used against me.

There was also an existing workplace conflict involving a senior employee against whom I had been a named witness in a Code of Conduct matter. I believe there is evidence suggesting that subsequent actions against me may have been retaliatory.

I ultimately sustained an accepted compensable psychological injury arising from workplace circumstances.

I was subsequently dismissed following a separate workplace investigation, despite concerns about the investigation process and my medically certified capacity at the time.

During settlement negotiations relating to my dismissal, my employer specifically sought a release from potential discrimination proceedings, among other claims.

I objected to this provision because I believed I may have grounds for a discrimination or victimisation claim arising from my treatment while experiencing domestic violence, accessing DV leave and participating in protected workplace processes.

However, my representative advised that I did not have a discrimination case and indicated that DV leave was not protected in the way I understood it to be.

I relied on that advice and ultimately signed the deed.

Recently, I discussed the circumstances with a senior manager from another government organisation who has extensive experience representing employers in the NSW Industrial Relations Commission. Their reaction was quite different. They suggested that, based on what I described, my former employer could have had significant concerns about potential discrimination proceedings.

I'm now trying to understand whether these are simply different legal interpretations or whether I may have been incorrectly advised.

My questions are:

  1. In NSW, are employees protected from adverse treatment connected with experiencing domestic violence or accessing domestic violence leave, even if domestic violence itself is not expressly listed as a protected attribute under particular discrimination legislation?

  2. Could retaliation connected with being a witness in an internal Code of Conduct investigation potentially give rise to a separate claim?

  3. Is there a meaningful legal distinction between unlawful discrimination, victimisation, adverse action and breaches of workplace leave protections in this context?

  4. If a representative incorrectly advises someone that no such claim exists, and that advice influences their decision to sign a broad release, are there any avenues to challenge the deed or seek advice about the representation?

I'm not asking anyone to determine whether I have a case based on a Reddit post. I'm particularly interested in understanding which legislation and protections may have applied, and whether the advice I received was legally sound.

I appreciate that signing a deed complicates matters. I'm simply trying to establish whether I made an informed decision based on accurate advice.

Thanks in advance.


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

SA Family law and posessions

33 Upvotes

My ex (married 8y) has stayed in our family home and basically has most of our household items.

I have finally found a rental and said I was going to collect things, and he is saying no to a bunch of stuff that is absolutely mine; gardening items I bought, gym equipment I bought and use, wool carpets/mats, some irrigation stuff.

He is saying he's keeping it.

We are mediating Monday, but in general none of these items are high value, some of them were actual gifts to me, and all of them I purchased.

Controlling/vindictive behaviour aside (he knows I can't afford to replace any of it), is this legal? I assume if I just take the stuff that's mine he can't really do anything about it.

I've literally left things because he and his sons use them, and always made sure things are fair, but this..... Feels like punishment for leaving.

Any tips?

I have a legal aid lawyer but funds are running out, my ex is running up a bill for me, so I can't hit her up for answers for small stuff sadly


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

NSW Case of man refused bail for magic mushrooms. What would his likely jail sentence be given the severity of the charges?

19 Upvotes

r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

NSW Driving woes

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

VIC Anyone have much experience with SAPSEs (serious adverse patient safety event)?

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I received a SAPSE report recently relating to a medical situation earlier in the year. It's basically a root cause analysis done by the hospital in Victoria for severe adverse patient safety events . It is meant to be transparent to prevent the event from happening again.

The report I received twists everything in such a way to make it sound like they did the right thing. I can point out several inaccuracies that make it seem like they were following a process and the mistake was basically within my own interpretation of the consent.

Is this normal? This whole thing has made me even angrier.


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

QLD [QLD] Boss is reversing on a verbal agreement

1 Upvotes

Seeking advice for a friend that doesn’t use reddit

My friend is an independent contractor that is facilitated through a 3rd party for subsidy reasons.

My friend and their boss had a verbal agreement that my friend would get paid for sick days and hours and usual days that were no longer needed

The boss has recently reversed this and has started saying this was never the agreement despite the boss having inspecting and “approving” timesheets.

As per the written contract that my friend and their boss have, her boss is responsible for approving any and all timesheets. The boss did not want to do this and has provided the details to my friend for them to approve themselves

Their boss has gone through time sheets going back to march and is trying to claim that there is wage theft totalling approximately $4000 despite the fact that it has been subsidised this whole time

Does my friend have any legal ground to not be liable for this?


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

VIC Casual applying for leave

3 Upvotes

Okay so. I work for one of the big groceries in Australia. I'm a casual but have worked there enough years to acquire long service leave of 7 weeks.

Now, I found a full time job in my area of studdy from university. Its a fixed term position however. Over 3 months long. I havent told the store yet. I don't want them to know because there have been some explosive reactions from management towards ex co-workers who left the store. I am aware as a casual my notification time can be whenever and so im using that to avoid being lashed at right now.

However.

Its generally known at my store that any time off over 3 months as a casual you need to put in for leave. Unpaid ofc as a casual. Pretty lucky my store changed its website recently so I can use that as an excuse for putting in late.

My question is. If I put in my leave as a casual. Can they deny it? Im considering that id put this as 'unpaid leave of absence' and not unpaid personal leave because absence leave is just that. I wont be available.

I'm aware I have an advantage of long service leave. Because I think if they refused my leave and ended up terminating me they'd have to pay me out my leave (at Christmas which ha. I dont think a retailer wants to do.) OR they can just wait out my absence and not have to pay me for the time I'm away.

The way I see it. It actually benefits the retailer to accept my leave right now. But im just wondering if there is any reason they wouldn't and what legal protection I may have.